Resolved
RESOLVED – That option 1 (to carry out the work to KCC standards with a City Council subsidy of £ 3,290) be approved.
Executive approved this item on Tuesday 19 April 2011. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
RESOLVED – That option 1 (to carry out the work to KCC standards with a City Council subsidy of £ 3,290) be approved.
Subject: KCC Agency Agreement – maintenance of the soft estate
Director/Head of Service: Head of Housing, Community Safety and Environmental Services
Decision Issues: These matters are within the authority of the Executive
Decision type: Non-key
Classification: This report is open to the public.
This report includes an annex containing confidential information and may be discussed without the press and public present.
CCC Ward(s): All
Summary: The city council has carried out maintenance of the soft estate for KCC for many years under an agency agreement. KCC have stated they wish to revise the method of payment for this work and reduce standards.
To Resolve That Option 1 (Carry out the work to KCC standards with a City Council subsidy of £3,290) be approved.
Next stage in process To advise KCC that the City Council will carry out grounds maintenance of the soft estate on behalf of the KCC for a further year at the rates offered.
SUPPORTING INFORMATION
1. Introduction
CCC has managed the soft estate on behalf of KCC for many years under an agency arrangement. This comprises grass cutting, hedge cutting, weed spraying etc of the highway. The most recent agreement with KCC in 2005 was for a period of 3 years, Thereafter it has been renewed annually. KCC wish to change the terms of this agreement.
2. Detail
CCC have until now invoiced KCC the cost of this work based on Serco’s tendered sums plus an additional 10% admin fee on all works with the exception of weed control. KCC recently asked for a 25% saving on these costs. Officers within Street Scene agreed reduced costs with Serco making a 26% saving and presented these to KCC for approval in October 2010.
On 4th February CCC received a letter from John Burr stating that KCC expected a 30% saving on previous costs.
On 21st February CCC received an email from Jacobs (KCC consultants) detailing the maximum payments KCC are prepared to pay based on what they consider to be an average value of the works within the county.
The net result is a 32% reduction in the amount CCC would receive compared to the start of 2010/11. CCC has offered a 31.2 %saving but this can only be achieved by reducing weed spraying to one treatment per annum and severely reducing the shrub maintenance.
The contract with Serco is an out-put specification whereas KCC have valued the work based on a frequency. For example amenity grass under the Serco contract would be maintained to a height of 50 mm throughout the year requiring cutting every 2 weeks in the growing season. KCC want 8 cuts per annum only.
Also Serco spray weeds twice a year – KCC are only willing to pay for the highway to be sprayed once. This would make a £31,000 saving for KCC but public dissatisfaction would be very high.
Carrying out grounds maintenance less frequently will mean the work will take longer when it is done. Also different equipment may be required as the machinery currently used may not be able to cope with taller grass etc. For this reason officers don’t consider it possible to achieve further reductions in contract price.
Serco have intimated that they would consider a claim against CCC for loss of profit, redundancy payments and early termination of equipment leases. However, the initial legal view is that there is no justification for a loss of profit claim because Clause 7.10 of the General contract Conditions states:
7.10The Parties confirm that there is no obligation on the Council to guarantee any
minimum value in the levels of Services or Jobs ordered throughout the Contract
Period.
Also TUPE would apply so redundancy payments would not be unnecessary. There may be a cost to Serco for early disposal of equipment.
Finally at a meeting of sponsors on Friday 25th March several sponsors claimed a reduction in grounds maintenance will mean a break in their contract and put at risk the income from roundabout sponsorship
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
KCC Agency Agreement: maintenance of the soft estateReport | 90 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Executive at Canterbury and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 May 2015 | Call-in for the Executive Decision at Minute No. E227 - Petition to Full Council concerning household projections figures and the Draft Local PlanRESOLVED - That the Council does not withdraw the local plan and progresses with the forthcoming public examination. ... | Approved | Open |
| 23 Apr 2015 | Matters referred to the Executive by either the Overview or the Scrutiny and Audit Committees for considerationRESOLVED accordingly. Reason for the decision The current number of audit days is sufficient for the delivery of the ... | Decided | Open |
| 23 Apr 2015 | Key Performance Indicators - Targets for 2015/16RESOLVED – That the proposed list of corporate key performance indicators and targets for 2015/16 are approved. Reaso... | Approved | Open |
| 23 Apr 2015 | Litter Project ReviewRESOLVED - That approval be given to the continuation of the project as an extended pilot until 31 March, 2016 during... | Approved | Open |
| 23 Apr 2015 | Additional and Selective LicensingRESOLVED – That it be recommend strongly to the next Council that a full student impact review be conducted as soon a... | Decided | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.