AI summaryEast Devon Planning Committee minded to refuse outline scheme for 9 homes at West Hill, citing countryside location, tree loss, biodiversity harm and no signed affordable housing deal. The applicant has appealed, so the Planning Inspectorate will decide.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedTo be recommended to the Planning Inspectorate after appeal
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextPlanning Inspectorate appealPrecise refusal wording delegated to Assistant Director
Who it affectsWest Hill, land at EastfieldOutline for 9 dwellings, 4 of which affordable
What was decided
The Committee adopted the Appropriate Assessment under the Habitats Regulations.
Members resolved they were minded to refuse planning permission, with the final wording delegated to the Assistant Director for Planning Strategy and Development Management.
The four minded refusal reasons cover countryside location, tree loss, biodiversity harm, and the absence of a signed Section 106 agreement for affordable housing.
Why
The site lies outside the Built-up Area Boundary of West Hill, conflicting with Local Plan strategies on the spatial strategy, scale of development, settlement boundaries and countryside protection. Report P47, P179, P201, P206
The Council's Ecologist advised the development would result in a quantified net loss of habitats mapped as Priority Habitat and degrade a Strategic Nature Area, though a 10 percent Biodiversity Net Gain is proposed through an offsite habitat bank. Report P17, P18, P25, P32, P33
No signed Section 106 obligation has been provided to deliver the 4 affordable dwellings or the Pebblebed Heaths mitigation contribution. Report P185, P95
What happens next
The Council will notify the Planning Inspectorate that members were minded to refuse; the Inspector will determine the appeal against non-determination. Report P12
The precise wording of the four refusal reasons is delegated to the Assistant Director for Planning Strategy and Development Management.
Public speaking was not reopened on this deferred application. Report P12
Options considered
Rejected: Officer recommendation: grant outline permission with conditions, subject to Section 106 and Appropriate Assessment.. Committee took a different view from officers, supported by the ward member and parish council, and resolved minded refusal on countryside, tree, biodiversity and Section 106 grounds. Report P5, P10, P39, P55
Chosen: Minded to refuse, with reasons delegated to the Assistant Director.
Implications
Legal: Decision is effectively a recommendation to the Planning Inspectorate, which will determine the non-determination appeal rather than the Council. Report P12
Legal: Committee noted the tilted balance in the National Planning Policy Framework, because the District can only show 2.97 years of housing land supply against a 5 year requirement. Report P48, P51, P212, P220
Climate: Ecologist's assessment records a net loss of 9.29 percent in area biodiversity units, offset by an offsite habitat bank and an 8.87 percent net gain in hedgerow units. Report P25, P33
Risk: Parish Council warned that approving development outside the Built-up Area Boundary would set a precedent for further countryside schemes around West Hill. Report P80
Other: Housing Strategy officer objected that the site is not allocated in the neighbourhood plan and is not community led, with no up to date parish housing needs survey. Report P114, P115, P116, P117, P118
Who and where
The applicant, who has lodged an appeal against non-determination. Report P12
West Hill Parish Council, which objected to both the original and amended scheme. Report P58, P83, P87
The ward member for West Hill and Aylesbeare, who objected. Report P88, P96
12 residents and objectors who raised concerns on trees, traffic, infrastructure and countryside character. Report P125, P126, P127
Future occupants of the proposed 4 affordable dwellings, whose delivery is dependent on a Section 106 agreement. Report P4
Timeline
19.02.2025: West Hill Parish Council first considered the application and objected. Report P58
19.05.2025: Parish Council considered the amended layout and maintained its objection. Report P84
19.08.2025: Planning Committee first considered the application and deferred pending the Council Ecologist's consultation response. Report P14
After October 2025: Applicant appealed against non-determination, removing the Council's ability to determine the application itself. Report P12
21.10.2025: Application further deferred for a site visit. Report P12
18.11.2025: Committee adopted the Appropriate Assessment and resolved minded refusal, to be relayed to the Planning Inspectorate. Report P6
Plain English for the jargon
Built-up Area Boundary (BUAB): The line on the Local Plan that defines where development is considered acceptable in a settlement.
Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG): A requirement for development to leave biodiversity in a better state than before, with a mandatory 10 percent target.
Section 106 Agreement: A legal planning obligation between a developer and the Council, used here to secure affordable housing and habitat mitigation.
Tilted balance: The presumption in favour of sustainable development in the National Planning Policy Framework that applies when a Council cannot show a 5 year housing land supply.
Tree Preservation Order (TPO): A legal order protecting specified trees from being cut down, topped or damaged without consent.
Habitat Management and Monitoring Plan (HMMP): A plan setting out how created or enhanced habitats will be managed and monitored, typically for 30 years.
Appropriate Assessment: An assessment under the Habitats Regulations of the impact of a plan or project on protected European sites such as the East Devon Pebblebed Heaths.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item49
Resolved
The Appropriate Assessment be adopted. RECOMMENDED: That the Council advises the Planning Inspectorate that members were minded to refuse planning permission for the following reasons set out below, with the precise wording to be delegated to the Assistant Director – Planning Strategy and Development Management: 1. Outside the built-up area boundary, contrary to Strategies 1, 2, 6 and 7 of the East Devon Local Plan 2. Loss of trees and future pressure to fell trees adversely impacting on the amenity and wooded character of the area, contrary to D1, D3 and NP26 of the East Devon Local Plan. 3. Adverse impact on protected species and biodiversity. 4. In the absence of a signed Section 106 Agreement, no mechanism to deliver affordable housing.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk
Applicant [name removed] Land Adjoining West Hayes Eastfield West Hill EX11 1GG
Proposal Outline application for the erection of 9 dwellings, including 4 affordable dwellings and associated parking. Approval sought for access, appearance, layout and scale (matters reserved: landscaping)
RECOMMENDATION: That the Council recommend to the Planning Inspectorate that planning permission be granted with conditions, subject to completion of s.106 obligations to secure affordable housing provision (including off site financial contribution), and adoption of an Appropriate Assessment
Crown Copyright and database rights 2025 Ordnance Survey 100023746 Committee Date: 18.11.2025
West Hill And Target Date: Aylesbeare 25/0057/OUT 27.03.2025 (West Hill)
Applicant: [name removed]: Land Adjoining West Hayes Eastfield West Hill
Proposal: Outline application for the erection of 9 dwellings, including 4 affordable dwellings and associated parking. Approval sought for access, appearance, layout and scale (matters reserved: landscaping)
RECOMMENDATION: That the Council recommend to the Planning Inspectorate that planning permission be granted with conditions, subject to completion of s.106 obligations to secure affordable housing provision (including off site financial contribution), and adoption of an Appropriate Assessment
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY UPDATE 18/11/2015
This application was further deferred for a site visit on the meeting of 21st October 2025. The applicant has now appealed against non-determination of the application; as such the Council cannot determine this application but instead needs to resolve what recommendation should be made to the Planning Inspectorate.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY – UPDATE 21/10/2015
This application was considered at the meeting of the Planning Committee held on 19th August. However, a resolution was deferred pending the submission of consultation comments from the Council's Ecologist.
These have now been received and, in the light of issues raised, an addendum to the applicant's ecological consultants' Ecological Impact Assessment (EcIA) in the form of a Technical Note, a Lighting Review Statement and revised Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG) Statutory Biodiversity Metric have also since been submitted.
These have been the subject of further consultation with the Council's Ecologist, whose comments are summarised in the following paragraphs.
The Technical Note and EcIA acknowledge that the development would result in
25/0057/OUT biodiversity net loss of habitats. The site is mapped as a Priority Habitat, which are habitats considered of principal importance for the purpose of conserving or enhancing biodiversity, under Section 41 of the Natural Environment and Rural Communities Act (2006). The site was discounted from the local plan site selection partly based on the designation of woodland habitat.
However, it should be recognised that the southern parts of the site consist of hardstanding and grassland and unlikely to be considered as a Priority Habitat.
The EcIA expands upon the site's habitats varying between grassland and scrub and it is advised that it had been grazed for over 20 years. Satellite image shows that between 2016 and 2018 the wooded nature of the site was reduced. For BNG purposes, under the mandatory framework only habitat changes made on or after January 2020 would be considered.
The applicant proposes to offset the losses of habitats and deliver 10% BNG using a habitat bank located outside of Honiton. The habitat bank is not currently registered on the Natural England offsite register, but it is envisaged that it would be by the end of this year.
The EcIA and Technical Note consider, despite the habitat losses, the proposed tree, hedge and scrub planting would maintain habitat connectivity to the nearby offsite areas of woodland and non-statutory designated wildlife sites.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
26/0534/MOUT (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. Approved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation subject ...
26/0535/MFUL (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. That the SANGS application be approved, subject to conditions and to the co...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.