Resolved
Permit Letters of Rep: 21 Update Report: (i) Additional representations (ii) Report update – additional condition (iii) Appendix to report – previous appeal decision EP introduced this application for planning permission for use of land for permanent occupation of a traveller family, and other provisions, as above. The land was previously occupied under a temporary permission following an earlier appeal decision, which has now expired. Previously there were three static caravans at the site; now there is just one. The application is for a personal consent for the applicant only. While it is acknowledged that the proposal causes some minor harm to the AONB, the lack of gypsy and traveller sites in Cheltenham, and the needs and human rights of the applicant have to be taken into consideration. The emerging JCS policy is criteria-based, and there is no straightforward alternative site. In March 2017, a county-wide assessment identified the need for three pitches in the borough. The continuing need is not likely to be filled by the JCS, and officers therefore feel it appropriate to recommend that permission be granted. Public Speaking: [name removed], on behalf of Save our AONB and neighbours, in objection Began by reminding Members that Cotswold AONB has the highest status of protection under the National Parks Act 1949, and the NPPF requires local authorities to give great weight to conserving landscape and scenic beauty – which this proposal will not, as a planning inspector has said at a previous appeal. Despite this, the inspector permitted a strictly conditioned, personal and temporary permission, until January 2017. Save our AONB cannot argue with this, but strongly objects to a permanent and unrestricted permission being granted. The application states that the site is 2.4 hectares, not just the 0.2 hectares covering the south-west corner. Members could unwittingly have granted permission for C3 land use over the whole site. They should also know that surface water continues to spill over Mill Lane several times a year, despite claims that drainage isn’t a problem, causing a hazard when icy; the use of the land now is nothing like it was in 2013, and there have been no horses on site for at least three years; another high, close-boarded fence went up on site about a year ago, subdividing a large open field and contrary to the 2016 Cotswold AONB Landscape Strategy; and the septic tank was cleared out this year and is no longer sufficient for a family and business. Thirdly, this application is attempting to subvert the protection of public interest by pre-empting alternative sites being brought forward through the JCS – one such site could be Arle Nurseries, on green belt land. The inspector specifically said ... view the full minutes text for item 123.