CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
East Devon District Council
Planning Committee, Tuesday 4 August 2026 at 10.00am

25/2529/FUL (Minor) NEWBRIDGES

Refused Planning 1 paper

AI summaryEast Devon Planning Committee has refused full planning application 25/2529/FUL for a new dwelling within remnant stone walls near Grove Cottage, Shute, in line with officer recommendation. The site lies in open countryside within the East Devon National Landscape.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeRefusedIn line with officer recommendation
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextNot stated
Who it affectsLand adjacent Grove Cottage, ShuteOpen countryside near Grade I Shute Gatehouse

What was decided

The committee refused application 25/2529/FUL for a new dwelling within the remnant stone walls of a former agricultural building at Shute, following the officer recommendation to refuse. Report P1, P118, P119

Three refusal reasons were given: conflict with countryside and re-use policies, less than substantial harm to designated heritage assets, and harm to the East Devon National Landscape. Report P119, P120, P121, P122

Why

The surviving walls are not structurally capable of conversion, so the scheme amounts to a new dwelling in open countryside, not a re-use under Policy D8, and the site is remote from services with poor sustainable transport. Report P2, P51, P52, P53, P56, P120

The Conservation Officer, Historic England and the previous appeal decision all identify less than substantial harm to the Grade I Shute Gatehouse and Old Shute House, with public benefits of one private dwelling insufficient to outweigh it. Report P3, P22, P75, P76, P77, P78, P121

The dwelling would domesticate an open part of the East Devon National Landscape, conflicting with Strategy 46 and Policy D1 on design and landscape. Report P58, P59, P60, P61, P115, P122

What happens next

The applicant may appeal the refusal to the Planning Inspectorate, although the papers do not set out any further council action. Report P117, P119

Options considered

  • Chosen: Refuse in line with officer recommendation. Conflicts with Strategy 7, Policy D8 and sustainable transport policies; less than substantial harm to heritage assets; harm to National Landscape. Report P117, P118, P119, P120, P121, P122
  • Rejected: Approve, as supported by Ward Member Cllr Ian Chubb and Shute Parish Council. Officers found the scheme is in substance a new dwelling, harms heritage assets and the National Landscape, and fails Policy D8. Report P1, P9, P10, P11, P12, P14, P51, P79

Implications

  • Legal: Section 66(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 applies: special regard must be had to preserving the setting of the Grade I Shute Gatehouse and Old Shute House, and harm to their significance is given great weight. Report P22, P72, P75, P79, P121
  • Equalities: The Human Rights Act 1998 and the public sector equality duty under the Equality Act 2010 were considered in reaching the recommendation. Report P142, P143
  • Climate: The site is self-build, exempt from the statutory 10% Biodiversity Net Gain requirement, but lighting and ecological mitigation is required to protect bats and the Beer Quarry and Caves SAC. Report P92, P93, P94, P95, P96, P97
  • Risk: Natural England initially raised insufficient information; following an Appropriate Assessment and lighting mitigation, it withdrew its objection on 09/07/2026. Report P23, P24, P26, P27, P97
  • Other: The site lies within the East Devon National Landscape, a Bat Consultation Area, SSSI Impact Risk Zone, Great Crested Newt 5km Consultation Zone, and an Airport Safeguarding Area. Report P47

Who and where

  • The applicant, who had previously had a similar scheme refused (24/2290/FUL) and dismissed at appeal (Ref. 6001134) on 12/01/2026 Report P37
  • Owners and occupiers of nearby properties including Boarscroft, Beagles Row and The Forge, separated by hedgerows and Shute Road Report P80, P81
  • The setting of the Grade I Shute Gatehouse and Old Shute House, and the Grade II listed Beagles Row, Forge, Stables and Barn at Old Shute House Report P48, P75, P79
  • Bats using the Beer Quarry and Caves SAC and the surrounding sustenance and connectivity zones Report P47, P96, P97

Timeline

  • 23/07/2025: Earlier application 24/2290/FUL for a similar dwelling refused Report P37
  • 12/01/2026: Appeal against 24/2290/FUL dismissed (Ref. 6001134) Report P37
  • 11/03/2026: Historic England objects on heritage grounds Report P19, P20, P21, P22
  • 11/03/2026: Natural England initially raises insufficient information for Habitats Regulations Assessment Report P23, P24, P25
  • 13/03/2026: Shute Parish Council and Cllr Ian Chubb express support Report P8, P9, P10, P11, P12, P13, P14
  • 09/07/2026: Natural England withdraws objection, subject to lighting mitigation being secured Report P26, P27
  • 04/08/2026: Planning Committee refuses application 25/2529/FUL in line with officer recommendation Report P119

Plain English for the jargon

  • Policy D8: East Devon Local Plan policy on the re-use of rural buildings outside settlements, which requires buildings to be structurally sound and capable of conversion without substantial reconstruction.
  • Strategy 7: East Devon Local Plan strategy that strictly controls new residential development in the open countryside.
  • Less than substantial harm: A category of harm to the significance of a designated heritage asset, to which great weight must be given, weighed against any public benefits (NPPF paragraphs 212 and 215).
  • Appropriate Assessment: A Habitats Regulations assessment under Regulation 63 of the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017 to test whether a plan or project would adversely affect the integrity of a European site such as the Beer Quarry and Caves SAC.
  • Section 66(1) duty: Statutory duty under the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 requiring special regard to be had to the desirability of preserving the setting of a listed building.
  • National Landscape: The current name for what were formerly called Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty; the site lies within the East Devon National Landscape.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item35

Resolved

Refused in accordance with officer recommendation.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting. Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from East Devon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

Executive summary

This application is before Members as the officer recommendation differs from that of the Ward Member, Cllr Ian Chubb.

The proposal seeks the construction of a new dwelling within the remnant stone walls of a former agricultural building in the open countryside. The surviving walls are not structurally capable of conversion and the development would, in substance, constitute a new dwelling rather than the reuse of a rural building. The site is remote from services and facilities, and the proposal conflicts with Strategy 7, Policy D8 and the sustainable transport policies of the East Devon Local Plan.

The development would introduce residential activity, domestic paraphernalia and lighting into an undeveloped rural landscape that contributes to the setting of numerous designated heritage assets, including the Grade I Shute Gatehouse and Old Shute House. The Council’s Conservation Officer, Historic England and the previous appeal decision all identify that the proposal would result in less than substantial harm to their significance, with insufficient public benefits to outweigh that harm.

A full Appropriate Assessment has been completed and Natural England has confirmed that, subject to the lighting mitigation measures being fully secured, the proposal would not adversely affect the integrity of the Beer Quarry and Caves SAC.

Notwithstanding Natural England’s position, the proposal remains contrary to the development plan and national policy and is therefore recommended for refusal.

CONSULTATIONS:

Local Consultations:

25/1191/FUL - Shute Parish Council – Support – Dated: 13/03/2026: (Summary) –

Shute Parish Council supports the application and raises no objections. They consider the proposal a valuable opportunity to provide local housing and note that the applicant has made substantial changes following the refusal of Ref: 24/2290/FUL.

They highlight that the site lies directly on a regular bus route and regard sustainable transport provision as reasonable for the parish. They also note long-standing efforts to improve pedestrian and cyclist safety.

The Council considers traffic impacts negligible compared with existing school-related movements nearby.

They state the site is centrally located within Shute and that the dwelling, set fully within existing walls with a green roof, would have limited visibility and minimal wider landscape impact. They also see the proposal as securing the long-term maintenance of the historic walls.

- Cllr Ian Chubb – Support – Dated: 13/03/2026 & 08/07/2026: (Summary) –

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
25/2529/FUL (Minor) NEWBRIDGESReport 511 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

14 of 23 attended
EW
Councillor Eileen WraggChair, present
SH
Councillor Steve HuntVice-Chair, present
BB
Councillor Brian BaileyCommittee Member, present
IB
Councillor Ian BarlowCommittee Member, present
KB
Councillor Kim BloxhamCommittee Member, present
CB
Councillor Colin BrownCommittee Member, present
SC
Councillor Sarah ChamberlainCommittee Member, apologies
MC
Councillor Maddy ChapmanCommittee Member, present
BC
Councillor Bethany CollinsCommittee Member, present
OD
Councillor Olly DaveyCommittee Member, present
SG
Councillor Steve GazzardCommittee Member, present
JH
Councillor John HeathCommittee Member, present

All 23 on the meeting page

On this subject at East Devon

Search all
  1. 25/2529/FUL (Minor) NEWBRIDGESThis decision
  2. 26/0854/FUL (Minor) BROADCLYSTApproved
  3. 26/0629/FUL (Minor) NEWBRIDGESApproved
  4. 26/0201/FUL (Minor) BUDLEIGH & RALEIGHApproved
  5. 25/2614/FUL (Minor) DUNKESWELL & OTTERHEADApproved
  6. 26/0478/FUL (Minor) EXMOUTH LITTLEHAMApproved

More from East Devon Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
1 Sep 2026 25/2471/MRES (Major) CRANBROOKApproved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation. Approved Open
1 Sep 2026 26/1143/PIP (Other) CLYST VALLEYThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. Permission in Principle be approved. Approved Open
1 Sep 2026 26/0854/FUL (Minor) BROADCLYSTApproved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation. Approved Open
1 Sep 2026 26/0534/MOUT (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. Approved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation subject ... Approved Open
1 Sep 2026 26/0535/MFUL (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. That the SANGS application be approved, subject to conditions and to the co... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies