RESOLVED that PLANNING PERMISSION be REFUSED. Reasons for Refusal The Local Planning Authority considers the horse chestnut tree to be healthy, of good shape and appearance, and of high amenity value in this prominent road side location. The proposed felling of the horse chestnut tree would be harmful to the visual amenities and the character of the area. Notes for Information It is recommended that a further investigation of the old pruning wounds on the main stem us undertaken by an arboriculturist. The applicant is advised to engage a consulting arboriculturist to undertake a tree condition survey and ongoing proactive tree safety inspections as recommended in any report.
Word for word from the decision Fareham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.fareham.gov.uk
P/17/0996/TO TITCHFIELD MR KEITH BROOKS AGENT: MR KEITH BROOKS HORSE CHESTNUT PROTECTED BY TPO 23: FELL 27A CATISFIELD ROAD FAREHAM PO15 5LT
Report By Paul Johnston - Direct Dial 01329 824451 Introduction In July 2015 the owner of 27A Catisfield Road submitted an application to fell a mature horse chestnut protected by TPO 23 on the grounds that it was dangerous due to its lean and was too large for its position.
The application was refused by the Planning Committee in August 2015 and a subsequent appeal by the applicant was dismissed by the Planning Inspectorate in December 2015.
In August 2017 the owner of 27A Catisfield Road submitted this application to fell the same mature horse chestnut on the grounds that it is dangerous and causing structural damage to the front boundary wall and the driveway forecourt of the property.
Site Description The application relates to a mature horse chestnut tree situated in the front garden of 27A Catisfield Road Fareham.
Relevant Planning History P/15/0625/TO - Fell one horse chestnut tree. REFUSED 21st August 2015. Subsequent appeal DISMISSED 22nd December 2015
Representations Four representations have been received supporting the application on the following grounds:
1) The tree is suffering from a disease causing the leaves to turn brown 2) The tree constantly sheds debris onto the road and pavement blocking drains 3) The branches obstruct the street light 4) The tree is too large for a residential front garden 5) There is too much shade and ground heave from the roots 6) Falling conkers are a hazard to pedestrians, moving vehicles and parked cars 7) The tree is causing structural damage and may cause subsidence
Three representations have been received objecting to the application on the following grounds:
1) The application is a repeat of the one in 2015 2) The supporting report is not from a professional structural engineer 3) The ground heave around the base of the tree is normal 4) The tree provides conservation and character to the area 5) This application is yet another attempt to undermine tree preservation orders 6) The positive impact of trees upon the urban environment should not be underestimated 7) The risk of slipping on tree debris may be less than the risk from particulate pollution 8) The tree makes a positive contribution to the wellbeing of the area
Planning Considerations - Key Issues Government guidance suggests that when considering tree work applications the Local Planning Authority is advised:
(1) to assess the amenity value of the tree or woodland and the likely impact of the proposal on the amenity of the area, and (2) in the light of their assessment at (1) above, to consider whether or not the proposal is justified, having regard to the reasons put forward in support of it.
They are advised also to consider whether any loss or damage is likely to arise if consent is refused or granted subject to conditions.
In general terms, it follows that the higher the amenity value of the tree or woodland and the greater the impact of the application on the amenity of the area, the stronger the reasons needed before consent is granted. On the other hand, if the amenity value of the tree or woodland is low, the impact of the application in amenity terms is likely to be negligible.
Tree preservation orders seek to protect trees in the interest of public amenity; therefore it follows that the removal of a protected tree should only be sanctioned where its public amenity value is outweighed by other considerations.
HEALTH OF THE TREE
The horse chestnut was visually inspected from ground level on 28 September 2017. The tree is a mature specimen situated in the front garden of 27a Catisfield Road approximately 1.5 metres from the front boundary with the public highway (photos at Appendix A). The trunk has a circa 10% lean to the north/ northeast and the crown is weighted over the highway to the northeast.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.