Sidmouth Connaught Cliffs Emergency works, request for additional in year funding up to £500k
AgreedExecutive1 paper
AI summaryCabinet defers the £500k Connaught Cliffs repair decision, sets up a working group with Sidmouth Town Council, and agrees extra security and CCTV while a further report is prepared for 7 October.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreedFurther report to 7 October Cabinet, work to start April 2027
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextFurther report to 7 October CabinetWorking group to include Sidmouth Town Council
Who it affectsSidmouth walkway, Connaught Gardens, Jacobs LadderResidents, visitors, beach concession, beach hut users
What was decided
Cabinet gave the Environment Operations portfolio holder, with the Director of Place, authority to set up a working group with EDDC and Sidmouth Town Council.
Cabinet asked for a further report to its 7 October meeting, aimed at budgeting for 2027/28 and starting work in April 2027 ahead of summer 2027, including an update on the working group.
Cabinet agreed that working group outcomes feed into the 2027/28 budget, and that increased security and CCTV be put in place at the site for public safety.
Why
To let options for repair be explored with key partners and find the most effective way to reopen the walkway.
The cliff cobblestone retaining wall has moved since last year's inspection, closing the undercliff path and part of Connaught Gardens on safety grounds. Report 1.1
Estimated costs exceed the remaining capital budget, so in year spend is needed to fix the wall and reopen the path. Report 1.1, 6.1
What happens next
Set up a working group with EDDC and Sidmouth Town Council, led by the Environment Operations portfolio holder.
Bring a further report to 7 October Cabinet, with a view to budgeting for 2027/28 and starting work in April 2027.
Increase security and CCTV at the site while options are worked up, and pursue external contributions towards the cost.
The money
up to £500k Additional in year funding requested to cover the works Report 2.1
£75k Estimated remaining existing capital budget available Report 6.1
£6.5k Income from about 40 events and weddings at Connaught Gardens last year
£10k Do Nothing option, permanent security fencing Report 4.1, P33
£150k Netting of existing wall option Report 4.2, P34
£250k Remove wall and regrade area option Report 4.4, P15, P36
£500k Remove wall and build new set back wall, or rebuild on similar alignment Report 4.5, 4.6, P19, P21, P37, P38
£425k Additional borrowing required for the £500k options Report P37, P38
up to a further £250k Potential future cost to repair or replace the listed Jacobs Ladder staircase
Options considered
Rejected: Do nothing, install permanent security fencing at £10k. Impact on the area and Sidmouth, plus ongoing public safety concerns Report 4.1, P8
Rejected: Netting of the existing wall at about £150k. Design will not meet required specification and code Report 4.2, P10
Chosen: Spray concrete of the existing wall at about £300k. Preferred option in the report, subject to being safe enough to construct by a rope access specialist Report 4.3, P12, P13
Rejected: Remove wall and regrade area at about £250k. Unknown costs, loss of public space, conservation concerns about change in appearance and layout Report 4.4, P15, P16
Rejected: Remove wall and build a new set back wall at about £500k. Unknown costs, loss of some public space, requires planning permission Report 4.5, P19, P22
Rejected: Remove wall and rebuild on similar alignment at about £500k. Unknown costs and significantly longer programme, requires planning permission Report 4.6, P21, P22
Implications
Financial: Any spend above the about £75k existing capital budget will need to be borrowed, at annual annuity loan costs ranging from £5k to £29k depending on option. Report 6.1, P33, P34, P35, P36, P37, P38, P39
Legal: As wall owner, the council has a duty of care to employees, contractors and visitors under Health and Safety law and the Occupiers Liability Acts, and must follow its Contract Standing Orders. Report 7.1, P40
Risk: Failure of the wall is rated as a major impact, likely risk to public and member s of the public, with permanent path closure and economic damage if it fails. Report P45, P46, 8.1, 8.2, 8.3
Staffing: Lower cost options may not be safe to build, as they would place works staff in front of a failing wall, so risk mitigation is needed.
Other: Events and weddings income at Connaught Gardens may fall while the fenced off area remains less attractive, and the beach concession trade is limited by the closed undercliff path. Report 15.1, P66
Who and where
Public using the undercliff millennium walkway between Sidmouth town and Jacobs Ladder Report P46
Visitors to Connaught Gardens, including event and wedding attendees
Beach users, beach hut users and the beach concession at Jacobs Ladder Report 15.1
Sidmouth Town Council, as a working group partner
Ward members and local businesses, who have been kept updated by fortnightly emails and notice boards Report P71
Timeline
2026-06-03: Cabinet decision to set up working group and bring further report
Late August into September 2026: Earliest works could start if planning permission submitted promptly (about 8 weeks to determine) Report P23, P24
7 October (Cabinet): Further report on options, costs, and 2027/28 budget implications
April 2027: Work to commence, in time for summer 2027, subject to 2027/28 budget
Summer 2027: Target period for the walkway to be available again
2027/28: Working group outcomes to be considered in budget setting
Plain English for the jargon
EDDC: East Devon District Council
Undercliff millennium walkway: Flat cliff path linking Sidmouth town to the Jacobs Ladder platform, beach, beach huts and concession
Connaught Gardens: Cliff top gardens in Sidmouth that host events and weddings
Jacobs Ladder staircase: Listed staircase in Sidmouth, also closed since its last inspection due to structural failure
Spray concrete: Method of applying concrete via hose, here proposed to coat and stabilise the existing cobblestone retaining wall
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item9
Resolved
RESOLVED that Cabinet; 1. Delegate authority to the Portfolio Holder Environment – Operations in consultation with the Director of Place, to create a working group with EDDC and Sidmouth Town Council. 2. That a further report be brought to the 7 th October Cabinet, with a view to budgeting for 2027/28 and commencing in April 2027 in time for the summer of 2027 and to provide an update on progress of the working group. 3. That the outcomes of the working group are brought into consideration for the budget for 2027/28. 4. That increased security and CCTV be agreed for site and public safety. REASON: To ensure that options for repair can be explored with key partners to ensure that the most effective solution was found to enable the reopening of the walkway.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk
1.1Following annual cliff inspections, the cobblestone cliff retaining wall supporting a walkway within Connaught gardens was found to have moved since last year’s inspection. This has forced the closure of the undercliff path/millennium walkway due to safety concerns. Following investigations and optioneering by designers and contractors due to the constraints the available options are estimated to be more th an the available remaining budget. Therefore, in year spend is required to fix the wall to enable the undercliff/millennium walkway to open. 1.2 The undercliff millennium walkway is currently closed due to the risk of the retaining wall falling off the cliff onto the walkway. The walkway is an important flat link from town to the Jacobs ladder platform area, providing access to not only the beach, but the beach huts and concession. 1.3 A section of Connaught gardens is closed due to the risk of wall failure. 1.4 We have both a designer and contractor appointed and there is a concern since initial thoughts that the lower value options may not be safe enough to construct as they would be placing works staff in front of a failing wall. Unless these risks can be mitigated, they may not be possible. 1.5 The reason for the high costs estimated is due to all the constraints • Poor access below • Poor access from above • Limited working area above (that would be safe to work from) • Conservation area • Near listed structures • Temporary works (and possible permanent works) would affect the garden layout/access considerably. • Height of the failing wall is about 3.5m high built upon a cliff about 7m high limiting plant and increasing risks around working from height. • Can’t put scaffolding etc below wall, due to risk it may fail onto work staff 1.6 It is worth noting that Jacobs Ladder Staircase is also closed due to structural failure since its last inspection. Its repairs are currently unfunded so there may be a up to a further £250k needed at a later date to repair/replace this stair case. The structure is well fenced, and not a risk to the public, so its replacement urgency is low compared to the retaining wall. Its worth noting that the Jacobs Ladder staircase is listed, and will require full planning permission for its repairs/replacement. 1.7 Connaught Gardens does provide income to the council via events and weddings. Last financial year, 40 events were run with income of around £6.5k, with hope to grow this. The ongoing wall work does not remove all future income, but may reduce it, as the area is less attractive due to the restricted access and fences. 1.8 The works are not eligible to external grant funding from the Environment Agency, as they are not flood or coastal infrastructure. An other external ask for contributions has gone out, and subject to approval there may be an external contribution towards the works. (Not agreed at time of writing)
2. Recommendations/Decision
2.1That cabinet recommends to council to approve £500k of budget to cover the works to make the area safe. Any unused budget will be returned 2.2 That cabinet decide on proceeding with the work as soon as possible to remove the risk to the public, or waiting for planning permission (needed as wall is in a conservation area) 2.3 That cabinet agree to proceed with the options for repair in the following preference Option 4.3, Option 4.4
3. Reasons for Recommendations/Decision
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.