Review of the Protocol for Member-Officer Relations
ApprovedCommittee3 papers
AI summaryCornwall Council has approved a revised Protocol for Member-Officer Relations, replacing a named list of office holders with a wider group and adding a requirement to declare personal relationships.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedRevised Member-Officer Relations protocol adopted by Council
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextTraining and implementationMember and officer training planned via the Member Development Plan
Who it affectsMembers and officersAll Cornwall Council Members and senior officers
What was decided
Council approved the revised Protocol for Member-Officer Relations, subject to specific amendments to paragraphs 1.7, 2.1, 3.7.1 and 3.7.2. Report P4, P5
Paragraph 1.7 now refers to those holding positions of Special Responsibility and Group Leaders, and broadens the reference to senior officers with the words 'including, but not limited to'. Report P5, P20
Paragraph 2.1 will be amended to reflect the requirements of the Employee Code of Conduct, and paragraphs 3.7.1 and 3.7.2 will use 'Undermine officers' and 'Undermine Members', with a new requirement to declare personal relationships. Report P5, P20
Why
The existing protocol had not been substantively reviewed for some time, and the updates are intended to align it with the Local Government Association's Best Practice and Guidance. Report P10, P11, P14
The revisions add the seven principles of public life, clearer Member and Officer role definitions, an informal resolution route, expanded detail on statutory officer roles, examples of acceptable and unacceptable behaviours, and new sections on communication standards, training, monitoring and review. Report P13
Officers told the committee that around 10 per cent of Member complaints at Cornwall Council are raised by other Members, compared with around 35 to 45 per cent at town and parish councils, highlighting the need for clear conduct rules. Report P17
What happens next
The amended protocol will be put into use, with training for Members and officers planned through the Member Development Plan, and additional communications to be provided if required. Report P16, P17
A future work programme item is likely to address Member-to-Member relationships, focusing on respectful working, committee conduct, local casework and formal processes, with the Standards Committee involved on ethical matters and the Code of Conduct. Report P17
Members were encouraged to use Casework Assist to raise potential breaches, which feeds intelligence to the Chief Executive and the Democratic Lead and Statutory Scrutiny Officer. Report P16, P17
Options considered
Chosen: Approve the revised protocol as recommended by the Constitution and Governance Committee, subject to the listed amendments. Endorsed by the Constitution and Governance Committee on 31 March 2026 and agreed by full Council on 21 April 2026 Report P4, P5, P18, P19, P20
Implications
Governance: Revises the framework that governs how Members and officers work together, bringing it into line with Local Government Association guidance. Report P10, P11
Legal: Paragraph 2.1 will be cross-referenced with the Employee Code of Conduct on officer conduct outside council business. Report P5, P20
Other: Adds a requirement for both Members and officers to declare personal relationships for transparency. Report P5, P20
Other: Introduces an informal resolution route where the protocol is considered not to have been followed, alongside existing formal mechanisms. Report P13, P17
Staffing: Training for Members and officers is planned and is referenced in the Member Development Plan. Report P16, P17
Who and where
All Cornwall Council elected Members, with particular reference to those holding positions of Special Responsibility and Group Leaders Report P5, P20
Cornwall Council officers, including the Chief Executive and other senior officers Report P5, P16, P20
Members and officers with personal relationships, who will need to declare them Report P5, P17, P20
Timeline
31 March 2026: Constitution and Governance Committee recommended the revised protocol to Council, subject to the listed amendments. Report P6, P7, P18, P19
21 April 2026: Full Council approved the revised Protocol for Member-Officer Relations, subject to the listed amendments. Report P2, P5
Plain English for the jargon
LGA: Local Government Association, whose Best Practice and Guidance the revisions align with.
Casework Assist: Cornwall Council system for Members to raise potential breaches of the protocol.
No surprises: Principle that Members should be informed about council matters in a timely manner, applying to all officers.
Positions of Special Responsibility: Council roles that carry significant responsibility beyond ordinary membership, used in the revised paragraph 1.7.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemCC/151
Resolved
RESOLVED that the revised Protocol for Member/Officer Relations, be approved, subject to: 1. Paragraph 1.7: i. Remove ‘the Leader, Cabinet Members, Chairman of the Council and Committee Chairmen’ and replace with ‘those holding positions of Special Responsibility and Group Leaders’; ii. In respect of the reference to senior officers add ‘including, but not limited to’ before ‘the Chief Executive’; 2. Paragraph 2.1: amend the reference to officers to reflect the requirements of the Employee Code of Conduct; 3. Paragraph 3.7.1 and 3.7.2: amend current wording of first line under ‘Don’t’ to ‘Undermine officers’ and ‘Undermine Members’ respectively and add an additional paragraph about the requirement for both Members and officers to declare personal relationships.
Word for word from the decision Cornwall published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cornwall.gov.uk
RECOMMENDATION FROM CONSTITUTION AND GOVERNANCE COMMITTEE – 31 MARCH 2026 REVIEW OF THE PROTOCOL FOR MEMBER/OFFICER RELATIONS
RECOMMENDATION TO COUNCIL THAT the revised Protocol for Member/Officer Relations, be approved, subject to:
1. Paragraph 1.7: i. Remove ‘the Leader, Cabinet Members, Chairman of the Council and Committee Chairmen’ and replace with ‘those holding positions of Special Responsibility and Group Leaders’; ii. In respect of the reference to senior officers add ‘including, but not limited to’ before ‘the Chief Executive’; 2. Paragraph 2.1: amend the reference to officers to reflect the requirements of the Employee Code of Conduct; 3. Paragraph 3.7.1 and 3.7.2: amend current wording of first line under ‘Don’t’ to ‘Undermine officers’ and ‘Undermine Members’ respectively and add an additional paragraph about the requirement for both Members and officers to declare personal relationships.
Minute excerpt of the meeting of the Constitution and Governance Committee held on 31 March 2026
Chopak, Dennis, Garrigan, O'Connor, M Thomas and Yelland.
Also in Councillor: Nolan. attendance:- Also in attendance Councillors: Boase, Jenkin and Magowan (virtual):- Apologies for Councillors: (None). absence:-
The Democratic Lead and Statutory Scrutiny Officer introduced the report and advised that it was being presented following the publication of the Local Government Association’s (LGA) Best Practice and Guidance. The Council’s existing protocol already provided a strong framework for Member and Officer working Information Classification: PUBLIC
relationships; however, the proposed updates were intended to ensure alignment with the LGA guidance.
The proposed changes were set out in the report and included:
· The seven principles of public life · Clearer definitions of Member and Officer roles · An informal resolution route where the protocol was considered not to have been followed · Expanded detail on statutory officer roles · Examples of acceptable and unacceptable behaviours · New sections covering communication standards, training and development, monitoring and review arrangements, and useful reference links
It was reported that the protocol had not been substantively reviewed for some time. The most recent update had arisen from a motion to Council relating to “no surprises” and the involvement of Local Members.
During the debate, the following points were noted:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.