It was proposed by Councillor D Gee, seconded by Councillor D Edgerley to defer the decision to allow the Site Inspection Sub-Committee to visit the development and make a reccomendation to this Committee. Councillor A Lowe proposed an amendment to the motion, seconded by Councillor R Lees and was subsequently RESOLVED (9:4) to refuse the retrospective planning permission for the following reasons: 1. The proposal, by reason of the height and siting of the boundary wall, would be visually obtrusive and detrimental to both the appearance and character of the street and the amenity of the area. This development is inappropriate as it does not relate well to the immediate surroundings which reflects a more open and sylvan character with softer boundary treatments. The proposal is therefore contrary to policy GN1 and GN5 of the Adopted Chorley Borough Local Plan Review.
Word for word from the decision Chorley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.chorley.gov.uk
Applicant [name removed]: This retrospective application is for the erection of a 2 metre high wall along a section of the southern boundary, adjacent to the highway.
The total length of the wall is 13.3 metres, which is constructed in an ‘L’ shape. The section of the wall which bounds the highway is 8.8 metres in length, and the remaining section is at right angles to the highway, coming within 1.2 metres of the dwelling house. The 2 metre high wall will comprise of a 0.8 metre dwarf brick wall, brick pillars 1.1 metres in height, 0.3 metres in width and finished with concrete cappings, and timber fence panels in between the pillars 1.8 metres in length.
Background: The application site comprises of a detached dwelling house and detached garage, both constructed out of brick. The site is a corner plot on Highways Avenue, which is on a housing estate built in the mid 1970s.
Policy: GN1: Settlement Policy – Main Settlements GN5: Building Design
Planning History: There have been two planning applications at the site: 87/00288/FUL – Two storey side extension. Permitted. 90/00046/FUL – Single storey rear extension. Permitted.
Consultations: CBC’s Highways Department have no comments to make.
Head of Environmental Services have no comments to make.
Representations: None
Assessment: The application site lies within a main settlement, in which there is a presumption in favour of appropriate development, subject to normal planning considerations and the other policies and proposals of the plan, as stated by policy GN1.
Design and impact on the street scene Policy GN5 states that the design of the proposed development will be expected to be well related to its surroundings. The immediate surrounding area reflects an open and sylvan character, evident by minimum boundary treatments at neighbouring properties, which include dwarf walls 0.5 metres high, and softer vegetation.
Neighbouring property no. 59 Highways Avenue to the west of the site, which is also a corner plot, has 3-metre high hedgerow as its boundary treatment. Neighbouring properties to the south and east of the wall incorporate dwarf walls and vegetation boundaries adjacent to the highway. These boundary treatments are softer and less prominent.
Approximately 35 metres away, property no. 40 Hawkshead Avenue has incorporated a 2.1 metre high wall, which has been constructed without planning permission. A retrospective application was refused (ref:9/05/00992/FUL) and enforcement action was approved in December 2005. An appeal against the enforcement notice has been made, which is currently ongoing. This unlawful development is also not in keeping with the area, and should not justify a similar proposal within the vicinity.
Prominent boundary treatments providing high levels of screening, enclosure and privacy, such as this proposal, are not reflected in this part of the street. The height and bulk of the wall would be visually obtrusive and detrimental to both the appearance and character of the street and the amenity of the area. The development is inappropriate, as it does not relate well to the immediate surroundings, which reflect a more open and sylvan character with softer boundary treatments.
Impact on neighbour amenity Due to the scale and siting of the proposal, it has no undue impact upon the amenities of neighbouring properties.
Impact on highway safety The proposal has no detrimental impact on highway safety.
Conclusion: The proposal will be a prominent feature in the street scene, and will have a significantly adverse impact on the character of the street scene when taking into account the absence of screening at other properties in the immediate area, and the prominent corner location occupied by the property.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.