CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
East Devon District Council
Planning Committee, Tuesday 24 February 2026 at 10.00am

25/0368/MFUL (Major) WEST HILL & AYLESBEARE

Refused Planning 1 paper

AI summaryEast Devon planners refuse four-dwelling scheme at Rosamondford Farm, Perkins Village, citing harm to rural character, unsustainable location and no public benefit over a prior approval.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeRefusedPlanning Committee, against officer recommendation
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextRight of appealApplicant may appeal the refusal
Who it affectsFour detached dwellings refusedReplacement of agricultural barn at Perkins Village

What was decided

The Planning Committee refused planning application 25/0368/MFUL for four detached dwellings at Rosamondford Farm, Perkins Village, as recommended by officers. Report P156

Officers concluded the previous Class Q prior approval could not be relied on as a realistic fallback because it expired on 13 February 2026 and no Regulation 77 application had been made. Report P2, P58, P59, P61, P150

The committee accepted officers' view that the proposed scheme was too large, suburban in layout and would harm the rural character of the countryside location. Report P4, P76, P77, P157

Why

The site is in the countryside outside any Built-up Area Boundary, and the proposed site area is three and a half times the size of the prior approval red line, with no public betterment over the fallback scheme. Report P3, P56, P79, P84, P152

The proposed dwellings would have large glazed gables and a suburban arrangement unsympathetic to local rural character, with a 35% increase in floor area over the approved scheme. Report P76, P77, P78

The location is poorly related to services and the nearest bus stop is 1km away on an unlit route, making the development car-dependent and contrary to sustainable development and accessibility policies. Report P92, P93, P94, P158

What happens next

The applicant has a right of appeal to the Planning Inspectorate against the refusal. Report P156

Officers noted the Class Q prior approval expires on 13 February 2026, after which the fallback position would lapse entirely. Report P2, P46, P150

Options considered

  • Rejected: Approve the four detached dwellings. Contrary to countryside, design and sustainability policies with harm to rural character and no public benefit over the prior approval fallback Report P85, P96, P154, P155, P156, P157, P158

Implications

  • Legal: A European protected species licence for bats was unlikely to be granted as the development was not in the public interest, raising potential Article 12 issues. Report P111, P114, P118, P121
  • Equalities:
  • Climate: The remote location would increase reliance on private vehicles, contrary to sustainable transport policies and the spatial strategy. Report P86, P87, P88, P89, P91, P92, P94, P96
  • Risk: East Devon's housing land supply stands at 3.5 years, triggering the tilted balance, but officers considered adverse impacts significantly and demonstrably outweighed the benefits. Report P5, P67, P68, P154
  • Other: The proposed site is 12,604 square metres, three and a half times the 3,600 square metre prior approval red line, with no public enhancements offered. Report P79, P84
  • Other: Aylesbeare Parish Council supported the application, contrary to the officer recommendation which led to the matter being heard by the Planning Committee. Report P1, P9

Who and where

  • The applicant seeking four detached dwellings on the site Report P47, P49, P156
  • Existing residents of Perkins Village and the surrounding hamlet Report P100, P101
  • Common pipistrelle and soprano pipistrelle bats using the main barn as a day roost Report P111, P208
  • Future residents who would have relied on car travel given the remote location Report P92, P94

Timeline

  • 15.11.2022: Retrospective application for enlarged field gate approved under 22/1471/FUL Report P31
  • 13.02.2023: Class Q prior approval for conversion of agricultural barn to five dwellings granted under 22/2796/PDQ Report P30, P59
  • 13.06.2023: New main entrance and access track approved under 23/0430/FUL Report P32
  • 21.05.2024: General Permitted Development Order amended to require nationally described space standards Report P61
  • 12.12.2024: Revised National Planning Policy Framework published, reducing housing land supply to 3.5 years Report P67
  • 13.02.2026: Class Q prior approval expires Report P2, P46, P150
  • 24.02.2026: Planning Committee refuses application 25/0368/MFUL

Plain English for the jargon

  • Class Q: Permitted development right allowing conversion of agricultural buildings to residential use without full planning permission, subject to prior approval.
  • Fallback position: An existing or permitted use that an applicant could rely on if a new application is refused, weighed as a material consideration.
  • BuAB: Built-up Area Boundary, defining the edge of settlements where certain forms of development are permitted by local plan policy.
  • Tilted balance: The presumption in favour of sustainable development under NPPF paragraph 11d that applies where a council cannot demonstrate a five-year housing land supply.
  • BNG: Biodiversity Net Gain, a requirement for developments to deliver a measurable improvement in biodiversity, currently set at 10%.
  • Regulation 77: Approval under the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017 required before Class Q development may begin.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item84

Resolved

RESOLVED : Refused as per officer recommendation.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting. Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from East Devon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

Executive summary

This application must be considered by the Planning Committee because the officer recommendation is in conflict with comments received from the Parish Council.

The application seeks approval for four detached dwellings using the previous Class Q approval as a fallback position. The relevant case law clarifies that the fall-back position will only be a material consideration if there is a realistic prospect of the Class Q permission being implemented. Given that the existing prior approval expires on 13th February 2026 it is not considered that the fall back is a realistic prospect. It is not clear that the prior approval scheme previously approved would comply with the requirements of the General Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015 as amended on 21/02/2024 which requires dwellings to comply with the Nationally Described Minimum Space Standards in terms of dwelling area and minimum headroom. As such it is not considered that the fall back position could be relied upon.

Irrespective of the fall back position however, the proposal gives rise to a number of concerns regarding wider negative impacts. The proposed application site is three and a half times larger than that of the prior approval red line site boundary, and in the absence of any public enhancements or benefits of the scheme over the fall back position, there is no fall back position for this extent of development on a plot of this size. There is therefore no overriding material consideration upon which to base any departure from local plan policy.

In comparison to the previous grant of prior approval scheme, the proposal would lead to harm to the character and appearance of the area through the suburban character of the proposed development, and large expanses of glazing in contrast to the low form and agricultural nature of the existing buildings.

25/0368/MFUL In terms of the presumption in favour of sustainable development, the moderate benefit of adding four additional dwellings to the housing supply and the benefits of the proposal to the local economy attract moderate weight in favour of the proposal. In the absence of a fall back position the proposal would not be in a suitable location having regard to the development plan policies aimed at ensuring the accessibility and sustainability of new residential development. The proposal would also be in conflict with polices that require development to respect the key characteristics of the area. As such the adverse impacts of granting permission would significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefits of the proposal.

Given the above, the proposal would be contrary to policies contained within the Local Plan and is therefore recommended for refusal.

CONSULTATIONS

Local Consultations

Parish/Town Council Aylesbeare Parish Council supports this application.

Technical Consultations

Exeter & Devon Airport - Airfield Operations+Safeguarding No safeguarding objections

County Highway Authority No objection subject to conditions requiring a CEMP and secure cycle storage

Contaminated Land Officer No objection

DCC Flood Risk Management Team

24.04.2025 – Objection

23.07.2025 – Objection

12.02.2026 – No objection subject to condition

EDDC District Ecologist

20.06.2025 - Objection

03.09.2025 – Objection

25/0368/MFUL 20.11.2025 – Objection

Natural England

No objection

Environmental Health

No objection subject to a condition upon site working hours

EDDC Trees

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
25/0368/MFUL (Major) WEST HILL & AYLESBEAREReport 819 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

13 of 28 attended
AB
Councillor Aurora BaileyGuest, in attendance
BB
Councillor Brian BaileyCommittee Member, present
IB
Councillor Ian BarlowCommittee Member, present
NB
Nigel BarrettOfficer, in attendance
KB
Councillor Kim BloxhamCommittee Member, apologies
CB
Councillor Colin BrownCommittee Member, present
SC
Councillor Sarah ChamberlainCommittee Member, absent
MC
Councillor Maddy ChapmanCommittee Member, present
BC
Councillor Bethany CollinsCommittee Member, present
RC
Councillor Roy CollinsGuest, in attendance
AC
Amanda CoombesOfficer, in attendance
OD
Councillor Olly DaveyChair, present

All 28 on the meeting page

On this subject at East Devon

Search all
  1. 25/0368/MFUL (Major) WEST HILL & AYLESBEAREThis decision
  2. 26/0535/MFUL (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREApproved
  3. 25/0965/MFUL (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEARERefused
  4. 24/0841/MFUL (Major) HONITON ST PAULSRefused
  5. 25/2397/MFUL (Major) & 25/2398/LBC EXMOUTH TOWNApproved
  6. 25/1259/MFUL (Major) HONITON ST MICHAELSApproved

More from East Devon Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
1 Sep 2026 25/2471/MRES (Major) CRANBROOKApproved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation. Approved Open
1 Sep 2026 26/1143/PIP (Other) CLYST VALLEYThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. Permission in Principle be approved. Approved Open
1 Sep 2026 26/0854/FUL (Minor) BROADCLYSTApproved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation. Approved Open
1 Sep 2026 26/0534/MOUT (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. Approved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation subject ... Approved Open
1 Sep 2026 26/0535/MFUL (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. That the SANGS application be approved, subject to conditions and to the co... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies