AI summaryEast Devon planning committee approved a new dwelling in the Blackdown Hills National Landscape at Stockland, against officer advice, with conditions on landscaping, a new south-east access, and a package treatment plant with no mains sewer connection.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedSubject to conditions, contrary to refusal recommendation
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextNot stated
Who it affectsStockland, Blackdown Hills National LandscapeSite near Grade I listed St Michael and All Angels Church
What was decided
The committee approved the application, contrary to the officer recommendation of refusal, subject to four specified conditions covering landscaping, vehicular access, the package treatment plant, and a ban on mains sewer connection. Report P1
Conditions require a landscaping scheme for visual mitigation between the site and the church, the existing northern access to be blocked up with all vehicles using the new south-east access, an Environment Agency Environmental Permit for the package treatment plant to be submitted before development starts, and no connection to the mains sewer at any time.
The proposal is a slightly revised version of a previously refused application, 25/0039/FUL, with the access now proposed from the south-east rather than the north-west to avoid flood risk areas. Report P2, P28, P99
Why
Officers had recommended refusal because the proposal would be a new dwelling in open countryside with no specific policy support, would harm the setting of the Grade I listed St Michael and All Angels Church and the Blackdown Hills National Landscape, would lead to reliance on private cars, and would not follow the foul drainage hierarchy requiring connection to the mains sewer. Report P3, P5, P6, P7, P8, P9
Both Dunkeswell and Otterhead ward councillors supported the application and asked for it to go to committee; the parish council abstained, while seven representations of support and no objections were received from the public. Report P12, P13, P14, P25, P26
Officers considered the tilted balance under paragraph 11 of the NPPF did not favour the scheme, as the harm to designated heritage assets, the National Landscape and the River Axe Special Area of Conservation counted as strong reasons for refusal. Report P155, P157, P158, P159, P160, P161
What happens next
The detailed wording of the conditions is to be agreed with the Chair and Ward Members before the permission is issued.
Before any development starts, a copy of the Environmental Permit from the Environment Agency for the package treatment plant must be submitted to the local planning authority.
Other conditions flagged in the report but not listed in the committee decision include requirements for archaeological investigation, a revised tree protection plan, surface water drainage details, a contaminated land watching brief, construction hours, ecological mitigation, and materials details; these would normally be added by officers in line with consultee advice. Report P17, P18, P23, P136, P137, P142, P143, P147, P151, P154
Options considered
Rejected: Refuse the application, as officers recommended. Committee chose to approve, contrary to officer advice Report P1
Chosen: Approve subject to the four listed conditions, including no mains sewer connection
Implications
Legal: The committee has approved the scheme against the officer recommendation; the conditions agreed with the Chair and Ward Members must be consistent with the committee's stated terms, including the prohibition on mains sewer connection.
Equalities: Officers considered that the dwelling would be a two-bedroomed self-build designed to function as a lifetime home. Report P102
Climate: The proposal is stated to be a low energy design, with solar gain, passive ventilation and a low energy heating system such as a ground source heat pump; self-build developments are exempt from Biodiversity Net Gain requirements. Report P102, P138
Risk: Officers warned of less than substantial harm to the setting of the Grade I listed St Michael and All Angels Church, harm to the Blackdown Hills National Landscape, and potential harm to the River Axe Special Area of Conservation through the foul drainage arrangement. Report P134, P141, P159, P160, P161
Other: Officers had concluded that the application should connect to the mains sewer because the site is around 20 metres from the public sewer, but the applicant argued that the dwelling itself is just over the 30 metre threshold; the committee's condition prohibits any mains sewer connection. Report P139, P140
Who and where
The applicant, proposing a two-bedroomed self-build dwelling Report P101, P102
Residents of Stockland and the wider Dunkeswell and Otterhead ward Report P89, P12, P13
Stockland Parish Council, which abstained on this reapplication Report P14
Visitors to St Michael and All Angels Church and its churchyard, where mourners had raised concerns about being overlooked by the proposed glazing Report P15, P150
The setting of the Grade I listed St Michael and All Angels Church and the Stockland Conservation Area Report P5, P6, P89
The Blackdown Hills National Landscape Report P5, P89, P130
The River Axe Special Area of Conservation and Site of Special Scientific Interest Report P92, P139
Timeline
18.07.2025: Previous application 25/0039/FUL for the same site was refused at planning committee. Report P28
12.02.2026: Cllr Yehudi Levine submitted support comments on the revised application. Report P13
02.03.2026: Cllr Colin Brown submitted support comments and requested committee determination. Report P12
10.03.2026: Stockland Parish Council recorded an abstention. Report P14
10.07.2026: East Devon Planning Committee approved the application, contrary to officer recommendation, subject to conditions.
Plain English for the jargon
National Landscape: Former designation of Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB), including the Blackdown Hills, with the highest status of protection for scenic countryside.
SAC: Special Area of Conservation, a European protected wildlife site; here the River Axe, which is in unfavourable condition due to phosphate pollution.
Nutrient neutrality: Demonstrating that a development will not add to nutrient (particularly phosphate) pollution reaching a protected habitat site.
Tilted balance: Paragraph 11 of the National Planning Policy Framework, which presumes in favour of sustainable development where the local plan is out of date, unless specific policies on protected assets apply.
Foul drainage hierarchy: National planning rule requiring new development to connect to the public sewer where feasible, ahead of package treatment plants or septic tanks.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item27
Resolved
Approved contrary to officer recommendation subject to conditions to be agreed with the Chair and Ward Member(s) to include the following: · Landscaping scheme which seeks to provide appropriate visual mitigation between the site and the church. · No vehicular access except via the new access point on the south-east corner of the site and any existing vehicular access on the northern side boundary to be blocked up in accordance with details to be agreed by the Local Planning Authority. · Prior to commencement of development, a copy of the Environmental Permit issued by the Environment Agency for the proposed package treatment plant shall be submitted to the Local Planning Authority. The package treatment plant shall then be installed in accordance with the approved details and retained and maintained as such for the lifetime of the development. · No connection to the mains sewer at any time.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk
This application is before Committee as the officer recommendation is for refusal, contrary to the views of the Ward Members.
The proposal is the re-building of a former building (used as a sawmill) and its use as a dwelling. The building would be constructed overlapping the footprint of a smaller barn, which is a remaining part of the original sawmill building (currently in agricultural use). It would be larger than the existing barn or the original sawmill building and partly subterranean, with the design of the non- subterranean part seeking to replicate the appearance of the original sawmill building. The proposed dwelling would be single storey and would have an associated garden, driveway and parking area. The proposal is a slightly revised version of an application that was refused, referenced 25/0039/FUL, with the access now being proposed from the southeast instead of the northwest, to avoid areas at risk of flooding.
In the absence of information suggesting that any part of the existing building would be incorporated within the re-instated building, the proposal does not represent a conversion, which might otherwise draw support from Local Plan Policy D8 (Re-use of Rural Buildings Outside of Settlements) in principle. The proposal is therefore considered to be a new building. The site is on the edge of the settlement of Stockland which does not have a Built Up Area Boundary and is thus in the open countryside. There is no specific policy support for the principle of the proposed dwelling, either through the Local or Neighbourhood plan.
25/2614/FUL It is acknowledged that the sawmill building existed but what remains of it is not a designated or non-designated heritage asset hence there is no heritage justification for the re-instatement of that building.
The site is within the Blackdown Hills National Landscape, within the setting of the Grade 1 listed St Michaels and All Angels Church and visible from the conservation area. The existing barn is a simple small scale open sided building with an agricultural character. The proposed dwelling is larger than the existing barn in all dimensions and it would incorporate features which are not present within the existing barn, such as extensive glazing, a different roof material and shutters. The Parish Council object to the large windows on the western elevation of the dwelling, highlighting that these fail to adhere to the Blackdown Hills Design Guide for houses. Whilst it is understood that the window design seeks to reference the character of the existing barn, the result of this is an extensive area of glazing which, together with the building’s increased scale, its driveway, garden and the introduction of domestic paraphernalia, will result in the building appearing prominent and both the building and its setting appearing domestic.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
26/0534/MOUT (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. Approved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation subject ...
26/0535/MFUL (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. That the SANGS application be approved, subject to conditions and to the co...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.