Appointment of Co-Opted Members to the Standards Committee and Appointment of Independent Persons
DecidedCommittee1 paper
AI summaryCornwall Council's Standards Committee recommends appointing a new Town and Parish Representative, raising Independent Persons from three to four, and naming two new Independent Persons until 31 December 2030.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedNew co-opted member, more Independent Persons, two named appointees
MoneyNo financial implicationsAllowances already in current budgets
What happens nextCouncil to consider recommendationsStandards Committee cannot appoint directly
Who it affectsStandards Committee membershipVacancies filled and capacity expanded
What was decided
The Committee will recommend to Council that Councillor J Peggs of Saltash Town Council be appointed as a co-opted Town and Parish Representative on the Standards Committee. Report 2.7
The Committee will recommend to Council that the number of Independent Persons appointed under section 28 of the Localism Act 2011 be increased from 3 to 4. Report 2.9, 2.10
The Committee will recommend to Council that Mr R Engley and Dr E Myatt be appointed as Independent Persons until 31 December 2030. Report P14, P15, P16
Why
A Town and Parish Council Representative and an Independent Person have resigned, creating vacancies that needed filling through a fresh recruitment round. Report 1.3, 1.4
Annual complaints to the Council have risen from about 80 to 180, and a fourth Independent Person is judged necessary for resilience and to prepare for expected further changes to the ethical standards regime. Report 2.9, 2.10
Adverts were placed after the summer break of 2025, including on social media, producing the largest number of applications ever for the Independent Person role; a Working Group shortlisted and interviewed candidates on 26 February 2026 at New County Hall. Report 2.4, 2.5, 2.6
What happens next
Council will be asked to approve the three recommendations; if agreed, Mr R Engley and Dr E Myatt will serve as Independent Persons until 31 December 2030. Report P14
No further recruitment steps are described in the report beyond the Council decision. Report P33, P34
Options considered
Chosen: Proceed with the recruitment outcomes: appoint Councillor J Peggs, raise Independent Persons from 3 to 4, and appoint Mr R Engley and Dr E Myatt.. Recommended by the Working Group after interviews and assessment of complaint volumes. Report 2.7, 2.10, P14
Rejected: Do not recruit: leave the Standards Committee membership unchanged and do not appoint additional Independent Persons.. Would leave vacancies unfilled and Independent Person capacity unchanged despite higher complaint numbers. Report P32
Implications
Governance: Expands the ethical standards regime by raising Independent Persons from 3 to 4 and filling a vacant co-opted Town and Parish seat on the Committee. Report 2.1, 2.10, 3.1
Financial: No financial implications; allowances for Committee members are already provided for in current budgets. Report 6.1
Legal: No legal or governance implications identified; appointments are framed under section 28 of the Localism Act 2011. Report 7.1, 2.8
Risk: No risks associated with the recommendation, in the view of the report. Report 8.1
Other: The Cornwall Development and Decision Wheel is recorded as not applicable to this report. Report 9.1
Who and where
Standards Committee of Cornwall Council, including its Town and Parish Council, Clerk and Lay Member places Report 2.1, 3.1
Cornwall Council councillors and co-opted members subject to the Code of Conduct, who may seek the views of an Independent Person when an allegation is made Report 2.8, 3.1
Residents and others who submit Code of Conduct complaints, given complaint numbers have risen to 180 a year Report 2.9, 3.1
Saltash Town Council, whose representative is put forward for the co-opted seat Report 2.7
Timeline
2014: Current composition of the Standards Committee put in place. Report 2.1
3 November 2022: Previous Standards Committee made recommendations on extending co-opted appointments during the pandemic. Report 1.1
Summer 2023: Recruitment to fill co-opted roles on the Committee for a four-year term.
23 November 2023: Previous Standards Committee decision referenced as a relevant prior decision. Report 4.1
May 2025: Town and Parish Council elections held; recruitment to the vacancies was held back until after them. Report 2.3
After summer break 2025: Adverts issued for the co-opted Town and Parish Representative and Independent Person roles, with further social media adverts for the Independent Person post. Report 2.4, 2.5
26 February 2026: Working Group undertook interviews at New County Hall. Report 2.6
30 April 2026: Standards Committee meeting at which the recommendations were made to Council.
31 December 2030: End date proposed for the new Independent Persons' terms. Report P14
Plain English for the jargon
Independent Person: A person appointed by the Council under section 28 of the Localism Act 2011 whose views must be sought before certain Code of Conduct allegations are investigated, and who can be consulted by a councillor or co-opted member against whom an allegation has been made; not a member of the Standards Committee.
Co-opted member: A person who is not an elected councillor of the Council but is appointed to the Standards Committee to bring in Town and Parish Council, Clerk or Lay Member perspectives.
Localism Act 2011: The Act that sets the current ethical standards regime for local councils, including the requirement to appoint Independent Persons and to have procedures for Code of Conduct complaints.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemS/28
Resolved
RESOLVED that it be RECOMMENDED TO COUNCIL that: 1. Councillor J Peggs be appointed as a co-opted Town and Parish Representative of the Standards Committee; 2. The complement for Independent Persons appointed under section 28 of the Localism Act 2011 be increased from 3 to 4; and 3. That [name removed] and [name removed] be appointed as Independent Persons as part of the ethical standards regime until 31 December 2030.
Word for word from the decision Cornwall published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cornwall.gov.uk
1.1At the meeting of the Standards Committee on 3 November 2022, recommendations were made to Council with regards to the extension of appointments of co-opted members to the Committee, these recommendations, which were later approved by Council, were necessary due the inability to recruitment to the Committee during the pandemic. 1.2 Going forwards, there was a recruitment process in the summer of 2023 to fill the co-opted roles on the Committee for the next four years which was successfully undertaken.
1.3Since these meetings, a Town and Parish Council Representative on the Committee and an Independent Person appointed as part of the ethical standards regime have resigned, creating vacancies which need to be filled.
1.4As a result, a recruitment process has been undertaken through the summer of 2025 to fill the above roles and vacancies, and this report covers the outcome of this process.
2 Purpose of Report and key information
2.1When the ethical standards regime changed in 2012 Cornwall Council opted to make the Standards Committee a Committee of the Council. The current composition of the Standards Committee has been in place since 2014 with the aim being to ensure that the membership of the Committee is as widely drawn as possible with this including Town and Parish Council Representatives, a currently serving Clerk from a Town or Parish Council, and Lay Members. 2.2 Prior to 2023 those co-opted onto the Committee were not appointed for a term of office, but since then the term has been set at 4 years, though those in the role can apply for an additional term if they wish to do so. The terms are also staggered in order to ensure that all the expertise on the Committee is not lost at once. Information Classification: PUBLIC
2.3In seeking to fill the current vacancies it was considered better to wait until after the elections in May 2025 as this would allow the same members of the Working Group, appointed by the Committee, to take the recruitment process forwards.
2.4To that end, adverts were sent out after the summer break for the vacant roles of a co-opted member on the Standards Committee representing Town and Parish Councils and for an Independent Person.
2.5There was a good response for the role of Town and Parish Representative but not for role of Independent Person and, after speaking to the Communications Team about this, adverts were placed on social media as this gave a wider reach. The end result was the largest number of applications we have ever received for the role.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.