AI summaryEast Devon planners approve outline scheme for three detached homes on a Lympstone car park site, against parish and councillor objections, with an extra foul drainage capacity condition.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedGranted with an extra foul drainage condition
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextReserved matters to be submittedWithin three years, then begin within two years
Who it affectsNot stated
What was decided
The Planning Committee approved the outline application in line with the officer recommendation, but added a condition requiring evidence of adequate foul drainage capacity before any of the new homes can be occupied. Report P142
The site already has an extant consent for one 690 square metre dwelling, and the new approval allows three two-storey detached dwellings with a 15% increase in floor area to about 795 square metres. Report P3, P4, P75
Officers weighed the scheme against the tilted balance in the NPPF, citing East Devon's 3.5 year housing land supply and past appeal decisions that found development on the site would not harm the Green Wedge. Report P8, P64, P76, P77, P86
Why
Inspectors on earlier appeals for the site found the proposals would have a negligible impact on the Green Wedge, would not lead to sporadic or isolated development, and would not encourage settlement coalescence. Report P76, P77, P85
The new scheme would break the large first floor element of the approved single dwelling into smaller sections, which officers said would better reflect the varied pattern of development at the settlement edge. Report P5, P84, P86
Environmental Health was satisfied once a Calculation of Railway Noise Assessment was submitted, subject to a Construction and Environment Management Plan condition. Report P18, P96, P97
What happens next
Reserved matters for layout, scale, access, appearance and landscaping must be submitted to the council for approval before any development begins. Report P143, P145
Conditions require a Construction and Environment Management Plan, cycle storage details, soakaway based surface water drainage, a 1.8 metre trespass proof fence to Network Rail land, and compliance with the submitted Ecological Impact Assessment. Report P149, P152, P154, P157, P159
A separate condition, added at committee, blocks occupation of any dwelling until evidence shows the foul drainage system can cope, with upgrades completed if needed.
Options considered
Chosen: Approve the outline application with the officer's conditions. Site has extant consent for one dwelling, tilted balance applies, officers judged no significant harm to Green Wedge Report P8, P64, P86, P141
Rejected: Refuse the application. Parish Council and two ward councillors objected on Green Wedge, scale and traffic grounds, but officers considered the harms did not outweigh the benefits under the tilted balance Report P12, P13, P14, P16, P24, P139, P140
Implications
Legal: Permission is granted in outline with all matters reserved, and conditions remove various permitted development rights to control future extensions, outbuildings and boundary treatments. Report P52, P162, P164, P166
Equalities: No equalities implications are identified in the officer report. Report P132, P133
Climate: Surface water must drain via soakaways sized for a 1 in 100 year storm plus 45% for climate change, with a 10% uplift for urban creep, and water butts of at least 110 litres per bedroom are required. Report P159, P168, P169
Risk: The added foul drainage condition is intended to prevent capacity problems once homes are built, with no occupation allowed until upgrades are completed if needed.
Risk: A 1.8 metre trespass proof fence must be installed along the Network Rail boundary, and soakways must stay at least 5 metres from railway land. Report P130, P131, P154
Who and where
Parish and ward councillors for Woodbury and Lympstone, who objected Report P12, P13, P14, P16, P209, P212
Six objectors and one supporter from the local community Report P22, P24, P26
Residents of Underhill Close, including properties at No. 3 and No. 8 Report P49, P81, P94
Network Rail, as neighbour to the site Report P20, P128, P130
Future residents of the three new dwellings Report P56, P94
Timeline
29.01.1980: Application 79/C1826 for two chalet dwellings refused Report P29
27.11.2015: Outline application 15/1838/OUT for four dwellings withdrawn Report P30
02.11.2018: Outline application 18/1995/OUT for a single dwelling refused Report P31
19.03.2021: Outline applications 20/0933/OUT and 20/0945/OUT refused Report P33, P34
01.03.2022: Appeal allowed for a predominantly single storey dwelling (ref APP/U1105/W/21/3282445) Report P35
21.07.2023: Reserved matters approval 22/2410/RES for the single dwelling Report P36
14.08.2025: Approval of 25/1114/FUL for a new dwelling with annexe on the same site Report P41
2026-02-09: Planning Committee approves outline application 25/1601/OUT for three dwellings with extra foul drainage condition
Plain English for the jargon
BuAB: Built up Area Boundary, the settlement limit used in East Devon's Local Plan
Green Wedge: An area of land between settlements where development is restricted to prevent coalescence
Tilted balance: NPPF paragraph 11d test where permission should be granted unless adverse impacts significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefits
Reserved matters: Details of layout, scale, appearance, access and landscaping that can be approved after an outline permission
CEMP: Construction and Environment Management Plan, a document controlling how building works are carried out
BNG: Biodiversity Net Gain, a requirement for developments to deliver at least a 10% increase in habitat value
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item74
Resolved
Approved in accordance with officer recommendation subject to an additional condition to require evidence that there is adequate capacity in the foul drainage system to accommodate these additional dwellings. If capacity cannot be evidenced then no dwelling shall be occupied until any identified system upgrades have been completed.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk
The application must be considered by the Planning Committee because the officer recommendation is in conflict with comments received from the Parish Council and the Ward Councillor.
The site lies on the southern edge of Lympstone, immediately adjacent to, but outside of the BuAB as defined by both the adopted Local Plan and the emerging Local Plan. The site is also located within a Green Wedge as defined by the Local Plan, and close to but not within the Coastal Preservation Area.
The site has a long planning history with outline approval being granted for a predominately single storey dwelling on appeal in 2022. The site now benefits from an extant consent to construct a 690 square metre dwelling.
Outline approval is sought for the three two storey detached dwellings on the site. The proposal would allow for a more efficient use of land, through the provision of three homes instead of one, with the illustrative scheme indicating a 15% increase in floor area from 690 square metres to a total of 795 square metres for the three dwellings.
In previous appeals for the site, Inspectors have considered that the proposed dwelling would have a negligible impact upon the Green Wedge, and that the proposal would be seen against the context of varied scales and styles on the edge of the settlement. Although the extant approval is for a predominately single storey dwelling, the first floor of the approved scheme measures 22 metres long by 8.5 metres wide, and in comparison the proposed scheme indicates a similar quantum of development at first floor level but broken up into smaller elements that would be more in keeping with the surrounding pattern and character of development.
25/1601/OUT As with the extant approved scheme, the proposed dwellings would also have limited visibility from publicly accessible locations due to the low built form, existing vegetation and site topography. The proposal would therefore have a low landscape impact, and in terms of the Green Wedge, would not lead to sporadic or isolated development, or encourage settlement coalescence.
Previous appeals at the site have also stated that the site lies a short walk from Lympstone's amenities and therefore despite its position outside of the BuAB, the site would comply with Local Plan Policy TC2.
EDDC's housing land supply position engages the presumption in favour of sustainable development, whereby permission for development proposals should be granted unless the adverse impacts of granting permission would significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefits of the scheme. The NPPF supports development that makes efficient use of land, and the proposal would provide three house on the site rather than one. The proposal complies with policies contained within the Local Plan and the NPPF, and in respect of the tilted balance, it is not considered there would be any adverse impacts of granting permission.
As such, the application is recommended for approval.
CONSULTATIONS
Local Consultations
Parish/Town Council Objection - The site is outside the BUAB, in the Green Wedge and is potentially harmful to the landscape and surrounding neighbours. The continued use of the site as a car parking would be preferred.
Woodbury And Lympstone - Cllr Geoff Jung Objection - Increasing the development footprint in this prominent location is not supported.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
26/0534/MOUT (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. Approved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation subject ...
26/0535/MFUL (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. That the SANGS application be approved, subject to conditions and to the co...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.