CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Exeter City Council
Council, Tuesday 9 December 2025 at 6.00pm

Strategic Scrutiny Committee - 3 November 2025 (Special)

Decided Committee 1 paper

AI summaryExeter City Council received the special committee's minutes. The minutes record unanimous agreement on Devon local government reorganisation work and feedback for the final proposal, with £135,000 approved for reorganisation work and higher spend to be reported [D] [P21] [P17].

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedMember feedback would help shape the Devon submission [P21]
Money£135,000 approved for reorganisation work [P17]Spend was greater and would be reported accordingly [P17]
What happens nextNot stated
Who it affectsDevon local government reorganisation [P12]Service delivery and future council boundaries were considered [P12] [P17]

What was decided

Exeter City Council received the minutes of the special Strategic Scrutiny Committee held on 3 November 2025. Report P2

A proposed amendment was carried unanimously and became the substantive motion. Report P20, P21

The committee noted officers' work to develop a final reorganisation proposal for Devon and member feedback to help shape the submission. Report P21

Why

The submission had to be legally compliant. Legal advice confirmed that using existing district boundaries, modified to reflect the proposed expanded boundaries, would comply. Report P12

The proposal had to be the best solution for all of Devon, and Exeter had outgrown its current administrative boundaries. Report P12

The four unitary model had been assessed with the same data used for other county areas and described as financially viable. Report P17

What happens next

Officers would incorporate member feedback where possible and identify matters for the new unitary authority. Report P16

A reference to the need to consider the River Exe would be included in the submission. Report P17

A service delivery plan would start being built while government direction remained uncertain. Report P17

The money

  • £135,000 Approved for local government reorganisation work. Spend was greater and would be reported accordingly. Report P17
  • £8,000 Cost of the Inner Circle Report. Report P17

Options considered

  • Chosen: Four unitary councils and a Coast and Countryside authority. Officers moved to this model from considering three unitary councils. It was assessed using the same data as other county areas and described as financially viable. Report P12, P17
  • Rejected: Three unitary councils. Officers had moved away from thinking that three unitary councils would be favourable. Report P12
  • Rejected: Include geography at the Interim Stage. No geography was included because officers felt there had not yet been enough empirical work. Report P12

Implications

  • Financial: The viability model included disaggregated upper tier costs and savings from bringing district councils together. It projected no significant savings from service transformation. Report P17
  • Legal: Submissions had to use existing district boundaries for legal compliance. Legal advice confirmed that modifying them for the proposed expanded boundaries would comply. Report P12
  • Staffing: There were eleven Section 151 Officers, but only four would be required. Report P17
  • Risk: A significant amount of work would follow once government indicated a direction of travel, so a plan needed to begin beforehand. Report P17
  • Financial: Government had offered flexible use of capital receipts for transformation costs. This might change capital programme planning, but borrowing would not cover transitional costs. Report P17
  • Legal: MHCLG would decide warding after taking advice from the Boundary Commission. Report P17
  • Equalities: The 72 councillor figure was the top end considered for a functioning council. It did not account for Exeter's lack of parish level representation. Report P17
  • Legal: Neighbourhood Plans were statutory and would not be undermined. Report P17

Who and where

  • Devon communities Report P12
  • Exeter residents Report P12, P17
  • Parish councils and the communities in their areas Report P12, P17
  • The future unitary authority Report P12, P16
  • People using adult social care, children's services and SEND Report P12, P17
  • NHS, Police and Fire services Report P17
  • Third sector organisations Report P17
  • Council staff Report P17

Timeline

  • February 2025: The official government return used for financial modelling was based on the budget set in February 2025. Report P17
  • once a direction of travel is indicated by Government: A significant amount of work would be needed. Report P17
  • last eleven months: Officers developed the reorganisation submission. Report P13
  • last week: A press release reported work with Plymouth and Torbay on where their proposals could fit Exeter's. Report P12
  • when it is established: The new unitary authority would consider some member feedback and service delivery decisions. Report P16
  • 3 November 2025: The special Strategic Scrutiny Committee met and agreed the substantive motion unanimously. Report P2, P21
  • around February: Government statutory consultation was likely to begin. Report P17
  • December: A new funding formula was expected to come forward. Report P17

Plain English for the jargon

  • LGR: Local Government Reorganisation, covering the proposed changes to local government in Devon [P9] [P12].
  • Unitary council: A single tier local authority in the proposed structure [P12] [P17].
  • Coast and Countryside authority: The proposed additional authority in the four unitary model [P12].
  • SEND: Special Educational Needs and Disabilities, identified as a service area for the new authority [P12].
  • MHCLG: The body that would take the warding decision, taking advice from the Boundary Commission [P17].
  • Section 151 Officer: An officer required to sign off a financial model [P17].
  • Neighbourhood Area Committee: A proposed local forum. Government regulations were awaited before details could be clarified [P12] [P17].
  • Precept: A parish charge funded from Council Tax. Parish councils can set it as they see fit [P17].
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item107

Resolved

RESOLVED that the minutes of the Special Strategic Scrutiny Committee held on 3 November 2025 be received.
Word for word from the decision Exeter published for this meeting. Source: committees.exeter.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Exeter's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Council, 5 pages

STRATEGIC SCRUTINY COMMITTEE

3 November 2025

Present: Councillor Liz Pole (Chair) Councillors Atkinson, Haigh, Harding, Miller-Boam, Moore, Rolstone, Wetenhall, Williams, M and Read (In place of Mitchell, K)

Apologies: Councillor K Mitchell

Also present: Chief Executive, Strategic Director for Corporate Resources, Executive Office Manager and Democratic Services Manager

In attendance as Portfolio Holder: Councillors Asvachin, Bialyk, Vizard, Williams R and Wood

17 Declarations of Interest

No declarations of interest were made by Members.

18 Local Government Reorganisation

The Chair invited the Chief Executive to present the report on Local Government Reorganisation.

The Chief Executive introduced her presentation stating that final briefings hadn’t taken place when the agenda was published and she wanted to incorporate feedback from those this evening.

The Chief Executive gave a presentation (slides attached) making the following points:  the Interim Stage had no geography included as it was felt that not enough empirical work had yet been carried out;  cross-party support had been a positive motivating factor for officers;  Growth was missing from Government’s six criteria and officers had identified six Exeter principles (slide 6);  Officers had worked with comparable cities such as Oxford, Cambridge and Norwich;  a press release last week showed that the officers had worked with Plymouth and Torbay to see where their proposals could be accommodated within Exeter’s;  officers had moved away from thinking at the interim stage that 3 unitary councils would be favourable, mindful of Torbay at the time as a small, well- performing unitary council, whose wishes had been accommodated to a degree, to a 4 unitary model – Exeter plus 49 parishes, Plymouth plus 13 adjacent parishes, Torbay and adjacent areas (different to Torbay’s model) and a Coast and Countryside authority;  the submission must be based on a solution best for all of Devon;  Exeter had outgrown its current administrative boundaries;  the Leader and Chief Executive were liaising with Devon Association of Local Councils as well as Police, Fire Service and other relevant stakeholders;  Exeter was not currently parished, unlike other areas and the intention would be develop Neighbourhood Area Committees and recommend that the new authority carry out a Community Governance Review;  Officers would look to replicate the good work undertaken in housing across wider public sector services, including different ways to deliver some of the services not currently provided by the Council such as Adult Social Care, Children’s Services and Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND);  how services would be delivered would be decisions for the new authority;  salient points from Members’ would be reflected as far as possible in the submission and it would be acknowledged where actions would be for the shadow or new authority;  academic work had focussed in the past on a large one authority bringing efficiencies but more recent research show that leadership, engaging with local demand, understanding local needs was recognised as more important;  joint areas of work with other districts had been established, resulting in data sharing, a data hub and discussion about engagement work;  submissions must be based on existing district boundaries to be legally compliant. A modification to the existing district boundaries had then been requested to reflect the proposed expanded boundaries. Legal advice had been taken which confirmed the submission would be compliant;  from options appraisals it appeared that the Devon County Council proposal was the least worst option but this had not been agreed through the formal decision-making process; and  Exeter had city status and must ensure that the Lord Mayoralty was protected as well as investigating Charter Status.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Strategic Scrutiny Committee: 3 November 2025 (Special)Minutes 5 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

29 of 45 attended
TR
The Right Worshipful the Lord Mayor Councillor Anne JobsonChair, present
MA
Councillor Marina AsvachinCommittee Member, present
YA
Councillor Yvonne AtkinsonCommittee Member, apologies
JB
Councillor James BanyardCommittee Member, present
JB
Councillor Jane BegleyCommittee Member, present
CB
Councillor Carol BennettCommittee Member, apologies
PB
Councillor Philip BialykCommittee Member, present
JC
Councillor James CooksonCommittee Member, present
DD
Councillor Deborah DarlingCommittee Member, apologies
BF
Councillor Bob FoaleCommittee Member, apologies
AF
Councillor Adrian FullamCommittee Member, present
LH
Councillor Lucy HaighCommittee Member, present

All 45 on the meeting page

On this subject at Exeter

Search all
  1. Strategic Scrutiny Committee - 3 November 2025 (Special)This decision
  2. Strategic Scrutiny Committee - 15 January 2026Decided
  3. Strategic Scrutiny Committee - 20 November 2025Decided
  4. Strategic Scrutiny Committee - 5 June 2025Decided
  5. Strategic Scrutiny Committee - 3 April 2025Decided
  6. Strategic Scrutiny Committee - 5 December 2024Decided

More from Exeter Council

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Exeter Harbour Board - 11 June 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Exeter Harbour Board of 11 June 2026 be received. Decided Open
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Planning Committee - 6 July 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Planning Committee of 6 July 2026 be received. Decided Open
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Planning Committee - 3 August 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Planning Committee of 3 August 2026 be received Decided Open
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Strata Joint Scrutiny Committee - 11 February 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Strata Joint Scrutiny Committee of 11 February 2026 be received. Decided Open
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Executive Committee - 15 July 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Executive Committee of 15 July 2026 be received. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies