Sidmouth Connaught Gardens emergency cliff works - Standing orders Exemption
AgreedExecutive1 paper
AI summaryEast Devon Cabinet approved standing orders exemptions to direct appoint John Grimes Associates for design and an unnamed contractor for cliff repairs at Sidmouth's Connaught Gardens, spending up to £120,000 from existing budgets to reopen a closed footpath by end of June.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreed
Money£120,000Anticipated value of both contracts, covered by existing cliff works budget
What happens nextNot stated
Who it affectsNot stated
What was decided
Cabinet noted a standing orders exemption to appoint John Grimes Associates for the investigation and design contract for cliff repairs at Connaught Gardens, and noted an exemption to appoint a yet-appointed contractor for the delivery contract. Report P4
Cabinet delegated authority to the Director of Place, in consultation with the Portfolio Holder for Environment and Operations, to award the two contracts. Report P4
Why
Running a procurement would add an extra two to three months before the path could reopen, during the summer months, and the risk of cliff failure would remain until repaired. Report P5
Direct awarding both contracts would let works finish before the end of June, while standard procurement would push completion to October or November. Report P11, P13
No available framework covers the specialist cliff design and construction work, and using one would likely cost more. Report P11
What happens next
Director of Place to award the design contract to John Grimes Associates and the construction contract to a suitable contractor via the standing orders exemption. Report P4
Carry out ground investigation and design before any repair works, then obtain a contractor quotation to allow quick award. Report P11
Complete cliff repairs and reopen the Undercliff and Millennium walkway to the public as soon as practicable. Report P13, P11
The money
£120k Anticipated value of both the investigation/design and construction contracts Report P12
£120k Existing budget covering cliff works across the district Report P12
Options considered
Chosen: Direct award both the design and construction contracts via standing orders exemption. Lets works finish before end of June, removing the cliff risk and reopening the path during summer Report P11, P13
Rejected: Run standard procurement for both contracts. Would delay completion to October or November, leaving the cliff risk in place over summer Report P11
Rejected: Use an existing framework for the specialist cliff work. No suitable framework covers this specialist work and subcontracting would likely cost more Report P11
Implications
Financial: Combined contract value of about £120,000 is funded from an existing district-wide cliff works budget; possible findings of the investigation could create further cost. Report P12, P14
Legal: Contract value is below the Procurement Act 2023 threshold; Cabinet can authorise an exemption under Contract Standing Orders Rule 3.1 because of risk to public safety and reputational risk. Report P14
Risk: High risk: an old cobblestone retaining wall on the cliff top is moving and could fall on people above or below; fencing cannot fully prevent public access from the seawall side. Report P8, P9, P13
Risk: Reputational and business risk from prolonged closure of the popular level walk between Sidmouth town and Jacobs Ladder beach, including possible effect on an EDDC concession rental. Report P13
Equalities: Low impact recorded, but the closed Undercliff and Millennium walkway is the only accessible route to Jacobs Ladder beach, with the alternative Chine path being steeply sloped. Report P8, 1.5
Climate: Medium impact recorded in the report; seaside fencing will need resetting after poor weather. Report P8, P13
Other: Jacobs Ladder area is already facing beach hut replacement, seawall works and planned cliff works, so the public will see multiple disruptions in coming months. Report P13
Who and where
Users of the Undercliff and Millennium walkway between Sidmouth town and Jacobs Ladder beach Report 1.5, P13
Visitors and concession holder at Jacobs Ladder beach Report P13, 1.5
Sidmouth residents and local businesses likely to feel the impact of a prolonged path closure Report P13
EDDC staff and contractors delivering the design and repair works Report P9, P11
Timeline
3 March 2026: Large cracks found behind the old cobblestone retaining wall during a routine inspection; Undercliff and Millennium walkway closed Report P9
1 April 2026: Cabinet considers and decides the standing orders exemption Report P1, P2
May 2026 (earliest under standard procurement): Investigation and design work would begin if procured normally Report P11
End of June 2026: Works could be completed and path reopened if both contracts are direct awarded Report P11
June or July 2026 (under standard procurement): Design expected to be ready if procured normally Report P11
October or November 2026: Works would complete if both design and construction were procured normally Report P11
Plain English for the jargon
Standing orders exemption: Cabinet permission to award a contract without following the council's usual competitive procurement process
Undercliff and Millennium walkway: Popular level path between Sidmouth town centre and Jacobs Ladder beach, now closed
Connaught Gardens: EDDC-owned cliff-top gardens in Sidmouth where the cracked retaining wall sits
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item188
Resolved
RESOLVED that Cabinet; 1. Note a standing orders exemption to appoint John Grimes Associates for the contract for investigation and design of cliff repairs at Connaught gardens. Note a standing orders exemption to appoint a yet appointed contractor for the contract for delivering cliff repairs at Connaught gardens. 2. Agree to delegate authority to the Director of Place in consultation with the Portfolio Holder for Environment and Operations to award the contracts. REASON: Running a procurement would add an additional 2 -3 months before the path could be reopened which would be during the summer months. The risk of a failure would also remain until it could be fixed.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk
Date of Meeting 1 April 2026 Document classification: Part A Public Document Exemption applied: None Review date for release N/A
Sidmouth Connaught Gardens emergency cliff works – Standing orders Exemption Report summary: Report to outline issue that’s been discovered, the risks of prolonged path closure and seeking cabinet approval to direct award a contract to complete the design and build to secure the cliff.
Is the proposed decision in accordance with: Budget Yes ☒ No ☐ Policy Framework Yes ☐ No ☒ Recommendation: 1)That Cabinet note a standing orders exemption to appoint John Grimes Associates for the contract for investigation and design of cliff repairs at Connaught gardens, and that Cabinet note a standing orders exemption to appoint an as of yet appointed contractor for the contract for delivering cliff repairs at Connaught gardens 2) That Cabinet agree to delegate authority to the Director of Place in consultation with the Portfolio Holder for Environment and Operations to award the contracts
Reason for recommendation: Running a procurement will add an additional 2 -3 months before the path can be reopened, which will be during the summer months. The risk of a failure will also remain until it can be fixed.
Portfolio(s) (check which apply): ☒ Assets and Economy ☐ Communications and Democracy ☐ Council, Corporate and External Engagement ☐ Culture, Leisure, Sport and Tourism ☒ Environment - Nature and Climate ☐ Environment - Operational ☒ Finance ☐ Place, Infrastructure and Strategic Planning ☐ Sustainable Homes and Communities
Equalities impact Low Impact Climate change Medium Impact Risk: High Risk; Risk of summer impacts on Sidmouth. Risks of cliff fall on public areas Links to background information Link to Council Plan Priorities (check which apply) ☒ A supported and engaged community ☐ Carbon neutrality and ecological recovery ☒ Resilient economy that supports local business ☐ Financially secure and improving quality of services
Report in full 1. Background 1.1. EDDC carries out regular cliff inspections on EDDC owned cliffs where there is a risk to the public either above or below. 1.2. On 3rd March 2026 on a routine inspection, large cracks were witnessed behind the old cobblestone retaining wall on top of the Connaught garden cliffs which support a footpath within Connaught garden. 1.3. It is the opinion of both the Engineering Project Manager and the specialist cliff inspector that this is dangerous and poses a risk to the public below and above as it could fall at any time 1.4. Therefore the Undercliff/millennium walkway remains closed to the public for the foreseeable future as well as a section of the cliff top path within the garden.
1.5The Undercliff/Millenium walkway is a popular path, allowing the only accessible access to Jacobs Ladder beach and its facilities. Alternative access is via the steeply sloped Chine path. Jacobs ladder stairway is also closed awaiting repair. Photos of crack along back of wall on top of cliff
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.