Resolved
Permit Letters of Rep: 25 Update Report: No MJC introduced this retrospective planning application for two picket fences in a new residential development. They are set in a communal space, shared by all the apartments, and planning permission is required because they are adjacent to a listed building. Councillor Sudbury has requested the application be considered at Committee, due to the high level of residents’ objections. Public Speaking: None. Member debate: KS: this is a difficult application, and has caused a lot of friction between residents, which would have been wholly unnecessary if the developer had got the scheme right in the first place. When residents first contacted her, could not see why it was such a big deal, but having visited the site, understood why they are concerned and felt it important to debate the issue. In other circumstances, fences like this are not an issue, but here they cause a problem. Firstly, the type of fencing is out of keeping – it has a suburban cottage style, while the rest of the development is high end, and features nothing else like this. Secondly, the space is communal, and needs to be available so that all residents feel they can use it. It is a planning issue; planning is about helping developers to make places where people can live comfortably, whether this is private, public or communal spaces. This site is unfortunate – not one thing or the other. Residents of the upper floors can’t use the communal space. It is situated in a very narrow part of the site. The issue needs far more attention; all residents should be able to enjoy the gardens. Welcomes the revisions to the scheme, but still feels it should not be permitted. It is out of keeping, and reduces the communal area. Personally feels the site needs to be re-landscaped, with no step-drops, but this is not an excuse, and communal space is important at this part of the site because it is so narrow. It’s such a shame as this is otherwise a good development – this is a weak point, and disappointing. Hopes that CBC learns a lesson that communal spaces cannot be left to chance – it neither looks good, nor helps with the garden’s function. Strongly urges Members to refuse or defer, to allow re-profiling of the grass to a more gentle slope. The communal garden is not currently a usable space for people paying for the privilege of using it. It isn’t great for people on the ground floor either; they have private spaces but no particular understanding of how they can use it. Hopes for a better proposal. Will move to refuse or defer, but would add that the residents who objected would be happier if the fences were of materials more in keeping with the rest of the development, allowing ... view the full minutes text for item 121.