Review of Admissions Policy: Fair Access for Mevagissey Families to Secondary School Transport: Proposer: Councillor Mustoe; Seconder: Councillor Ewert
DecidedCommittee2 papers
AI summaryCornwall Council asks Cabinet to make Penrice and Poltair joint designated schools so Mevagissey pupils get free transport to either, and to review the wider policy for other rural communities.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedCouncil asks Cabinet to update admissions policy
MoneyPapers say little or no extra cost
What happens nextCabinet to decideOn joint designation and wider policy review
Who it affectsMevagissey families and rural communitiesPupils travelling to St Austell for secondary school
What was decided
Council resolved to ask Cabinet to update the admissions policy so Penrice and Poltair become joint designated schools for their current designated areas, giving Mevagissey pupils fair access to school transport. Report P7, P15
Council also asked Cabinet, in doing so, to review the wider policy so other rural communities are not adversely affected in the same way. Report P7, P24, P25
Why
Penrice School is always fully subscribed because St Austell housing growth has added many children to its designated area, squeezing out pupils from Mevagissey and other outlying communities. Report P10, P11, P12
The same bus takes Mevagissey pupils to Poltair first, then Penrice, so giving them free transport to either school would not need extra vehicle provision. Report P13, P14
Joint designation already exists in Newquay and Penzance, so the change would not set a new precedent. Report P17, P30
What happens next
Cabinet is asked to decide on the joint designation and the wider rural review. Report P7
The proposer asks that, if the policy allows, the change be backdated to affect children already at the affected schools. Report P23
Options considered
Chosen: Make Penrice and Poltair joint designated schools for Mevagissey and surrounding communities. Penrice is oversubscribed due to St Austell growth, same bus serves both schools, and joint designation already exists in Newquay and Penzance Report P15, P17, P30
Rejected: Leave the policy unchanged and rely on the existing admissions process. Proposer says the current policy is no longer fit for purpose and is not serving Mevagissey families Report P20, P22
Implications
Legal: Minor changes required to the school admissions policy to make Poltair and Penrice joint designated schools for the Penrice catchment area. Report P29
Financial: Little or no extra cost expected, as pupils already use the same bus to both schools. Report P14, P27
Other: Multi Academy Trust CELT MAT, which covers Mevagissey, Penrice and Poltair, supports the change rather than diverging from the local authority policy. Report P36, P38, P39
Who and where
Pupils from Mevagissey travelling to St Austell for secondary school Report P8, P13, P15
Families in rural communities around St Austell, including Trewoon, Polgooth, Pentewan, Charlestown, Duporth, Portmellon, Tregrehan, Trethurgy and Luxylyan Report P9
Other rural communities in Cornwall whose children travel to larger towns for secondary education Report P8, P24, P25
Timeline
December 2025: Most recent officer reply received by the proposer on the transport policy Report P18, P19
19 March 2026: Proposer spoke with the Service Director for Education and Community Health, and the School Admissions Manager Report P34
27 March 2026: Proposer spoke with Cabinet Member Hilary Frank and supplied a draft motion Report P35
31 March 2026: Proposer spoke with the CEO of CELT MAT Report P36
1 April 2026: CEO of CELT MAT replied in support of joint designation Report P37, P38, P39
21 April 2026: Motion debated at Full Council and referred to Cabinet Report P2
Plain English for the jargon
Designated school: The school formally assigned to a defined area for admissions and home to school transport purposes.
Joint designated schools: Two schools both formally assigned to the same catchment area, so pupils can get free transport to either. Already used in Newquay and Penzance.
LA: Local Authority, here Cornwall Council.
MAT: Multi Academy Trust, a group of academies run together.
CELT MAT: The Multi Academy Trust that includes Mevagissey, Penrice and Poltair schools.
Home to school transport: Free or council arranged transport from a child's home to their designated school.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemCC/153
Resolved
RESOLVED that Cabinet is requested to (i) Update Cornwall Council’s admissions policy to make Penrice and Poltair Schools joint designated schools for the current Penrice School and Poltair designated areas, thus allowing pupils from Mevagissey fair access to school transport; and (ii) In carrying out (1), take the opportunity to review the wider policy to ensure other rural communities are not being adversely affected in the same way.
Word for word from the decision Cornwall published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cornwall.gov.uk
Title of Motion Review of Admissions Policy: Fair Access for Mevagissey Families to Secondary School Transport
Proposer Cllr Mustoe
Seconder Cllr Ewert
Supporters (a Cllrs Alvey, Clemens, Cunningham, Glasson, O’Connor minimum of three Parsonage, Pascoe and Yelland. are required)
Recommendation for That Cabinet is requested to Council to vote on (i) Update Cornwall Council’s admissions policy to make Penrice and Poltair Schools joint designated schools for the current Penrice School and Poltair designated areas, thus allowing pupils from Mevagissey fair access to school transport; and (ii) In carrying out (1), take the opportunity to review the wider policy to ensure other rural communities are not being adversely affected in the same way.
Context for the This is an issue I have been working for many years, to motion (i.e. why is try to change the designated school areas used when the motion being determining school transport from Mevagissey. The submitted – what is issues my residents face is likely to be symptomatic of the proposer aiming others rural areas in Cornwall. to achieve) As background, when children from Mevagissey go to secondary school, they have to travel at least as far as to a secondary school in St Austell.
Penrice School remains the designated secondary school for most of St Austell, but also a vast area of communities to the south and west of it, including Trewoon, Polgooth, Pentewan, Charlestown, Duporth, Mevagissey and Portmellon, plus to the north and east, Tregrehan, Trethurgy and Luxylyan. The boundary of the designated area in fact goes virtually right up to the other secondary school, Poltair, which is also in St Austell, virtually equidistant from Mevagissey, and which has a much smaller designated area.
St Austell has seen significant growth in the past decade or so. There are now estates with several Information Classification: PUBLIC
hundred houses on them in multiple sites across St Austell, and these are exclusively in the Penrice School designated area.
Because of this development and population growth, there are more and more children living closer to Penrice, and these are squeezing children from Mevagissey and other communities outside of St Austell out. Penrice is always fully subscribed. I have checked again this year, and it is the case again. Because of this, as well as having to make choices around attending school with siblings and additional SEN- related choices, families in Mevagissey have in recent years began having their children attend Poltair, which is virtually the same distance from Mevagissey as Penrice.
Children who catch the bus to Penrice and Poltair from Mevagissey catch the same bus. It goes to Poltair School first, and then Penrice. However children who apply for Poltair as their first choice are refused free transport. If they applied for Penrice as their first choice and Poltair as their second choice, and Penrice was full, they would be allocated Poltair, and given free transport, on the same bus.
Giving them free transport would not cost the council anything extra in terms of extra vehicle provision as children catch the same bus to either school.
A simple solution would be to make Penrice and Poltair both the designated schools for Mevagissey and the surrounding communities, because of the particular population growth in St Austell in the designated Penrice area, which is making it more and more difficult for children in outlying communities to get a place at a secondary school in the town.
If the admissions policy was thus changed, then the Home-School Transport team will, if following the same process they do now, give children who successfully apply to Penrice and Poltair from Mevagissey, free home to school transport.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Review of Admissions Policy: Fair Access for Mevagissey Families to Secondary School Transport: Proposer: Councillor Mustoe; Seconder: Councillor EwertReport
CC/153Review of Admissions Policy: Fair Access for Mevagissey Families to Secondary School Transport: Proposer: Councillor Mustoe; Seconder: Councillor EwertThis decision
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.