That the application be refused for the following reasons: 1 The site is located within Flood zones 1, 2 and 3 and the proposal is identified as being more vulnerable in the NPPF. It is considered the detail submitted do not demonstrate that the requirements set out in paragraph 9 the Technical Guide to the National Planning Policy Framework are met . The proposal does not therefore accord with policy CS31 of the Core Strategy or the NPPF in terms of flood risk and impact. 2 In accordance with policy CS12 and CS27 of the adopted Core Strategy and policy 119 of the local plan, the scheme fails to demonstrate an acceptable relationship can be achieved in the built form that would not harm the character and setting of the adjacent listed building. 3 The scheme fails to demonstrate that an acceptable relationship in terms of adequate privacy can be achieved for future occupiers in accordance with policy CS12 of the adopted Core Strategy and saved Appendix 3 of the saved DBLP 1991-2011.
Word for word from the decision Dacorum published for this meeting.Source: democracy.dacorum.gov.uk
This application was brought to the Development Control Committee for consideration on 29th April 2015. The Committee resolved to defer making a decision on the application due to an outstanding objection from the Environment Agency. It was not resolved at that meeting in April that the two other issues (design and impact to listed building and privacy distances) were found to be acceptable by the members and as such the three reasons for refusal are still to be considered in full together with the other merits of the scheme.
Members should therefore consider the updated information below together with the committee report which was reported to the Development Contol committtee on 29th April which is also set out below.
Case officers Comments in response to information submitted following writing of committee report
Flood Risk and deculverting - Following on from the latest objection from the Environment Agency, the applicant has produced further modelling in association with the Flood Risk Assessment. The environment agency are reviewing the latest information and their comments will be available before the committee meeting. Until such time that the environment agency remove their objection, the reason for refusal remains relating to flood risk and deculverting of the site.
Privacy distances - the agent has produced a number of examples whereby he believes that lessened privacy distances of 23m have been allowed on other schemes in the Borough. This information has been taken into account however this does not overcome the reason for refusal relating to insufficient distance between the residential flats to allow for adequate privacy. It remains the view of the case officer that the distances provided between the blocks is inadequate to ensure sufficient privacy is maintained and indeed it is noted that on one such flat, a bedroom has no window. Also having adequate distance between the blocks of flats would ensure sufficient light levels to be achieved and a good quality layout. Whilst, it is appreciated that the scheme is outline with detailed design to be dealt with at reserved matters stage, it is still considered that the scheme fails to achieve adequate privacy for the future occupiers.
Impact to listed building - The information that has been submitted by the agent and architect has been taken into account by both the case officer and the conservation and design officer and the recommended reason for refusal remains. It is appreciated that the site previously contained bulky industrial buildings associated with the John Dickinson site and that the listed building once stood adjacent to large buildings, however, it is considered by the conservation officer that the context of the listed building has changed. It is considered that the scale, height and bulk of the proposed building fronting onto the London Road would detract from the setting of the listed building.
Letter from agent dated 26th April 2015 - reported to members on 29th April at DCC.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.