CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Exeter City Council
Council, Tuesday 3 March 2026 at 6.10pm

Strategic Scrutiny Committee - 15 January 2026

Decided Committee 1 paper

AI summaryExeter City Council received the 15 January 2026 Strategic Scrutiny Committee minutes, which recorded agreements to hold a Hillcrest Park and Doriam Close petition for any future Article 4 review and to recommend the Executive explore a negotiated stopping policy on unauthorised encampments.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedFull Council formally noted 15 January 2026 Scrutiny minutes
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextArticle 4 petition held for future reviewExecutive to explore negotiated stopping policy on encampments
Who it affectsNot stated

What was decided

The Council received the minutes of the Strategic Scrutiny Committee held on 15 January 2026, agreeing them subject to the substantive scrutiny decisions recorded within them. Report P7

The Scrutiny Committee carried, as amended, that the Hillcrest Park and Doriam Close petition be held to inform any future Article 4 direction review. Report P44, P46, P51

The Scrutiny Committee unanimously recommended that the Executive explore the viability and impact of a negotiated stopping policy, that the definition of an unauthorised encampment in the protocol be reviewed, and that officers note the evidence given. Report P69, P70

Why

Petitioners asked Exeter City Council to extend the Article 4 direction to cover Hillcrest Park and Doriam Close, citing concerns about student HMOs, narrow streets, parking, refuse access and pressure on residential amenity near the university. Report P34, P36

Officers reported that the most reliable datasets showed no HMO records in the two roads and that the NPPF required Article 4 to cover the smallest geographical area possible, so they did not recommend an extension. Report P39, P41

Members heard from Isca Bowling Club about repeated unauthorised encampments at the Arena car park and from TravellerSpace about the welfare needs of gypsy and traveller communities and the lack of transit sites in Exeter. Report P54, P59, P60

What happens next

The petition on Hillcrest Park and Doriam Close is to be held to inform any future Article 4 direction review; no review is currently timetabled. Report P44, P41

Officers will note written and verbal evidence from residents, organisations and members to inform work on the unauthorised encampments protocol going forward. Report P69

The Executive will be asked to explore the viability and impact of a negotiated stopping policy for unauthorised encampments. Report P69

The money

  • £47,000 Internal council staff costs on unauthorised encampments over the last 3 years Report P67
  • £404 Court fees per application for encampment proceedings Report P67
  • £150 Process service fees per encampment application Report P67
  • 532 hours at £35 per hour Officer time spent on unauthorised encampments over the last 3 years Report P67

Options considered

  • Chosen: Hold the Hillcrest Park and Doriam Close petition to inform any future Article 4 direction review. Members wanted the petition retained even though officers found insufficient HMO evidence to extend Article 4 now Report P44, P45, P46, P51
  • Rejected: Undertake a review of the council's policy on updating Article 4 directions. Officers advised this would be a substantial piece of work while the Local Plan examination is the team's current focus, with hearings between March and May Report P49, P50
  • Chosen: Recommend that the Executive explore a negotiated stopping policy, review the encampment protocol definition and note evidence given. Unanimous support following evidence from Isca Bowling Club and TravellerSpace on tensions and welfare needs Report P69, P70
  • Chosen: Defer the Rivers 2 and transparency template motion to a later Scrutiny meeting. South West Water declined to attend and declined to use the proposed template; item to be timetabled later with broader evidence Report P26, P27, P71

Implications

  • Legal: Officers set out that the Council has a duty under the Equality Act when assessing encampments, using agents to determine needs before deciding whether to tolerate; an injunction renewal at the Arena is being investigated but cannot extend across the whole city. Report P64
  • Legal: The Monitoring Officer noted that police have powers to direct travellers or trespassers to leave land and that section 62a of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act provides additional powers where alternative transit sites exist. Report P68
  • Equalities: Members raised concern that there was no EQIA on encampment work and that people with protected characteristics could be targeted when no safe stopping place exists; TravellerSpace highlighted lower life expectancy and health indicators for gypsies and travellers. Report P59, P66
  • Financial: Scrutiny was told that £47,000 of internal staff costs and 532 hours at £35 per hour were spent on encampments over three years, and that further costs on the Bus Station Wider Options work will be met by virement from the Liveable Exeter budget. Report P19, P67
  • Risk: Height restriction barriers at the Arena car park have been ordered and are expected to be installed in the first half of the year, with members warning that barriers have been cut in the past. Report P57, P66
  • Staffing: Officers said a review of Council policy and procedure on Article 4 could be done more quickly than a full Article 4 review but the Local Plan examination, with hearings between March and May, is the team's current focus. Report P50
  • Other: An air quality consultant was expected to be appointed in early February to design a timeline, after which an Air Quality Action Plan update would be shared. Report P12

Who and where

  • Residents of Hillcrest Park and Doriam Close, Exeter Report P36, P43
  • Petition organiser and supporters seeking Article 4 extension Report P35, P36
  • Councillor Palmer and other St James ward members Report P38
  • Members and users of Isca Bowling Club Report P54
  • Gypsy and traveller communities passing through or staying in Exeter Report P59, P60
  • People experiencing homelessness using vehicles or vans Report P63, P66
  • Strategic Scrutiny Committee members and officers attending Report P3, P5, P6

Timeline

  • 3 November 2025: Special Strategic Scrutiny Committee meeting whose minutes were approved subject to one amendment Report P8
  • 20 November 2025: Ordinary Strategic Scrutiny Committee meeting whose minutes were approved with several amendments Report P9, P10
  • 15 January 2026: Strategic Scrutiny Committee meeting whose minutes were received by full Council Report P2
  • early February 2026: Likely appointment of air quality consultant followed by design of a timeline Report P12
  • February 2026: Special Council meetings scheduled to consider Senate Court and office relocation Report P29
  • 3 March 2026: Exeter City Council meeting at which these Scrutiny minutes were received
  • March to May 2026: Local Plan examination hearings expected Report P50
  • first half of 2026: Height restriction barriers expected to be installed at the Arena car park Report P57

Plain English for the jargon

  • Article 4 direction: A planning tool that removes permitted development rights in a designated area so that planning permission is needed for certain changes of use, such as a family home becoming a small HMO
  • HMO: House in Multiple Occupation, with Class C4 covering a dwelling house occupied by 3 to 6 unrelated people
  • PBSA: Purpose-Built Student Accommodation, which the Leader said would not be located in city council owned properties
  • NPPF: National Planning Policy Framework, the government's planning policy against which Article 4 evidence is assessed
  • Negotiated stopping: An approach where travellers are allowed to stop on a site for an agreed period, with arrangements for waste, drainage and tidy departure, often with a welfare assessment on arrival
  • SPD: Supplementary Planning Document, which the officer noted may need to change to a different document type under expected national policy changes
  • LTP4: The draft Devon and Torbay Local Transport Plan, which the minutes recorded had no reference to Air Quality until Exeter City Council's feedback was responded to
  • EQIA: Equality Impact Assessment, which members noted was missing from the encampments discussion
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item148

Resolved

RESOLVED that the minutes of the Strategic Scrutiny Committee held on 15 January 2026 were received.
Word for word from the decision Exeter published for this meeting. Source: committees.exeter.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Exeter's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Council, 16 pages

STRATEGIC SCRUTINY COMMITTEE

15 January 2026

Present: Councillor Liz Pole (Chair) Councillors Mitchell, K, Atkinson, Haigh, Harding, Miller-Boam, Moore, Wetenhall and Knott (In place of Rolstone)

Apologies: Councillor Rolstone

Also present: Strategic Director for Corporate Resources, Head of Legal and Democratic Services & Monitoring Officer, Head of Service - Commercial Assets, Assistant Service Lead – Local Plan, Danny Damarell, Estates Surveyor and Democratic Services Manager

In attendance as Portfolio Holder: Councillors Bialyk, Vizard, Williams, R., Wood and Wright

27 Minutes

The minutes of the special meeting held on 3 November 2025 were taken as read, approved and signed by the Chair as correct, subject to an amendment to insert the word ‘have’ on minute no. 18 – “Section 151 officers must sign off a financial model and therefore couldn’t have put this forward ethically if it was not believed to work”

The minutes of the ordinary meeting held on 20 November 2025 were taken as read, approved and signed by the Chair as correct, subject to the following amendments, with additions in italics:

Minute No. 23 - Each yellow sign had the number of the nearest camera on them in order that people didn’t need to say where they are and locations of cameras could be shared with councillors on request but would not be made public; Minute No. 24 - views of those in the current area at East Wonford Hill that had in previous years not been below the government objective were important to the action plan; Minute No. 24 spelling corrected – butadiene; Minute No. 25 addition of - The Chair brought Members' attention to the fact a wrong version of the Motion referred by Council had been included in the Agenda Reports Pack. The correct version was tabled and is appended to the minutes; and Minute No. 25 amended to read - the draft Devon and Torbay Local Transport Plan, LTP4, transport plan had no reference to Air Quality until Exeter City Council’s feedback had been responded to.

Councillor Wetenhall asked that Democratic Services consider numbering rather than bullet points to aide situations such as amending minutes.

The Chair updated the committee with regard to Air Quality stating that the Strategic Director for Operations anticipated that following the likely appointment of a consultant in early February a timeline would be designed and shared. 28 Declarations of Interest

No declarations of interest were made by Members.

29 Questions from Members of the Public Under Standing Order No.19

There were no questions submitted by the public.

30 Questions from Members of the Council Under Standing Order No.20

In accordance with Standing Order No. 20, the following question was submitted by Councillor Moore in relation to the Portfolio of Councillor Bialyk who attended the meeting. The question was circulated at the meeting to Members of the Committee. The question and response are set out below:

Question: Please provide an update on the Bus Station Wider Options project including the works that have been undertaken and why it went over budget.

Response: The Council has engaged Avison Young to undertake a market and deliverability assessment across the former bus station and the civic centre site. This assessment has also examined high level architectural layout and massing options together with scheme viability and associated deliverability constraints. In order to ensure that a comprehensive regeneration approach had been undertaken, the Council re-engaged Avison Young to undertake a further linked phase 2 assessment which included the Sidwell St retail frontage properties (Eastside row opposite John Lewis). This additional work generated a further fee commitment resulting in an overspend, which will be covered by a virement from the wider Liveable Exeter budget.

Once this assessment has been fully reviewed a report will be brought to the Executive.

Supplementary Question and Response

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Strategic Scrutiny Committee: 15 January 2026Minutes 16 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

36 of 46 attended
TR
The Right Worshipful the Lord Mayor Councillor Anne JobsonLord Mayor, present
MA
Councillor Marina AsvachinCommittee Member, present
YA
Councillor Yvonne AtkinsonCommittee Member, present
JB
Councillor James BanyardCommittee Member, present
JB
Councillor Jane BegleyCommittee Member, present
CB
Councillor Carol BennettCommittee Member, present
PB
Councillor Philip BialykCommittee Member, present
JC
Councillor James CooksonCommittee Member, present
DD
Councillor Deborah DarlingCommittee Member, present
BF
Councillor Bob FoaleCommittee Member, present
AF
Councillor Adrian FullamCommittee Member, present
LH
Councillor Lucy HaighCommittee Member, present

All 46 on the meeting page

On this subject at Exeter

Search all
  1. Strategic Scrutiny Committee - 15 January 2026This decision
  2. Strategic Scrutiny Committee - 20 November 2025Decided
  3. Strategic Scrutiny Committee - 3 November 2025 (Special)Decided
  4. Strategic Scrutiny Committee - 5 June 2025Decided
  5. Strategic Scrutiny Committee - 3 April 2025Decided
  6. Strategic Scrutiny Committee - 5 December 2024Decided

More from Exeter Council

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Exeter Harbour Board - 11 June 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Exeter Harbour Board of 11 June 2026 be received. Decided Open
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Planning Committee - 6 July 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Planning Committee of 6 July 2026 be received. Decided Open
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Planning Committee - 3 August 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Planning Committee of 3 August 2026 be received Decided Open
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Strata Joint Scrutiny Committee - 11 February 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Strata Joint Scrutiny Committee of 11 February 2026 be received. Decided Open
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Executive Committee - 15 July 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Executive Committee of 15 July 2026 be received. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies