Planning permission refused. It was proposed by Councillor Ken Ball, seconded by Councillor Christopher France and subsequently unanimously RESOLVED – To refuse planning permission for the following reason: 1. Although the proposed extended roof does incorporate a shallower roof pitch that is considered to more in keeping with the design of the property in accordance with Policy DC8A of the adopted Chorley Borough Local Plan Review, as a result it is considered the proposal will have a detrimental impact on the neighbouring property ‘Pippins’. It will result in an uninterrupted view of a roof plane from the window in the side (west) elevation. This is considered contrary to Policy DC8A of the adopted Chorley Borough Local Plan Review and the Council’s adopted Supplementary Planning Document Householder Design Guidance.
Word for word from the decision Chorley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.chorley.gov.uk
Proposal Application for amendments to the pitch of the roof over the entrance and garage to the front of the property, and application for retrospective permission for the roof pitch over side extension.
Location Woodcock Barn Runshaw Lane Euxton Chorley PR7 6HB
Applicant [name removed] expiry: 17 May 2011
Application expiry: 23 May 2011
Proposal 1. Application for amendments to the pitch of the roof over the entrance and garage to the front of the property, and application for retrospective permission for the roof pitch over side extension.
Recommendation 2. It is recommended that this application is refused planning permission.
Chairs Brief 3. The application is being brought to Chairs brief as an objection has been received and the proposal is the subject of an extant enforcement notice that was approved by the Development Control Committee. Consultation expiry date: 17th May 2011 (site notice). Neighbour letter expired 26th April 2011 Decision date: 23rd May 2011
Background 4. This application relates to amendments to a previously approved planning application ref: 08/01226/FUL. The extensions were however not built in accordance with the originally approved plans. A change was made to the roof pitch over a side extension and changes were also made to the entrance and roof over garage.
5. In 2009 a retrospective application (ref: 09/00909/FUL) was made to regularise these changes but was refused at Committee. Enforcement notice EN635 was served on the property after being authorised by the Development Control Committee following a site visit. The applicant appealed the refusal of the planning permission (but did not appeal the enforcement notice) but the appeal was dismissed on the impact that the roof over the entrance and garage would be out of keeping with the gentle pitches and altogether more streamlined profiles of the remaining parts of the roof and as a result the design and final character of the dwelling would detract from its surroundings.
6. The current application has been submitted in response following the appeal decision. It proposes to retain the roof over the side extension as built, but to alter the roof over the entrance/garage as built.
Main Issues 7. The main issues for consideration in respect of this planning application are: • Design and appearance of the proposal on the existing dwelling. • Impact on the amenity of the neighbour. Representations 8. One letter of objection have been received from the neighbour at Pippins on the following grounds: • The Appeal acknowledged the extensions to Woodcock Barn had not been implemented in accordance with the approved plans. The ‘cat slide’ required for the main pitched roof which was needed to differentiate the garage from the rest of the dwelling had not been implemented which now left a severe unrelieved slope. The other main change to the roof was to the roof over the garage and entrance. Here a flat section had been extended forwards by approximately 3m further than permitted and now culminates in a short, steeply pitched plane. Although the Appeal inspector found that the change to the pitch of the main roof did not differ from the permitted line to such an extent as to be detrimental, she did find that the amendments to the roof over the garage and entrance caused harm to the character of the existing dwelling and thus the surrounding area.
• Although the Appeal inspector disagreed with my and the planning councils opinion that the unapproved changes to Woodcock Barn had had a negative and overbearing impact on the neighbouring occupiers at ‘Pippins’ the new proposed planning application 11/00262/FUL proposes changes to the roof over the entrance and garage to the front of the property which will incorporate a further extension to this flat roof which is already some 3m longer than what was approved in planning application 08/01226/FUL.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.