CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
East Devon District Council
Planning Committee, Tuesday 12 May 2026 at 10.00am

25/2468/MOUT (Major) OTTERY ST MARY

Refused Planning 1 paper

AI summaryEast Devon Planning Committee refused outline permission for 140 homes at Gerway Farm, Ottery St Mary, against officer advice, citing countryside location, loss of agricultural land and lack of a legal agreement.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeRefusedFour broad reasons; final wording delegated to officers
MoneyNHS requested £44,600Section 106 healthcare contribution requested by Royal Devon trust
What happens nextReasons for refusal to be draftedExact wording delegated to officers; appeal possible
Who it affectsUp to 140 dwellings proposedAround 7 hectares of agricultural land on southern edge of town

What was decided

Outline planning permission for up to 140 homes on land adjacent to Gerway Nurseries, Ottery St Mary, was refused, contrary to the recommendation of officers to approve. Report P7

The final wording of the four reasons for refusal was delegated to officers.

Why

The site lies outside the built-up area boundary and extending development west would harm the rural character of the area, contrary to Strategy 46 and Policy D1 of the Local Plan, the National Planning Policy Framework and the Neighbourhood Plan. Report P2, P103

The development would lead to the loss of best and most versatile agricultural land without an overriding need being demonstrated, contrary to Policy EN13. Report P2, P5

The scheme conflicts with the spatial strategy that focuses development in East Devon's West End and limits growth in Ottery St Mary to local needs, contrary to Strategies 1, 2 and 7. Report P3, P101

Without a legal mechanism to secure the Section 106 heads of terms, the impacts of the development cannot be fully mitigated or considered policy compliant.

What happens next

Officers will draft the exact wording of the refusal reasons.

The applicant may appeal the refusal to the Planning Inspectorate within the usual time limit; no appeal is recorded in the papers.

The money

  • £44,600 Section 106 healthcare contribution requested by Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust Report P40, P41

Options considered

  • Rejected: Approve with Section 106 agreement and Appropriate Assessment (officer recommendation). Members considered the harm to countryside, agricultural land and policy conflict outweighed the benefits, and no Section 106 was in place Report P7
  • Chosen: Refuse planning permission (member motion). Conflict with development plan, loss of best and most versatile agricultural land, unsustainable countryside location and absence of a Section 106 agreement

Implications

  • Legal: Application refused as a departure from the Local Plan; the applicant may lodge an appeal and the Neighbourhood Plan policy on countryside development will be a material consideration. Report P1, P3, P79
  • Financial: The requested £44,600 Section 106 contribution for healthcare, and contributions for transport, public rights of way, ecology and archaeology, will not be secured through this application. Report P4, P40, P41
  • Equalities: 140 homes, including 56 affordable units, will not be delivered through this application, in a district with a 3.5 year housing land supply shortfall. Report P3, P4, P7
  • Climate: Loss of best and most versatile agricultural land on roughly 7 hectares and increased reliance on private cars from a car-dependent countryside site were weighed against the climate emergency declared by the council. Report P2, P14, P97
  • Risk: Holding objections from the council's Landscape Architect, concerns about sewage capacity at Fluxton WwTW, and an initially unresolved archaeological objection were cited as harms. Report P5, P12, P23, P61

Who and where

  • The applicant seeking outline permission for up to 140 dwellings Report P2
  • The Ward Member for Ottery St Mary, who objected on countryside, agricultural land, highway, drainage, landscape and density grounds Report P10, P11, P12, P13, P14
  • The Devon County Councillor for the Otter Valley, who objected on highway safety, public rights of way, ecology, trees and flood risk grounds Report P15, P16, P17, P18
  • Ottery St Mary Town Council, which strongly objected on highways, infrastructure, countryside location and wastewater grounds Report P19, P20, P21
  • 588 objectors and 5 supporters who submitted written representations, mainly on traffic, wastewater, landscape, density and infrastructure Report P5, P64, P66, P67
  • Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust, which requested an unfunded £44,600 healthcare contribution Report P39, P40, P41
  • Future residents, including 56 affordable homes and roughly 35 primary and 21 secondary school-age children forecast by Devon County Council Report P4, P26

Timeline

  • 9 January 2026: Devon County Council Education response, finding sufficient primary and secondary school capacity and no contribution required Report P26
  • 14 January 2026: South West Water full consultation response, raising no objection subject to conditions Report P27
  • 13 March 2026: Written Scheme of Investigation for archaeology submitted, leading to the Historic Environment Team withdrawing its objection Report P24
  • April 2026: Revised Flood Risk Assessment and Drainage Strategy submitted, leading the Lead Local Flood Authority to withdraw its objection Report P29, P30
  • 24.04.2026: Environmental Impact Assessment Screening Opinion issued, finding the development is not EIA development and no Environmental Statement required Report P73
  • 12 May 2026: Planning Committee considered and refused the application, against officer recommendation

Plain English for the jargon

  • BUAB: Built-Up Area Boundary, the line defining the edge of a settlement for planning purposes
  • Best and Most Versatile agricultural land: Land graded 1, 2 or 3a, which planning policy aims to protect from development
  • Section 106 agreement: A legal agreement between a developer and the local council used to secure planning obligations such as affordable housing or contributions
  • Tilted balance: The presumption in favour of sustainable development in paragraph 11(d) of the National Planning Policy Framework that applies when a council cannot show a five-year housing land supply
  • EIA Screening Opinion: A decision on whether a proposed development needs a formal Environmental Impact Assessment
  • Sequential Test: A planning test to steer development to areas with the lowest flood risk first
  • Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG): A requirement that development delivers a measurable improvement in biodiversity, with a mandatory 10% national threshold
  • Public Rights of Way (PRoW): Footpaths, bridleways and byways that the public can use
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item117

Resolved

Refused contrary to officer recommendation for the following broad reasons: 1. Having regard to the extension of residential development to the west of the draft allocated site the development will have an adverse impact on the rural character of the area contrary to Strategy 46 and Policy D1 of the East Devon Local Plan 2013 to 2031, East Devon District Council emerging Local Plan 2020 to 2042, National Planning Policy Framework and Neighbourhood Plan. 2. The development will result in the loss of best and most versatile agricultural land and it has not been demonstrated that there is an overriding need for the development the benefits of which would justify the loss. As such the development is contrary to Policy EN13 of the East Devon Local Plan 2013 to 2031. 3. The development is located outside of the built-up area of Ottery St Mary, within the countryside. This significant development of 140 houses is contrary to the spatial strategy of the East Devon Local Plan and emerging East Devon Local Plan which seeks to focus development in East Devon’s West End with development in towns such as Ottery St Mary focused and limited to that required to meet local needs and to maintain the vibrancy of the town. As such the development is contrary to Strategies 1, 2 and 7 of the East Devon Local Plan 2013 to 2031, East Devon District Council emerging Local Plan 2020 to 2042, the National Planning Policy Framework and the Neighbourhood Plan. 4. And reasons for refusal to reflect the fact that in the absence of a legal mechanism to secure the matters set out in the Section 106 Heads of Terms, the impacts of the development cannot be fully mitigated nor deemed to be policy compliant. The exact wording of the reasons for refusal was delegated to officers.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting. Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from East Devon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

Executive summary

This application is before Members because it represents a departure from the adopted Local Plan and a contrary view has been expressed by the Ward Member and Parish Council.

The proposal seeks outline planning permission for up to 140 dwellings on around 7 hectares of agricultural land on the southern edge of Ottery St Mary. The site lies outside the Built-Up Area Boundary and is largely Grade 2 and 3a Best and Most Versatile agricultural land. All matters are reserved except access from Sidmouth Road.

The Council is currently unable to demonstrate a five-year housing land supply, with provision standing at 3.5 years against an annual requirement of 1,168 dwellings. As a result, the tilted balance in paragraph 11(d) of the NPPF applies, creating a strong presumption in favour of development unless the adverse impacts would significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefits. Part of the eastern section of the site, approximately 2.37 hectares, is identified as draft allocation Otry_21 in the emerging Local Plan for around 70 dwellings, whereas the current proposal extends over a wider area at double that scale. The western part of the site was previously rejected through the Council’s site selection process due to landscape and countryside impacts. The emerging Local Plan is at Regulation 19 stage and therefore attracts limited weight. The proposal also conflicts with the Ottery St Mary Neighbourhood Plan, although its age means that conflict alone cannot outweigh the benefits of housing delivery.

25/2468/MOUT The scheme would deliver up to 140 new homes, including 56 affordable dwellings, in our district which has a significant housing shortfall. This represents a substantial social benefit. Additional benefits include short-term construction employment and economic activity, along with secured contributions toward sustainable transport, public rights of way enhancements, ecological mitigation and archaeological investigation. The Lead Local Flood Authority does not object to the drainage strategy.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
25/2468/MOUT (Major) OTTERY ST MARYReport 959 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

13 of 28 attended
BB
Councillor Brian BaileyCommittee Member, present
JB
Councillor Jessica BaileyGuest, in attendance
IB
Councillor Ian BarlowCommittee Member, present
NB
Nigel BarrettOfficer, in attendance
KB
Councillor Kim BloxhamCommittee Member, apologies
CB
Councillor Colin BrownCommittee Member, present
SC
Councillor Sarah ChamberlainCommittee Member, apologies
MC
Councillor Maddy ChapmanCommittee Member, absent
BC
Councillor Bethany CollinsCommittee Member, present
RC
Councillor Roy CollinsGuest, in attendance
OD
Councillor Olly DaveyChair, present
PF
Councillor Peter FaithfullGuest, in attendance

All 28 on the meeting page

On this subject at East Devon

Search all
  1. 25/2468/MOUT (Major) OTTERY ST MARYThis decision
  2. 26/0534/MOUT (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREApproved
  3. 25/2397/MFUL (Major) & 25/2398/LBC EXMOUTH TOWNApproved
  4. 25/0356/MOUT (Major) SIDMOUTH SIDFORDApproved
  5. 23/2077/MOUT (Major) OTTERY ST MARYApproved
  6. 25/1060/MOUT (Major) FENITONApproved

More from East Devon Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
1 Sep 2026 25/2471/MRES (Major) CRANBROOKApproved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation. Approved Open
1 Sep 2026 26/1143/PIP (Other) CLYST VALLEYThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. Permission in Principle be approved. Approved Open
1 Sep 2026 26/0854/FUL (Minor) BROADCLYSTApproved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation. Approved Open
1 Sep 2026 26/0534/MOUT (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. Approved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation subject ... Approved Open
1 Sep 2026 26/0535/MFUL (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. That the SANGS application be approved, subject to conditions and to the co... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies