CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Dacorum Borough Council
Development Management, Thursday 18 February 2021 at 6.30pm

4/02204/18/MFA - Old Silk Mill Brook Street Tring HP23 5EF

Refused Committee 3 papers

Development Management refused this item on Thursday 18 February 2021. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item5b

Resolved

That planning permission be REFUSED due to the following reasons: 1. The site lies within Flood Zone 3b (functional floodplain) which is defined by the South West Hertfordshire Level 1 Strategic Flood Risk Assessment March 2019 as having the highest probability of flooding. The development is classed as “more vulnerable” in accordance with table 2 of the Flood Zones and flood risk tables of the Planning Practice Guidance (PPG) Flood Risk and Coastal Change . Tables 1 and 3 make it clear that this type of development is not compatible with this Flood Zone and therefore should not be permitted. In accordance with the sequential approach of the National Planning Policy Framework, the development should be relocated to land with a lower risk of flooding. In accordance with the PPG, there is no case for an exception. The proposal is therefore contrary to National Planning Policy Framework and Policy CS31 of the Dacorum Core Strategy September 2013. 2. The Flood Risk Assessment (FRA) submitted in support of the application is not based on the most up to date available data, namely the South West Hertfordshire Strategic Flood Risk Assessment (SFRA) and its flood zone 3b allocation. An FRA is vital to making informed planning decisions. In the absence of an acceptable FRA, the flood risks posed by the development are not fully known and understood. The proposal is therefore contrary to the National Planning Policy Framework and Policy CS31 of the Dacorum Core Strategy September 2013. 3. The proposal would result in buildings being constructed over the culverted Long Marston Brook. The proposed building is for residential apartments and if there was a need to access the culvert this could create severe disruption to a residential area, and furthermore could result in flooding or other impacts in the area if for any reason the culvert were to become blocked and access could not be gained. The proposal is contrary to Policy 8 of the Hertfordshire Local Flood Risk Management Strategy 2 which states that “In principle, no construction works should occur on the top of a culvert” . The proposal would therefore be contrary to the National Planning Policy Framework which states that advice should be taken from the Lead Local Flood Authority ... view the full minutes text for item 5b
Word for word from the decision Dacorum published for this meeting. Source: democracy.dacorum.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Dacorum's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Management

Recommendation

1.1That planning permission be REFUSED.

Summary

2.1The application is recommended for refusal. The application is for the demolition of a semi-detached pair of houses and the erection of 41 extra care apartments within a 3 storey block with undercroft car parking and access from Brook Street. The site is part of a General Employment area, the majority of which is a vacant, undeveloped site. Together with the two residential properties, it comprises a generally rectangular site which sits substantially below the level of dwellings immediately to the west at Kingsley Walk. The intervening land comprises a steep earth embankment which will be cut back and supported by a retaining wall to enable the development to take place. Landscape margins are proposed to the Brook Street and northern frontages with tree planting at podium level on the western boundary.

2.2In principle, the loss of the employment land is considered acceptable as the majority is not currently in active employment use whilst the loss of the small commercial unit would not have a significant impact on the functionality or viability of the business park or GEA, and should be balanced against a more efficient use of the land for residential purposes, the use for which is considered appropriate given the dwellings at 21 and 22 Brook Street and the siting adjacent to existing housing.

2.3The loss of the two semi-detached dwellings of 21 and 22 Brook Street is considered to have a low level of significance in conservation terms and is not objectionable. There would be no harm to the setting of The Old Silk Mill Grade II listed buildings and in design terms, subject to details by condition, the Conservation Officer has raised no objection to the height and appearance of the development which would reflect the scale, mass and form of the Silk Mill buildings whilst respecting the design and materials of the terraced dwellings opposite.

2.4Car parking is acceptable and there would be no material detriment to highway safety. The impact on adjoining residential amenity in terms of privacy, light and visual appearance is acceptable.

2.5Since the resolution to grant planning permission in May 2019, which was subject to the completion of an s106 agreement, there have been a number of material changes in circumstance. In particular, following the recent publication of the South West Herts Strategic Flood Risk Assessment, part of the site now lies within Flood Risk Zone 3b, land with the highest risk of flooding, and comprising the functional floodplain. The classification of residential development as being “more vulnerable” means that on this basis alone, in accordance with the NPPF and the associated Planning Practice Guidance on flood risk, the development should not be permitted. The Environment Agency recommend refusal on this ground and advise that the layout should be amended to avoid it.

2.6The addition of objections from the Lead Local Flood Authority on the grounds of building over the culverted Long Marston Brook, contrary to its policy and advice, and harm to the water environment and sustainable drainage principles, only serves to exacerbate the environmental harm from this development, contrary to NPPF guidance.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
4/02204/18/MFA: Old Silk Mill Brook Street Tring HP23 5EFReport 559 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
DMC: 18 Feb: 21: Item 5b DMC Report Old Silk Mill Appendix C (part 1)Appendix 848 KB Download
PDF
DMC: 18 Feb: 21: Item 5b DMC Report Old Silk Mill Appendix CAppendix 829 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

On this subject at Dacorum

Search all
  1. 4/02204/18/MFA - Old Silk Mill Brook Street Tring HP23 5EFThis decision
  2. 4/02934/18/mfa - demolition of existing buildings and redevelopment of the land for 17 residential apartments within a mansion block with associated, vehicular access, car parking, landscaping and engineering works. - the old orchard, shootersway, berkhamsted, hp4 3ngRefused
  3. 4/02204/18/mfa - demolition of existing buildings. construction of extra care scheme comprising 41 no. apartments with associated landscaping and parking. - old silk mill, brook street, tring, hp235efApproved

More from Dacorum Development Management

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
10 Sep 2026 25/02075/FUL Proposed change of use from 1no. dwellinghouse operating within Use Class C3 to 1no. Small Residential Care Home operating within Use Class C2That planning permission be GRANTED. RECOMMENDATION That planning permission be GRANTED subject to the conditions set... Approved Open
13 Aug 2026 26/01005/FUL Construction of dwelling (self build) and associated landscaping at Land adjacent 25 Peter's Place 25 Peters Place, Northchurch, Berkhamsted, HertfordshireThat planning permission be DELEGATED with a VIEW TO APPROVAL . RECOMMENDATION That planning permission be DELEGATED ... Approved Open
13 Aug 2026 26/00379/FUL Installation of Timpson Key Cutting Kiosk to hardstanding adjacent to Tesco Superstore TESCO, London Road, Tring, HertfordshireThat planning permission be GRANTED. RECOMMENDATION That planning permission be GRANTED. Condition(s) and Reason(s): ... Approved Open
16 Jul 2026 26/00885/FUL Creation of Two Additional Gypsy/Traveller Pitches comprising a single mobile home and Touring Caravan and Construction of a Shared Day Room Land on the North Western side of Green Lane, MarkyateThat planning permission be DELEGATED with a VIEW TO APPROVAL . RECOMMENDATION It is recommended that planning permis... Approved Open
16 Jul 2026 25/01407/ROC Variation of Condition 2 (Approved Plans) attached to planning permission 22/02538/FUL (Replacement Dwelling) allowed on appeal under APP/A1910/W/23/3327060 Frithsden Vineyard, Frithsden Lane, Frithsden, Hemel Hempstead, Hertfordshire, HP1 3DDThat planning permission be GRANTED. RECOMMENDATION That planning permission be GRANTED, subject to the below conditi... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies