Agreed That:- (1) the continuation to provide the current recycling service (described as the ‘baseline’ of the circulated report) be approved; (2) officers provide an annual update on the food waste business case in the Recycling Plan; and (3) the current and planned measures to improve the recycling rate achieved by the current service be noted. Reason for As set out in the report.
Word for word from the decision Exeter published for this meeting.Source: committees.exeter.gov.uk
1) That Place Scrutiny Committee supports, and Executive agrees, that Exeter City Council continues to provide the current recycling service (described as the ‘baseline’ in this report) 2) That officers provide an annual update on the food waste business case in the Recycling Plan that is submitted to Place Scrutiny Committee 3) That Place Scrutiny Committee and Executive Committee note the current and planned measures to improve the recycling rate achieved by the current service
Reasons for the recommendation
3.1Continuing the current recycling service without a food waste collection (described below as the ‘baseline’ service) is the service option with the lowest modelled costs and lowest financial risk.
4. What are the resource implications including non financial resources.
4.1The above recommendations are planned to be achieved within agreed revenue budgets for 2018/19.
5. Section 151 Officer comments:
5.1There are no financial implications to consider in this report.
6. What are the legal aspects?
6.1Exeter’s recycling scheme is already compliant with the requirement in the Waste (England and Wales) Regulations 2011 for separate recycling collections. There are currently no statutory recycling rate targets applicable to Exeter. 7. Monitoring Officer’s comments:
7.1This report raises no issues of concern for the Monitoring Officer.
Background
8.1Exeter City Council’s Corporate Work Programme included a commitment to investigate the business case for separate food waste collections and report on the outcome (ref PH25).
8.2In 2016, Eunomia was appointed as the consultant to assist in the investigation of the business case. Five different recycling and rubbish collection scenarios were modelled, comparing cost and performance against that of the current service (the ‘baseline’) that we provide (Appendix 1).
8.3The financial modelling included any changes to service revenue costs. The provision of any new vehicles and waste containers, and communications material, were accounted for on an annualised revenue basis.
8.4Option 4 was modelled as delivering the highest recycling rate and best environmental performance (measured in CO2 equivalent). This option consists of a weekly collection of food waste and other recyclable materials, collected on the same lorry and largely sorted into separate streams at the kerbside. The frequency of rubbish collection would reduce to once every three weeks.
8.5Option 4 was also modelled by Eunomia as being marginally the cheapest option, saving a total over 10 years of £6,000 compared to the baseline service.
8.6Option 3 was modelled as being the next cheapest option, costing an additional £854,000 over 10 years compared to the baseline. A comparison of all five service options against the baseline service is shown in Appendix 1.
8.7Eunomia’s project brief was to model the operational resources (costs and income) required for the baseline and five service options. This did not include the additional administration and customer support resource requirements associated with a major service change (any of options 1 – 5). Comparison with other local authorities introducing major service changes indicates that an additional four full-time recycling education officers and two Environment Support Officers would be required for the roll- out period of 6-12 months. This would result in additional expenditure of £68,000 - £135,000 depending on the length of the roll-out (exclusive of the 2018/19 pay award).
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Review of Exeter Business Centre Ltd.AGREED: RESOLVED that Executive: (1) note the current position of Exeter Business Centre Ltd and the review of Exeter...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.