CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Crawley Borough Council
Cabinet, Wednesday 24 November 2021 at 7.00pm

Crawley Homes Rent Overcharge

Agreed Executive 1 paper

Cabinet agreed this item on Wednesday 24 November 2021. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item9

Resolved

RESOLVED That the Cabinet: a) notes the reasons behind, and the actions being taken to rectify, the rent overcharge b) endorses that Full Council makes the necessary financial provision for both for the refund of rent and the lower income anticipated within the Housing Revenue Account in both the current and future years. The Cabinet recommends to Full Council to a) Note and comment on the reasons behind, and the actions being taken to rectify, the rent overcharge. b) Agree the necessary financial provision for both for the refund of rent and the lower income anticipated within the Housing Revenue Account in both the current and future years. The cost in the current and future financial years will result in less resource to fund future housing. e) Note that the cost of the refunds made to tenants/DWP will impact in the current financial year the sum that will be transferred to the major repairs reserve for investment in future housing stock. This will be in reported in the Quarter 3 Budget Monitoring Report. Reasons for the Recommendations a) In April 2021 the Council was contacted by the Regulator for Social Housing following a first mandatory data return about the setting of target rents. The Council was identified as an outlier in that its target rents were higher than the Government’s formula rent and valuations suggested they should be. b) Forensic investigation identified that the issue dates back to changes to the Tenancy Agreement agreed in October 2013 and implemented in April 2014. One of the changes implemented was to move from charging rent based on a 48-week year to a 52-week year. Actual rents were changed but the target rents on the system were not. This has affected 2,259 tenancies, of which 1,757 are current tenancies. c) Existing tenancies were not affected by this change, and neither have new tenancies within properties built since April 2014. New tenancies since April 2014 within properties that pre-date April 2014 have consequently been overcharged in the region of 8%. d) Tenants have paid the rent they would have signed up to pay as part of their Tenancy Agreement, but that rent level was set higher than it ought to have been. Given that rents have been set as part of a valid Tenancy Agreement and that all subsequent actions have been taken in line with that Tenancy Agreement, the Council has acted legally throughout. e) The Leader and Cabinet Member were informed at the end of April 2021 and were clear that this needed to be resolved consistent with natural justice and transparency, and as quickly as possible. The Leader of the Opposition Group was also informed and agreed this needed to be resolved in a way that had the least possible impact on residents, and that wider communication should be at a time when the Council was ready to rectify the problem. f) Given the scale and complexity of the issue it has taken a number of months to put everything in ...
Word for word from the decision Crawley published for this meeting. Source: democracy.crawley.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Crawley's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Recommendations

2.1To the Overview & Scrutiny Commission:

That the Commission consider the report and decide what comments, if any, it wishes to submit to the Cabinet

2.2The Cabinet is recommended to: a) Note and comment on the reasons behind, and the actions being taken to rectify, the rent overcharge

b) Endorse that Full Council makes the necessary financial provision for both for the refund of rent and the lower income anticipated within the Housing Revenue Account in both the current and future years

2.3Request Full Council to:

a) Note and comment on the reasons behind, and the actions being taken to rectify, the rent overcharge b) Agree the necessary financial provision for both for the refund of rent and the lower income anticipated within the Housing Revenue Account in both the current and future years. The cost in the current and future financial years will result in less resource to fund future housing.

c) Note that the cost of the refunds made to tenants/DWP will impact in the current financial year the sum that will be transferred to the major repairs reserve for investment in future housing stock. This will be in reported in the Quarter 3 Budget Monitoring Report

Reasons for the recommendations

3.1In April 2021 the Council was contacted by the Regulator for Social Housing following a first mandatory data return about the setting of target rents. The Council was identified as an outlier in that its target rents were higher than the Government’s formula rent and valuations suggested they should be.

3.2Forensic investigation identified that the issue dates back to changes to the Tenancy Agreement agreed in October 2013 and implemented in April 2014. One of the changes implemented was to move from charging rent based on a 48-week year to a 52-week year. Actual rents were changed but the target rents on the system were not. This has affected 2,259 tenancies, of which 1,757 are current tenancies.

3.3Existing tenancies were not affected by this change, and neither have new tenancies within properties built since April 2014. New tenancies since April 2014 within properties that pre-date April 2014 have consequently been overcharged in the region of 8%.

3.4Tenants have paid the rent they would have signed up to pay as part of their Tenancy Agreement, but that rent level was set higher than it ought to have been. Given that rents have been set as part of a valid Tenancy Agreement and that all subsequent actions have been taken in line with that Tenancy Agreement, the Council has acted legally throughout.

3.5The Leader and Cabinet Member were informed at the end of April 2021 and were clear that this needed to be resolved consistent with natural justice and transparency, and as quickly as possible. The Leader of the Opposition Group was also informed and agreed this needed to be resolved in a way that had the least possible impact on residents, and that wider communication should be at a time when the Council was ready to rectify the problem.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Crawley Homes Rent OverchargeReport 373 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

6 of 18 attended
PL
Councillor Peter LambChair, present
II
Councillor Ian IrvineCommittee Member, present
GS
Councillor Gurinder S JhansCommittee Member, present
MJ
Councillor Michael JonesCommittee Member, present
CM
Councillor Chris MullinsCommittee Member, present
PS
Councillor Peter SmithCommittee Member, present
NB
Natalie Brahma-PearlOfficer, in attendance
SC
Siraj ChoudhuryOfficer, expected
ID
Ian DukeOfficer, expected
KH
Karen HayesOfficer, in attendance
CP
Chris PedlowOfficer, in attendance
HG
Heather GirlingOfficer, expected

All 18 on the meeting page

On this subject at Crawley

Search all
  1. Crawley Homes Rent OverchargeThis decision
  2. Crawley Homes Complaints Performance and Service Improvement Plan 2026Approved
  3. Crawley Homes Asset StrategyApproved
  4. Crawley Homes Complaints Performance and Service Improvement Plan 2026Noted
  5. Crawley Homes Asset StrategyNoted
  6. Crawley Homes Pets PolicyApproved

More from Crawley Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
9 Sep 2026 Financial Outturn 2025-2026 (Quarter 4)RESOLVED That the Cabinet: a) notes the outturn for the financial year 2025/26 as summarised in report FIN/745 . b) a... Approved Open
9 Sep 2026 Treasury Management Outturn 2025 – 2026RESOLVED That the Cabinet: a) notes the Treasury Management Outturn 2025/2026 report FIN/746 . b) approves the actual... Approved Open
9 Sep 2026 2026-2027 Budget Monitoring - Quarter 1RESOLVED That the Cabinet notes the projected outturn for the financial year 2026/27 as summarised in report FIN/747 ... Approved Open
9 Sep 2026 Crawley Homes Complaints Performance and Service Improvement Plan 2026RESOLVED That the Cabinet: a) approves the Crawley Homes Annual Complaints Performance and Service Improvement Plan R... Approved Open
9 Sep 2026 Crawley Homes Asset StrategyRESOLVED That the Cabinet: a) approves the Crawley Homes Asset Management Strategy ( appendix A of report CH/222 ) fo... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies