RESOLVED – That it is expedient to issue an Enforcement Notice under Section 172 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 in respect of the following breach of planning control: 1. Without planning permission the erection of a stable block upon land to the south and east of the rear of Ash House Farm, Ulnes Walton Lane. Remedy for Breach 1. Demolish the stable block erected upon the land identified at 15 (i). 2. Remove all material resultant from the works carried out under 15ii(a) from the land. Period of Compliance 180 days Reason The development is located within the Green Belt as defined by Policy 2 and the Key Diagram of the Adopted Lancashire Structure Plan and by the proposals Map of the Adopted Chorley Borough Local Plan Review. The development is contrary to Policy 4 of the Adopted Lancashire Structure Plan and Policy DC1 of the Adopted Local Plan Review. Within the Green Belt planning permission will not be given except in very special circumstances for the erection of new buildings other than for the purposes of agriculture, forestry, essential facilities for indoor sport and recreation, for cemeteries, and other uses which do not conflict with the purposes of including land in it, or limited extension, alteration, or replacement of existing dwellings. It is not considered that the stable block as erected represents an essential facility for outdoor recreation in this case. The stable block erected by virtue of its siting and scale is contrary to the provisions of criterion (a) and (c) of Policy EP8 of the Adopted Chorley Borough Council Local Plan Review and Adopted Supplementary Planning Guidance “Development involving Horses”.
Word for word from the decision Chorley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.chorley.gov.uk
1. To consider whether it is expedient to take enforcement action in respect of the above case.
CORPORATE PRIORITIES
2. This report does not affect the corporate priorities.
RISK ISSUES
3. The report contains no risk issues for consideration by Members.
Background
4. The case relates to the erection of a large stable block on land that is claimed to be residential curtilage at this property. An application was received and considered by the Planning Authority for the erection of six stables on land to the south and east of Ash House Farm; this development was described on the planning application as, “Proposed erection of six stables”. Part 2 (P1A), additional information in respect of shopping, office, industrial or other commercial use was also completed on which it was stated that, “Once or twice a week she would give carriage driving lessons from the property”. This application was refused. The reasons for refusal were threefold, highway safety, contrary to Greenbelt Policy and contrary to the Councils Supplementary Planning Guidance, Development Involving Horses.
5. Following refusal of that planning application, a stable block has been erected upon land to the south and east of Ash House Farm, the same parcel of land as that shown in the refused application. The landowner has erected these stables claiming the land forms part of the domestic curtilage of the dwelling, and that the stables, therefore benefit as permitted development granted by virtue of, Schedule 2, Part 1, Class E, The Town & Country (General Permitted Development) Order 1995. Complaint regarding the erecting of these stables coupled with information, which counter the assertion by the landowner that the land is domestic curtilage has been received. The complainant stating the land has never been used as such and in addition, the complainant reports that carriage- driving lessons are being operated from the property by the owner/occupier.
ASSESSMENT
6. The main issue to consider is whether the development that has been carried out is in fact on land that forms part of the residential curtilage of this property. On the one hand the title holder of this recently acquired property states the land to the south and east is residential curtilage. The owner refers to advice given to her by the Planning Office, and
ADMINREP/REPORT that only after receipt of that advice were the stables erected on that land. However no correspondence exists between the Council and the landowner to corroborate this statement. It is accepted that the title holder of the property did seek advice regarding erecting stables utilising permitted development rights. However the advice given by the Planning Office regarding permitted development rights concerned a different parcel of land, land immediately to the rear of the dwellinghouse, not land to the south and east. There are no planning records held since 1948, that accurately reflect the use of this parcel of land, save old aerial photographs which of themselves are inconclusive.
7. The owner of the land has not made any formal application to the Council for determination of the use of this land. This could be done through the submission of an application for a Certificate of Lawful Use and would examine all evidence given by the landowner to establish whether that claimed use is lawful. The complainant has stated in correspondence to the Council that the parcel of land had originally had a commercial greenhouse on it and subsequent to it falling down no care had been expended on including it into the large garden and orchard area immediately behind the farmhouse.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.