4/02084/17/FHA - REPLACE EXISTING GARAGE AND SUMMER HOUSE WITH OUTBUILDING TO PROVIDE NON-HABITABLE ANNEX WITH GARAGE AND NON COMMERCIAL ART STUDIO - 32 STOCKS ROAD, ALDBURY, TRING, HP23 5RU
RefusedCommittee2 papers
Development Management refused this item on Thursday 12 April 2018. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved That planning permission be REFUSED due to the following reasons: The proposed outbuilding by virtue of its scale, bulk, height and site coverage would be overly prominent, out of keeping and detrimental to the pattern of development of adjacent properties and the surrounding area. As such the proposed development would fail to comply with Policies CS11(b), CS12 (f), and CS12 (g) (iii-vi) of the Dacorum Borough Core Strategy (September 2013).
Word for word from the decision Dacorum published for this meeting.Source: democracy.dacorum.gov.uk
2.1The proposal will replace an existing summerhouse and garage providing a non- habitable outbuilding to serve no. 32. There are no objections in principle to this domestic ancillary outbuilding. The design would be compatible with the Conservation Area and the Chilterns Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty. There would be no harm to the residential amenity of the locality arising from its domestic non-residential use, with due weight to the relationship with the existing communal garden layout and the position of the adjoining dwellings. There are no other planning objections.
2.2The development would accord with Policies CS7, CS12, CS24 and CS27 of Dacorum Core Strategy.
3. Site Description
3.1No. 32 forms part of a terrace of 2 two storey 200 year old cottages (nos. 22 to 36 even) located parallel with but substantially set back from Stocks Road. The dwellings feature elongated front gardens with frontage hedging. Nos 32, 34 and 36 feature a large communal type rear garden. These units are served by a roadway/ combined with a public footpath/ bridleway linking Stocks Road with a rear parking and bin storage area. No. 32 is served by a garage and parking space. The roadway also serves other more modern dwellings in the immediate area.
4. Proposal
4.1This is for a single storey slate gable roof timber clad truncated 'L' shaped outbuilding to replace the existing garage and summerhouse located on part of their respective footprints. It would provide a garage and non-commercial art studio, with an associated toilet and boot room. The building would measure about 13.2m in length and 3.6m depth for the main part, with 'L' shape end / 'tail' about 5.6m. Its ridge level would be 3.3m with the roof featuring three conservation type rooflights.
4.2There are two flank wall windows serving the garage and boot room respectively facing into the communal garden.
4.3There is no proposed residential use, with building available for other domestic purposes. The Applicant has proposed a Unilateral Undertaking which would ensure that in perpetuity that the building is not used for residential purposes and converted into a separate self-contained residential unit.
The Original Scheme has been superseded by the Revised Scheme, involving several design changes :
All ground work will comply with BS 5837 2012. Trees in Relation to Design, Demolition & Construction. This will comprise of screw piling with suspended reinforced concrete slab & will include the protection procedures required to preserve and protect the adjacent mature beech tree during the course of the works.
Removal of the roof window over boot room on the west elevation, following the request by Conservation & Design.
Reduction in the building in height by 150mm by reducing the level of the slab. As there was no tree roots whatsoever found in the excavated layer suggesting the beech tree’s root system lays below the excavation depth. Under these circumstances it is feasible to lower the suspended reinforced concrete slab by 150mm with a resultant lower floor level.
5. Relevant Planning History
None.
6. Policies
6.1National Policy Guidance
National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) National Planning Policy Guidance (NPPG)
4/02084/17/FHA: REPLACE EXISTING GARAGE AND SUMMER HOUSE WITH OUTBUILDING TO PROVIDE NON-HABITABLE ANNEX WITH GARAGE AND NON COMMERCIAL ART STUDIO: 32 STOCKS ROAD, ALDBURY, TRING, HP23 5RUAppendix
2634/02084/17/FHA - REPLACE EXISTING GARAGE AND SUMMER HOUSE WITH OUTBUILDING TO PROVIDE NON-HABITABLE ANNEX WITH GARAGE AND NON COMMERCIAL ART STUDIO - 32 STOCKS ROAD, ALDBURY, TRING, HP23 5RUThis decision
4/02084/17/FHA - REPLACE EXISTING GARAGE AND SUMMER HOUSE WITH OUTBUILDING TO PROVIDE NON-HABITABLE ANNEX WITH GARAGE AND NON COMMERCIAL ART STUDIO - 32 STOCKS ROAD, ALDBURY, TRING, HP23 5RUThis decision
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.