CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Exeter City Council
Council, Tuesday 3 March 2026 at 6.10pm

Planning Committee - 19 January 2026

Decided Committee 1 paper

AI summaryExeter City Council formally received the 19 January 2026 Planning Committee minutes, which record approval of the Royal Clarence redevelopment and deferral of the Mary Arches Street co-living scheme for further design work.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedRoyal Clarence approved; Mary Arches Street deferred
MoneyS106 contributions agreedIncluding £2,394,258.82 affordable housing payment
What happens nextMary Arches to returnFor design revisions on scale and massing
Who it affectsCity centre developers and residentsTwo major redevelopment sites affected

What was decided

The Council received the minutes of the Planning Committee held on 19 January 2026.

The minutes record that Planning Committee approved the Royal Clarence redevelopment of 25 dwellings and a public house and restaurant, with building consent for the listed building, subject to a Section 106 legal agreement and conditions. Report P38, P39, P40, P44, P45

The minutes record that Planning Committee deferred the Mary Arches Street car park application, requiring further work on scale, massing and street facing design, and added a requirement that the pedestrian route through the site be treated as a permissive path. Report P76, P77, P84, P85, P86

Why

For the Royal Clarence, officers assessed heritage harm as less than substantial and judged that public benefits of restoring the fire damaged Grade II listed site outweighed that harm, applying a tilted balance due to a lack of five year housing supply. Report P27, P31, P37

For Mary Arches Street, Members considered Block B to be one storey too high and the design quality to be sub optimal, while the wider benefits of redeveloping the car park and providing 297 co-living units and 60 affordable private rent units were acknowledged. Report P70, P81, P83

What happens next

For the Royal Clarence, the Head of Service for City Development is delegated to grant permission subject to completing the Section 106 agreement, with the developer intending to start on site between late January and early February 2026. Report P31, P40

For Mary Arches Street, officers are to go back to the developer to seek further consideration of scale, massing and street facing design, with the revised scheme to be reported to a subsequent Planning Committee. Report P79, P85, P86

For the Royal Clarence, a Construction Management Plan is conditioned, with working hours of 8am to 6pm weekdays, 8am to 1pm Saturdays, and no work on Sundays or bank holidays. Report P33

The money

  • £1,284.72 per dwelling for recreational impacts on the Exe Estuary protected marine site Section 106 contribution per dwelling Report P41
  • 35% Affordable Housing to be paid as a financial contribution of £2,394,258.82 Affordable housing contribution under a Deferred Contributions Mechanism Report P43
  • £16,083 for expansion of oversubscribed GP surgeries at Barnfield Hill, Southernhay House, St Leonards Practice and St Thomas Health Centre GP surgery expansion contribution Report P43
  • £93,035 Archaeology public engagement contribution Report P59

Options considered

  • Chosen: Approve Royal Clarence application as recommended by officers. Heritage harm assessed as less than substantial and outweighed by public benefits of restoring the site Report P31, P37, P38
  • Rejected: Refuse Royal Clarence application. Officers concluded the benefits outweighed harm and the committee voted unanimously for approval Report P38
  • Chosen: Add a Section 106 requirement that the pedestrian route through the Mary Arches site be permissive and kept open unless closure is justified by anti-social behaviour. Amendment proposed by Councillor Atkinson to keep public access by default Report P73, P74, P76, P77
  • Chosen: Defer the Mary Arches application to allow officers to seek design revisions from the applicant on scale, massing and street facing elevations. Concerns that Block B was one storey too high and the design was sub optimal Report P78, P79, P84, P85
  • Rejected: Refuse the Mary Arches application. Deferral preferred as more constructive than refusal, with the developer open to revisions Report P83, P84

Implications

  • Legal: Both applications rely on Section 106 agreements under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, with a Deferred Contributions Mechanism applying to the Royal Clarence affordable housing and GP contributions. Report P40, P42, P43
  • Equalities: Disabled parking provision was raised as a concern for both sites, with Mary Arches providing only two on site disabled bays for 297 co-living units, although further on street provision could be explored. Report P49, P67
  • Other: The Mary Arches developer offered a voluntary 10% cap on full time student occupation, which cannot be enforced through planning conditions on market housing. Report P65, P67
  • Climate: Biodiversity net gain is to be supported by replacement tree planting and new tree planting secured by conditions at the Mary Arches site. Report P67
  • Risk: Construction impacts on Cathedral Green and city centre activity are to be managed through a Construction Management Plan, with restricted working hours. Report P33, P35

Who and where

  • Royal Clarence site developer, named in the papers as the applicant Report P25, P31
  • Utopia Homes, the preferred partner for the Mary Arches Street car park redevelopment Report P55
  • Residents and businesses near the Royal Clarence and Cathedral Green Report P33, P35
  • Exeter Civic Society, which spoke against the Mary Arches application Report P52, P53
  • The Synagogue on Mary Arches Street, which objected to loss of parking Report P49, P59
  • Operators of GP surgeries at Barnfield Hill, Southernhay House, St Leonards Practice and St Thomas Health Centre Report P43

Timeline

  • 1 December 2025: Previous Planning Committee minutes approved and signed Report P13
  • 8 December 2025: Previous Planning Committee minutes approved and signed Report P14
  • Monday 19 January 2026: Planning Committee meeting held, 5.30 pm to 8.31 pm Report P2, P87
  • Late January to early February 2026: Developer intended start on the Royal Clarence site, subject to legal agreement Report P31
  • 18:12 to 18:17: Brief adjournment during the Planning Committee meeting Report P46
  • 3 March 2026: Full Council received the Planning Committee minutes

Plain English for the jargon

  • Section 106: A legal agreement under section 106 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 used to secure planning obligations such as affordable housing and contributions.
  • Deferred Contributions Mechanism: An arrangement where financial contributions, including affordable housing, are reassessed after completion and any surplus value is captured through a clawback.
  • Tilted balance: Planning decision making approach applied where a council cannot demonstrate a five year housing supply, weighing sustainable development benefits more heavily.
  • Co-living: A housing format with individual studio units alongside shared kitchens, lounges and other communal facilities.
  • PBSA: Purpose built student accommodation, restricted at the Mary Arches site by a separate land covenant.
  • Less than substantial harm: A category of heritage harm under planning policy, weighed against public benefits in the planning balance.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item150

Resolved

RESOLVED that the minutes of the Planning Committee held on 19 January 2026 were received.
Word for word from the decision Exeter published for this meeting. Source: committees.exeter.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Exeter's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Council, 16 pages

PLANNING COMMITTEE

Monday 19 January 2026

Present:-

Councillor Knott (Chair) Councillors Rolstone, Asvachin, Atkinson, Banyard, Hussain, Mitchell, M, Pole, Williams, M and Bennett (as substitute for Councillor Ketchin)

Apologies

Councillors Hughes and Ketchin

Councillors in attendance under Standing Order No. 44 Councillor Moore speaking on items 5 and 6 (Minute No. 56 and 57 below)

Also Present Strategic Director for Place, Planning Solicitor, Principal Project Manager (Development) (HS), Principal Project Manager – Development Management, Principal Project Manager (Heritage) and Democratic Services Officer

51 APOLOGIES

Apologies were received from Councillor Ketchin, with Councillor Bennett attending as his substitute. It was confirmed Councillor Bennett had undertaken the required training and understood the responsibilities of the role.

Apologies were also received from Councillor Hughes.

52 MINUTES

The minutes of the meeting held on 1 December 2025 was taken as read, approved and signed by the Chair as correct.

The minutes of the meeting held on 8 December 2025 was taken as read, approved and signed by the Chair as correct.

53 DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST

No declarations of interest were made by Members.

54 LIST OF DECISIONS MADE AND WITHDRAWN APPLICATIONS

The report of the Strategic Director for Place was noted.

55 APPEALS REPORT

A Member thanked officers for their work and engagement for the appeal 24/0714 for Greencroft, Streatham Rise.

The report of the Strategic Director for Place was noted.

56 PLANNING APPLICATION NO. 25/0895/FUL & 25/0896/LBC - SITE OF ROYAL CLARENCE HOTEL The Chair invited Councillor Moore to speak under Standing Order No. 44, who made reference to:

the site being of significant historic importance and of ongoing public interest; she enquired on the expected timescale for delivery of the redevelopment, given that the developer had referred to the timelines from the previous committee stage; having a reputable developer with heritage experience was welcomed, but emphasised the need for clarity on public expectations; and a timescale was needed on record and sought confirmation on when works were likely to commence and complete.

No Member questions were raised for Councillor Moore. The Chair confirmed there were no public speakers registered to speak on the item.

The Principal Project Manager – Development Management presented the application for the redevelopment of the Royal Clarence, to include 25 new residential dwellings on the upper floors with part residential on the ground and part basement floor and commercial on the remaining ground and basement floor as a public house and restaurant.

Members received a presentation which included:

the application was for ground floor commercial units for a public house and restaurant, and 25 residential apartments above, creating a five and six storey mixed development use; the applicants had submitted an updated phasing plan (Condition 4), which was found to be acceptable and would limit heritage harm; the phasing schedule outlined when works were expected to commence and complete on the site; a previous consent was granted for a similar scheme with ground floor commercial use and flats above, with a similar external appearance; the current proposal included revised internal layouts, including a repositioned stair core, altered internal walls, larger lightwells and updated heritage considerations; the site was a Grade II listed building, surrounded by multiple high-value heritage assets and was located within a central conservation and archaeologically sensitive area; the buildings current condition was poor, having suffered fire damage, structural deterioration and water ingress; the proposed apartments met national space standards and offered acceptable resident amenities and the development would be car free; and the development would use obscured glazing, screening and noise controls to ensure there were no significant amenity impacts to neighbours.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Planning Committee: 19 January 2026Minutes 16 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

36 of 46 attended
TR
The Right Worshipful the Lord Mayor Councillor Anne JobsonLord Mayor, present
MA
Councillor Marina AsvachinCommittee Member, present
YA
Councillor Yvonne AtkinsonCommittee Member, present
JB
Councillor James BanyardCommittee Member, present
JB
Councillor Jane BegleyCommittee Member, present
CB
Councillor Carol BennettCommittee Member, present
PB
Councillor Philip BialykCommittee Member, present
JC
Councillor James CooksonCommittee Member, present
DD
Councillor Deborah DarlingCommittee Member, present
BF
Councillor Bob FoaleCommittee Member, present
AF
Councillor Adrian FullamCommittee Member, present
LH
Councillor Lucy HaighCommittee Member, present

All 46 on the meeting page

On this subject at Exeter

Search all
  1. Planning Committee - 19 January 2026This decision
  2. Planning Committee - 13 January 2025Decided
  3. Planning Committee - 27 January 2025Decided
  4. Planning Committee - 15 January 2024Decided
  5. Planning Committee - 18 January 2021Decided
  6. Planning Committee - 6 January 2020Decided

More from Exeter Council

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Exeter Harbour Board - 11 June 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Exeter Harbour Board of 11 June 2026 be received. Decided Open
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Planning Committee - 6 July 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Planning Committee of 6 July 2026 be received. Decided Open
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Planning Committee - 3 August 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Planning Committee of 3 August 2026 be received Decided Open
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Strata Joint Scrutiny Committee - 11 February 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Strata Joint Scrutiny Committee of 11 February 2026 be received. Decided Open
8 Sep 2026 Minutes of Executive Committee - 15 July 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Executive Committee of 15 July 2026 be received. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies