Planning permission refused. It was proposed by Councillor Roy Lees to defer the decision to allow Members of the Committee to visit the site. It was proposed by Councillor David Dickinson, seconded by Councillor Simon Moulton, and subsequently RESOLVED unanimously to refuse retrospective planning permission on the following ground: The proposed amendments by reason of their size, siting and design result in an overbearing impact on the neighbouring occupiers at ‘Pippins’ and cause harm to the design and appearance of the existing dwelling. The proposal is contrary to Saved Policy DC8A of the Chorley Borough Local Plan Review and the guidance as set out in the Householder Design Guidance SPD.
Word for word from the decision Chorley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.chorley.gov.uk
Proposal Amendments to previously approved planning application ref: 08/01226/FUL to include change to roof pitch over side extension and changes to roof over garage (retrospective application).
Location Woodcock Barn Runshaw Lane Euxton ChorleyPR7 6HB
Applicant [name removed] expiry: 6 January 2010
Application expiry: 7 January 2010
Proposal 1. This application relates to amendments to a previously approved planning application ref: 08/01226/FUL to include change to roof pitch over side extension and changes to roof over garage, which is a retrospective application.
2. The roofs have been built differently to those from the approved plans. The plans were approved in February 2009.
Recommendation 3. It is recommended that this application is refused.
Main Issues 4. The main issues for consideration in respect of this planning application are: • Design and appearance of the proposal on the existing dwelling. • Impact on the amenity of the neighbour.
Representations 5. 1 letter of objection has been received from the neighbour, which are as follows: • The owner has deviated from the original approved plan (08/01226/FUL). • The roof pitch over the side extension is not as the original approved plans indicate. The new roof line does not incorporate a ‘catslide’ roof pitch. The reasons the planning officer insisted this could be included in the original plans still apply. The ‘break’ in the roof angle would clearly separate the garage/house line. • The flat roof over the garage is substantially larger than indicated in the original approved plans. This has resulted in an extremely large and unsightly visible aspect from my bedroom window. The reasons the planning officer insisted on the original design and scale still apply. • The garage has been substantially extended further than indicated on the original approved plans. • The industrial guttering used is oversized aluminium box type which is not only visibly unsightly but extremely noisy as my bedroom window is now only a matter of a few feet away from the guttering. • The scale, appearance and design of these substantial changes have already been irresponsibly implemented without authority which has now made the building extremely overbearing and intrusive towards my property. Such a large and overpowering building is I feel totally ‘out of keeping’ set against adjoining bungalows. 6. Euxton Parish Council; have not made any comments.
Consultations
7. Chorley’s Conservation Officer states the nearest listed building is Bourne Farm, this development does not impact on the listed building.
Assessment Design and Appearance of the Proposal on the Existing Dwelling 8. It was established in the report, on the previous application (08/01226/FUL) that due to the number of changes that had been carried out to the dwelling that it no longer had the character of an agricultural dwelling. Therefore it has to be looked at in terms of a more contemporary way.
9. There was some negotiation in the previous scheme to change the massing and bulk of the roof shown, and it was subsequently amended so as to create a ‘cat slide roof’ over the garage so it looks as if there is some form of separation between the two elements. A window was also added to the front elevation.
10. Since the approval of the scheme (including amended plans) the roof has been built differently to the approved plans. The roof has been built outwards to the side and the length of the garage with a change in the pitch. The main roof, where it links into the garage, has also been built differently to the approved plans in that there is no change in pitch from the main roof and that of the garage, so there is now a vast expanse of roof with the same pitch.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.