RESOLVED that subject to:- (i) the conditions in the report, as amended to specify that the replacement tree must be of advanced nursery stock (not less than 6 metres in height) ;and (ii) delegation to the Head of Development Management to approve the species of replacement tree CONSENT be granted to fell one Monterey Pine tree protected by TPO 209 due to stem defect/significant basal decay identified following detailed investigation. be granted.
Word for word from the decision Fareham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.fareham.gov.uk
P/14/0519/TO PARK GATE ESSO SERVICE STATION AGENT: RICHARD PROWSE FELL ONE MONTEREY PINE TREE PROTECTED BY TPO 209 DUE TO STEM DEFECT/SIGNIFICANT BASAL DECAY IDENTIFIED FOLLOWING DETAILED INVESTIGATION ESSO LOCKSHEATH SERVICE STN BRIDGE ROAD PARK GATE SOUTHAMPTON SO31 7ZE
Report By Paul Johnston - Ext.4451 Site Description This application relates to a tree situated on the frontage of the Locks Heath Service Station and adjacent to the Station Road / Bridge Road roundabout.
Description of Proposal Consent is sought to fell one monterey pine protected by TPO 209. Policies The following policies apply to this application:
Approved Fareham Borough Core Strategy CS4 - Green Infrastructure, Biodiversity and Geological Conservation CS17 - High Quality Design Fareham Borough Local Plan Review DG4 - Site Characteristics
Relevant Planning History The following planning history is relevant:
P/11/0354/TO CARRY OUT WORKS TO MONTEREY PINE COVERED BY FTPO 209 CONSENT 16/06/2011 Representations Two objections have been received objecting to the works because it is felt that further investigation is required. Further comments note that the tree is a significant landmark that should be retained.
One representation did not object to the felling but would like a replacement tree of significant size planted.
Planning Considerations - Key Issues Government guidance suggests that in considering applications to fell protected trees the Local Planning Authority are advised:
(1) to assess the amenity value of the tree or woodland and the likely impact of the proposal on the amenity of the area, and (2) in the light of their assessment at (1) above, to consider whether or not the proposal is justified, having regard to the reasons put forward in support of it.
They are advised also to consider whether any loss or damage is likely to arise if consent is refused or granted subject to conditions.
In general terms, it follows that the higher the amenity value of the tree or woodland and the greater the impact of the application on the amenity of the area, the stronger the reasons needed before consent is granted. On the other hand, if the amenity value of the tree or woodland is low then the impact of the application in amenity terms is likely to be negligible.
Tree preservation orders seek to protect trees in the interest of public amenity; therefore it follows that the removal of a protected tree should only be sanctioned where its public amenity value is outweighed by other considerations.
The subject pine is a very large and prominent mature specimen, which makes a significant contribution to the public amenity of its surroundings. The removal of this tree will only be mitigated in the long term by any replacement planting.
During a recent detailed investigation on the 20 March 2014 two Picus Tomograph (acoustic measurement) readings were undertaken at 50 & 500mm above ground level following the observation Sparassis crispa (Cauliflower fungus) around the base of the tree. The tomography revealed internal decay at the base of the main stem over approximately 50% of the cross sectional area. Sparassis typically develops in the root system, sometimes extending up into the stem base. The fungus causes a cubical 'brown-rot' resulting in virtually no tensile strength and a significant increased risk of breakage (brittle fracture) in the root-plate or at the stem base. 'Brown rot' wood decay can result in a sudden catastrophic failure without any visible adaptive growth features being exhibited by the tree. There are no failure criteria available for wood decay of the root system and stem base, which makes assessing and managing the risk of failure impossible.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.