What was decided
Council approved in principle the change of use of Brandon Wood Golf Course to a nature reserve and registered Biodiversity Net Gain habitat bank, including demolition of the former golf club house, subject to a formal planning process via Rugby Borough Council. Report P9, P17
Council delegated authority to the Director of Regeneration and Economic Development, in consultation with relevant directors and the Cabinet Member, to enter into legal agreements, accept up to £2m in BNG unit sales, approve up to £1.4m addition for the project, and join the Natural Capital Investment Strategy partnership with Warwickshire County Council and Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council. Report P10, P12, P13, P14, P18, P20, P21, P22, P23
All Biodiversity Net Gain income from the site is to be ringfenced and reinvested in biodiversity and enabling activities. Report P15, P24
Why
The UK is one of the most nature depleted nations, and the council has a commitment in its Climate Change Strategy (2024-2030) to support nature recovery at scale. Report P1, 1.1, 1.4
The former golf course has been closed since 2020 and was deemed financially unviable to continue, while the 64 hectare site could generate up to 304 BNG units to fund habitat creation and management for 30 years without council investment. Report P2, 1.16, 1.18, 1.27
Joining the Warwickshire, Coventry and Solihull Natural Capital Investment Strategy partnership is intended to help plan and manage BNG and emerging nature markets more strategically and to pool resources. Report P4, P13, 1.22, 1.23, 1.25
What happens next
A planning application will be prepared for a decision in the first half of 2026, with works potentially commencing in the second half of 2026 and the site fully open to the public by the end of 2027. Report P4, 4.1
Warwickshire Wildlife Trust will manage the site under a property transaction with the council for up to 30 years, with a Conservation Covenant put in place with Warwickshire County Council as the responsible body. Report 1.10, P5, P11, P116, P119, P120
A separate report on the proposed outdoor education, training and wellbeing hub on the former clubhouse site will be brought back to Cabinet for consideration within 12 months, with a backstop that the land reverts to BNG use if the hub does not proceed. Report 1.15, P82
The money
- up to £8m Legal agreements to maximise BNG units for the whole site Report P12, P20
- up to £2m Acceptance of BNG unit sales for the initial phase of delivery Report P13, P22, P118
- up to £1.4 million Council addition for delivering the project, subject to financial mitigations Report P14, P23
- £50-100k Annual maintenance cost of leaving the site as it is (do nothing option) Report P74
- £70k Annual cost of the former golf club house, including security and business rates Report 1.27, P76
- £0.4m Cost of demolishing the former club house Report P76
- £3.5m Total cost over 30 years for Option A (214 BNG units) Report P97, P108
- £8.1m Total cost for Option B (304 BNG units, full visitor experience) Report P78, P97
- £3.1m Additional infrastructure and operating costs for full visitor destination over 30 years Report P78
- £1.5m Modelled upfront income in year one from selling 60 BNG units at £25,000 each Report P92, P97
- £25,000 Conservative flat rate applied per BNG unit in the financial model Report 1.18, P97
- £20,000 to £35,000 Typical BNG unit value range based on market supply and demand Report 1.18
- £50,000 Potential selling price per high value wetland BNG unit Report 1.18, P101
- £1.8m Potential surplus income from Option A (214 units sold) reinvested in biodiversity and infrastructure Report P75
- £0.5m Financial pressure under Option B (304 units with full visitor experience) Report P78, P95, P97
- £1.4m Potential funding gap if council cannot sell remaining 154 BNG units after initial transaction Report P110
- £580k Potential reduction in liability over remaining term if 60 unit scheme reduced at year 10 Report P110
- nearly £1m Nature Towns and Cities Fund secured for the Green for All project on access to nature Report 1.8
Options considered
- Rejected: Do nothing (Option 1): continue to incur £50-100k annual maintenance costs with the site closed to the public. Rules out BNG income, leaves the site closed, ongoing antisocial behaviour and flytipping costs Report P74
- Rejected as standalone: Deliver a nature reserve and habitat bank on part of the site, generating 214 BNG units (Option 2/Option A). Viable but loses the opportunity to create a visitor destination and connect with the wider 293ha landscape Report P75, P77, P94
- Rejected: Deliver a nature reserve and create a visitor destination across the whole site, generating 304 BNG units (Option 3/Option B). Shows a £0.5m financial pressure and offers no surplus income or outdoor education facility Report P78, P80, P95
- Chosen: Deliver a nature reserve and visitor destination with an outdoor education, training and wellbeing hub on the former clubhouse site (Option 4). Shares infrastructure costs and offers benefits for outdoor learning, wellbeing and visitor experience; 90 fewer BNG units but business case still viable Report P81, P82, P83, P99
Implications
- Financial: The project is intended to be self-financing through BNG unit sales, with up to £1.4m of council funding approved as a safeguard. A phased approach is recommended to avoid the council having to borrow up front, and any surplus BNG income must be ringfenced and reinvested in biodiversity. Report P14, P15, P22, P23, P24, P99, P106, P110
- Legal: A Conservation Covenant will be put in place with Warwickshire County Council as the responsible body to monitor the habitat management and monitoring plan for 30 years, and a property transaction will be entered into with Warwickshire Wildlife Trust Group under Section 123 of the Local Government Act 1972. New access arrangements will need to be agreed with Network Rail because the existing access agreement expires in 2037 and would cease on change of use. Report 1.10, P11, P116, P120, P121, P122
- Equalities: The site is intended to be made accessible through upgraded and accessible footpaths, disabled parking, a changing place toilet, hire of all terrain wheelchairs and a wheelchair accessible viewing platform. Learnings from the £1m Green for All project on inequalities in access to nature will inform visitor engagement at the reserve. Report 1.8, 1.11, 1.12, P6
- Climate: The scheme delivers a priority action in the Coventry Climate Change Strategy (2024-2030) for landscape scale nature restoration and supports the city's contribution to the national 30 by 30 target, currently at about 11% in Coventry. Report 1.2, 1.4, 1.6, 1.7, P130
- Risk: The BNG market is immature and there is uncertainty over the timing of unit sales. If units cannot be sold, the council could face a funding gap of up to £1.4m as funder of last resort, partly mitigated by potential agricultural stewardship funding and possible removal of unsold units from the scheme. Report P4, P107, P108, P109, P110, P111, P112, P113
- Other: The proposal is described as non-economic under the Subsidy Control Act 2022 because it is a not for profit, fully cost recovery environmental restoration initiative, with all BNG income ringfenced and reinvested in habitat creation, monitoring and long term management. Report P126, P127
Who and where
- Coventry residents and visitors who will gain a publicly accessible 64 hectare nature reserve and visitor facilities on the edge of the city Report P1, 1.9
- Warwickshire Wildlife Trust, which will manage the site for up to 30 years under a property transaction with the council Report P5, 1.10, P11, P120
- Warwickshire County Council and Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council as partners in the Natural Capital Investment Strategy and as the responsible body for the Conservation Covenant Report 1.10, P13, P21, P116, P118
- Rugby Borough Council, which will determine the planning application for the change of use Report P9, P17
- Developers in Warwickshire, the West Midlands and potentially nationally seeking to offset Biodiversity Net Gain requirements, who are expected to be the main buyers of the up to 304 BNG units Report P3, 1.19, 1.21
- Network Rail, with whom a new access agreement will need to be negotiated because the existing 60 year agreement expires in 2037 and would cease on change of use Report P121, P122
- Coventry Outdoors and users of Plas Dol Y Moch, with a possible new Outdoor Education, Training and Wellbeing Hub on the site of the former clubhouse Report P6, 1.13, 1.15
Timeline
- First half of 2026: Planning application prepared and submitted for decision via Rugby Borough Council Report 4.1, P4
- Second half of 2026: Works could commence on site, subject to planning and legal agreements Report P4, 4.1
- End of 2027: All works expected to be complete and the site fully open to the public, subject to phasing Report 4.1
- Within 12 months of this report: Cabinet to consider a further decision on the proposed outdoor education, training and wellbeing hub Report 1.15, P82
- Up to 30 years: Duration of habitat management and monitoring under the BNG Conservation Covenant and Warwickshire Wildlife Trust arrangement Report P11, P19, 1.10, 1.18, P116, P120
- 2037: Expiry of the existing British Railways Board access agreement over the Network Rail bridge Report P122
Plain English for the jargon
- Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG): A mandatory requirement under the Environment Act 2021 for most new developments in England to deliver at least a 10% net gain in biodiversity, maintained for at least 30 years, often through the purchase of BNG units from habitat banks.
- BNG units: Standardised biodiversity credit units generated by creating and managing habitats, which developers buy to offset biodiversity loss from their developments. At Brandon Wood the council's model uses £25,000 per unit, with high value wetland units potentially selling for more than £50,000.
- Conservation Covenant: A legally binding agreement between a landowner and a responsible body, in this case Warwickshire County Council, to manage land for nature conservation for a set period, here 30 years.
- Habitat bank: A site created and registered to generate and sell BNG units to developers, providing a long term income stream for habitat creation and management.
- Natural Capital Investment Strategy (NCIS): A sub regional partnership between Warwickshire County Council, Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council and Coventry City Council to plan and manage BNG and emerging nature markets collaboratively.
- 30 by 30: A national target to conserve and manage 30% of the UK's land, inland waters, coasts and oceans for nature by 2030. Coventry currently sits at around 11%.
- Section 123 Local Government Act 1972: The statutory power under which local authorities dispose of land, which the council will rely on for the property transaction with Warwickshire Wildlife Trust Group.