It was proposed by Councillor Brownlee, seconded by Councillor Whittaker and subsequently RESOLVED 15:7 to refuse planning permission for the following reason: 1. The proposed development is located in a prominent location highly visible from public vantage points. The proposed design of the hotel and public house elements represents a poor form of urban design with tension between the design of the proposed elements that would create buildings that appeared out of context with each other and is contrary to the advice in PPS1 on Design policy DP3 of the Regional Spatial Strategy for the North West (RPG13) and policy GN5 of the Chorley Borough Local Plan Review 2003.
Word for word from the decision Chorley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.chorley.gov.uk
Item A. 2 05/00455/FULMAJ Refuse Full Planning Permission
Case Officer [name removed] Chorley North East
Proposal Erection of hotel and public house/restaurant and related works,
Location Land Between M61 Motorway And Leeds And Liverpool Canal, Millennium Way, Chorley, Lancashire,
Applicant Mitchells & Butlers
Site: The site comprises part of the land between the M61 Motorway and the Leeds and Liverpool Canal to the north of Botany Bay Mill. The northern boundary is the A674 (Millennium Way) from which access is gained from the existing roundabout. The site extends to some 5 hectares in total.
Background: This application is related to outline application 05/00394/OUTMAJ found elsewhere on this agenda. That report provides a full resume of the background to the applications, the planning history, consultation responses, and the relevant planning policies. They are not repeated in this report for the sake of brevity.
The application has subsequently been submitted on behalf of Mitchells and Butler (Vintage Inns) for a Hotel and Public House on the northernmost part of the site adjacent to the A674 roundabout. It is understood that the hotel operator is Ramada, although this is not specified in the application submission.
The applicant originally incorrectly indicated that Bluemantle were the owners of the site. As a consequence the applications were invalid until the correct certificate was received on the 7 November 2005.
Proposals: This application proposes the construction of a 109 bed hotel (C1) and public house/restaurant (A3/A4) in the north western most corner of the site with frontage to the access and the A674. Finished floor levels are uncertain although the applicants have indicated they would wish to raise the ground levels to increase the prominence of the building. The pub is domestic in scale and has the appearance of an old cottage. It is similar to their recent development at Three Rings (Bamber Bridge) in South Ribble.
Issues: The general issues relating to the principles of the proposed development have been addressed in the report on the outline planning application. Those issues apply equally to this application as they do the outline, and therefore are not repeated here.
However, the detailed application includes the design and location of the proposed development. Issues relating to these specific issues are discussed in detail below:
1 The proposed public house is located in the north eastern most corner adjacent to the existing roundabout on the A674. The proposed hotel is located immediately to side (west) of this also adjacent to the northern boundary of the site. The site is very prominent with open views from the elevated road adjacent to the site. The development will also be prominent in terms of views from further a field including Blackburn Road to the East and the M61 to the west, particularly from Junction 8.
The two buildings the subject of this application have been designed as two distinct entities. They are described in detail below.
The Proposed Hotel
The proposed hotel was originally submitted as a bland building with a curved roof with two storey entrance feature. This design was considered to be unacceptable as it paid no regard to context, the characteristics of the site, the adjacent mill buildings, the canal or the desire to create a building of a high standard of design. As a result the proposed development has been amended by the applicant.
The amended plans have sought to create a contemporary building whilst accepting the presence, scale and detailing of the Botany Bay Mill. The proposed building is L shaped in plan form being 52 metres by 34 metres approximately. The building is largely four storeys in height (13.5 metres). There is a central glass atrium located at the corner of the L which accommodates the entrance, reception, stairs, and lifts. The atrium is 5 storey (16.5 metres) in height to accommodate air conditioning and lift head equipment.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.