Resolved
Resolved (by 3 votes to 2 with 1 abstention) not to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommendation, for the reasons set out in the Officer’s report (with delegated authority to Officers to make minor amendments to the conditions as drafted) , subject to: i. the planning conditions set out in the Officer’s report and amendment sheet; ii. delegated authority to Officers, in consultation with the Chair, Vice Chair and Spokes, to amend condition 4 to include both weight and time limit provisions for construction traffic in Salmon Lane ; iii. include an informative requesting inclusion of a lift to make the first floor accessible to all. A discussion ensued on ‘minded to’ reasons for refusal . Three reasons were considered by the Committee which ultimately resolved : Resolved (by 4 votes to 0 with 2 abstentions) to accept as a reason for refusal : 1. The proposal by virtue of its scale, massing, form, inappropriate materials and overall appearance would result in an overly dominant, stark and simplistic building form which would fail to successfully contrast with its immediate context and would therefore be out of character with its surroundings. As a result, less than substantial harm would result to the setting of surrounding heritage assets, including nearby listed buildings, buildings of local interest and the conservation area. There are no public benefits which would outweigh this harm. The proposal is therefore contrary to Cambridge Local Plan (2018) policies 55, 56, 57, 61, 62 and the NPPF (2023) paragraph 202 and Section 66 and 72 of the Planning (LBCA) (1990). Resolved (by 3 votes to 1 with 2 abstentions) not to accept as a reason for refusal : 2. The proposal fails to meet the principle of inclusive design, in particular of disabled people because of its failure to provide access to all parts of the building due to the absence of a lift to the first floor. The proposal is therefore contrary to Cambridge Local Plan (2018) policy 56 (criteria k) and 57 (criteria b). Resolved (by 3 votes to 0 with 3 abstentions) not to accept as a reason for refusal : 3. The proposed construction access to the site would result in undue harm to adjacent residential neighbours because of the constrained nature of Salmon Lane resulting in noise, vibration, dust and disturbance, which could not adequately be mitigated. The proposal is therefore contrary to Cambridge Local Plan (2018) policy 35. Resolved ( 4 votes to 0 with 2 abstentions ) to refuse the application contrary to the Officer recommendation for the following reason: The proposal by virtue of its scale, massing, form, inappropriate materials and overall appearance would result in an overly dominant, stark and simplistic building form which would fail to successfully contrast with its immediate context and would therefore be out of character with its surroundings. As a result, less than substantial harm would result to the setting of surrounding heritage assets, including nearby listed buildings, buildings of local interest and the conservation area. There are no public benefits which would outweigh this harm. The proposal is therefore contrary to Cambridge Local Plan (2018) policies 55, 56, 57, 61, 62 and the NPPF (2023) paragraph 202 and Section 66 and 72 of the Planning (LBCA) (1990).