CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cornwall Council
Individual Decision Day, Wednesday 14 October 2026 at 10.00am

Individual Decision - Direct Contract Award to Provider A

Approved Committee 2 papers

AI summaryCornwall Council approved a direct contract award to Provider A for care at an existing extra care scheme, starting 1 November 2026. [D] [1.4] Home care instead would cost approximately £0.130m per annum more. [1.5]

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedStarts 1 November 2026. [D]
MoneyFramework hourly ceiling £26.54 [6.1]Set for 2026/27. [6.1]
What happens nextTransparency notice and procurements [8.1] [8.3]Notice before award; two procurements same day. [8.1] [8.3]
Who it affectsExtra care residents and Council [3.1] [10.6]Residents keep onsite care; the Council avoids extra cost. [3.1] [10.6]

What was decided

Cornwall Council approved the direct contract award to Provider A. The contract start date is 1 November 2026. [D] [P1] Report P1

The direct award will replicate the contract terms used in the Extra Care Services Framework. [5.1] Report 5.1

Why

Cornwall has a significant and growing shortfall in suitable accommodation with care. The Council says the gap could widen over the next 25 years without action. [1.1] Report 1.1

Provider A owns the scheme and has delivered care since 2010. It wants to continue so it can control care quality and will not allow another provider to deliver the service. The alternative is home care, which would not follow the Council's strategic direction and would cost approximately £0.130m per annum more. [1.4] [1.5] [2.11] Report 1.4, 1.5, 2.11

The Council considers that Provider A has exclusive rights as the premises owner and that no reasonable alternative is available. It relies on paragraph 5 of Schedule 5 of the Procurement Act 2023. The Extra Care Services Framework cannot be used for a direct award at an existing scheme because direct awards through it are for new developments. [1.6] [2.10] [7.3] [7.4] [7.5] [P57] [P58] Report 1.6, 2.10, 7.3, 7.4, 7.5, P57, P58

What happens next

Publish a transparency notice before the contract is directly awarded. It will inform stakeholders and give interested parties an opportunity to consider the justification. [8.1] Report 8.1

Publish two competitive procurements through the Extra Care Services Framework on the same day as the transparency notice, allowing framework providers to bid for Council business. [8.3] Report 8.3

The direct contract with Provider A starts on 1 November 2026. [D] [P1] Report P1

The money

  • £26.54 The Extra Care Services Framework hourly ceiling rate for 2026/27. It was set using benchmarking with other local authority rates and the Council's home care and supported living rates. [6.1] Report 6.1
  • approximately £0.130m per annum The extra cost of delivering care through home care instead of Provider A at the scheme. [1.5] [8.4] [10.6] Report 1.5, 8.4, 10.6

Options considered

  • Chosen: Approve a direct contract award to Provider A. Provider A says it can retain control of care quality if it continues, and the Council considers the direct award conditions are met. The alternative is fragmented home care at approximately £0.130m per annum more. [1.4] [1.5] [7.3] [7.5] [10.1] [10.5] Report 1.4, 1.5, 7.3, 7.5, 10.1, 10.5
  • Rejected: Do not approve a direct contract award to Provider A. Provider A opposes another provider taking over the service. Without onsite care, existing residents would need fragmented home care, the scheme might no longer be usable for extra care, and the Council would face an additional £0.130m per annum. [8.4] [10.2] [10.4] [10.5] [10.6] Report 8.4, 10.2, 10.4, 10.5, 10.6

Implications

  • Legal: The Council's stated legal basis is paragraph 5 of Schedule 5 of the Procurement Act 2023. It considers that Provider A has exclusive rights as owner and that no reasonable alternatives are available. [7.2] [7.3] [7.4] [7.5] [P57] [P58] Report 7.2, 7.3, 7.4, 7.5, P57, P58
  • Financial: The framework's hourly ceiling is £26.54 for 2026/27. Using home care instead would cost approximately £0.130m per annum more. [1.5] [6.1] Report 1.5, 6.1
  • Financial: The detailed financial implications are held in legally privileged exempt Appendix 1. [6.2] [11.1] Report 6.2, 11.1
  • Risk: There is a small risk that another provider could challenge the award. A transparency notice must be published before direct award, and the Council considers the risk mitigated. [8.1] [8.2] Report 8.1, 8.2
  • Risk: Without Provider A, the Council might no longer be able to use the scheme for extra care. Home care would replace onsite provision and would be fragmented, with delivery not optimised. [8.4] [10.4] [10.5] Report 8.4, 10.4, 10.5
  • Equalities: Positive impacts were identified for age, disability, carers, human rights and safeguarding. [P69] Report P69
  • Climate: The decision wheel records mostly no or neutral environmental and social impact, with a positive impact for Valuing Local from the scheme's existing VCSE links. [P69] Report P69
  • Other: Provider A's continued role lets it control the quality of care provision, which it says would not happen if another provider were appointed. [1.4] [10.3] Report 1.4, 10.3

Who and where

  • Council funded service users already receiving care at the scheme Report 7.5
  • People living in Provider A's extra care scheme Report 1.4, 2.6, 3.1
  • People living in the surrounding area Report 3.1
  • Adults with care or support needs Report 1.2
  • Cornwall Council Report 1.1, 7.1
  • Provider A Report 1.4
  • Other Extra Care Services Framework providers Report 8.3
  • People who would need home care if Provider A were not appointed Report 8.4, 10.5

Timeline

  • 8 November 2023: Cabinet approved the Supported and Specialist Housing Strategy. [4.1] Report 4.1
  • 2050: The housing strategy projects demand for extra care through this year. [2.2] Report 2.2
  • 30 April 2026: The Strategic Director approved the Extra Care Development Framework and Extra Care Services Framework contract awards. [4.6] Report 4.6
  • 2026/27: The Extra Care Services Framework hourly ceiling rate is £26.54. [6.1] Report 6.1
  • since 2010: Provider A has delivered care into the scheme under direct award arrangements. [1.4] [2.11] Report 1.4, 2.11
  • 1 November 2026: The approved direct contract with Provider A starts. [D] [P1] Report P1
  • 2028: A new extra care scheme nearby is expected to become operational. [7.5] Report 7.5

Plain English for the jargon

  • Extra care: Housing with onsite care and support that helps people remain in their own homes. It is usually for people aged 55 and over, with access for younger people whose needs can be met. [2.5] [2.6] [3.2]
  • Direct award: Awarding a public contract without first running a competitive tender, which the Procurement Act 2023 permits in special cases. [1.7] [7.2]
  • Extra Care Services Framework: One of the Council's two extra care frameworks, covering the delivery of care into extra care. [1.3] [1.6]
  • Core service element: A prevention service with 24/7 onsite support available to everyone living in the scheme. [2.6]
  • Commenced care element: Commissioned care and support delivered according to assessed needs, eligibility under the Care Act 2014 and each person's care and support plan. [2.6]
  • Transparency notice: A notice published before direct award to inform stakeholders and allow interested parties to consider the justification. [8.1]
  • Exclusive rights: A direct award ground where only one supplier can provide the services because of intellectual property or other exclusive rights. The Council applies this to Provider A's ownership of the premises. [7.3] [7.4]
  • No reasonable alternatives: A direct award ground requiring that there are no reasonable alternatives to the services. The Council cites current service users and the lack of another nearby operational extra care facility. [P58] [7.5]
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemIDD-L92

Resolved

That the direct contract award for Provider A set out in the report and exempt appendix be approved with a contract start date of 1 November 2026.
Word for word from the decision Cornwall published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cornwall.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cornwall's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Individual Decision Day

Recommendation

1. That the direct contract award for Provider A set out in the report and exempt appendix be approved with a contract start date of 1 November 2026.

Executive summary

1.1Cornwall’s Supported and Specialist Housing Strategy and Market Sustainability Plan (2023–2025) highlight a significant and growing shortfall in suitable accommodation with care. Without proactive intervention, this gap will widen over the next 25 years. The Council must act to ensure a sustainable, high-quality care market for all residents, including self-funders.

1.2Extra care aims to help adults with care and/or support needs to maximise their independence and remain in their own homes within the extra care scheme by supporting them with essential personal and practical tasks that they are unable to manage safely for themselves, including support to maintain or to enable independent living skills and to achieve outcomes that matter to them.

1.3The Council has recently awarded contracts for two extra care frameworks – one framework for the development of extra care (Extra Care Development Framework) and one framework for the care delivery into extra care (Extra Care Services Framework).

1.4However, Provider A owns one of our existing extra care schemes and has delivered care into the scheme since 2010 under direct award arrangements. Provider A wants to continue to deliver the care and support into the extra care scheme, to ensure they can control the quality of the care provision delivered for the group of older adults who live in their property.

1.5As Provider A has already confirmed they would not be willing to allow another care provider to deliver an extra care service from the property, the only alternative would be a home care service, which does not meet the Council’s strategic direction and would be more expensive to deliver by approximately £0.130m per annum. Information Classification: PUBLIC

1.6Provider A have recently been appointed to the Extra Care Services Framework, so the Council has been assured of the quality-of-care delivery and value for money. This framework could not be used for the direct award because it is not a new build property.

1.7Under the Procurement Act 2023 there are circumstances in which a contracting authority is permitted to award a public contract to a supplier without first running a competitive tendering procedure and these conditions have been met.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Individual Decision: Direct Contract Award to Provider ADecisions 549 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Individual Decision: Direct Contract Award to provider A: Appendix 2 -L92Decisions 536 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

0 of 9 attended
AP
Adam PaynterCommittee Member, expected
TD
Tim DwellyCommittee Member, expected
HF
Hilary FrankCommittee Member, expected
PL
Peter La BroyCommittee Member, expected
TM
Thalia MarringtonCommittee Member, expected
JM
Jim McKennaCommittee Member, expected
SP
Sarah PreeceCommittee Member, expected
LR
Loic RichCommittee Member, expected
DR
Dan RogersonCommittee Member, expected

On this subject at Cornwall

Search all
  1. Individual Decision - Direct Contract Award to Provider AThis decision
  2. Individual Decision - National Jobs Guarantee – Cornwall and DevonAgreed
  3. Individual Decision - Local Transport Consolidated FundingDecided
  4. Individual Decision - Tamar Crossings - Supply of Replacement Ferry Main Chains for the Torpoint FerriesDecided
  5. Individual Decision - Environment Service Licensing SchemesDecided
  6. Individual Decision - Visit Cornwall Asset LicensingApproved

More from Cornwall Individual Decision Day

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
14 Oct 2026 Individual Decision - National Jobs Guarantee – Cornwall and DevonThat, subject to a positive funding decision from the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP), Cornwall Council accept... Agreed Open
14 Oct 2026 Individual Decision - Local Transport Consolidated FundingThat Cornwall’s refined Local Transport Delivery Plan, as set out in Appendix?1 to the report, be endorsed to enable ... Decided Open
14 Oct 2026 Individual Decision - Tamar Crossings - Supply of Replacement Ferry Main Chains for the Torpoint FerriesFollowing an open competitive tender procedure, that the award of the Supply of Replacement Ferry Main Chains for the... Decided Open
2 Sep 2026 Individual Decision - Environment Service Licensing SchemesThat authority be delegated to the Service Director for Environment & Connectivity to procure suppliers for the follo... Decided Open
2 Sep 2026 Individual Decision - Visit Cornwall Asset LicensingThat the licence of Cornwall Council’s Visit Cornwall intangible assets to Cornwall Visitor Alliance Ltd be approved.... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies