Resolved
RESOLVED that PLANNING PERMISSION be REFUSED. Reasons for Refusal: The development would be contrary to Policies CS2, CS4, CS5, CS6, CS14, CS16, CS17, CS18, CS20, CS21 and CS22 of the Adopted Fareham Borough Core Strategy 2011 and Policies DSP5, DSP6, DSP13, DS14, DSP15 and DSP40 of the adopted Local Plan Part 2: Development Sited and Policies Plan; And, Paragraphs 109, 129, 131, 132 and 134 of the National Planning Policy Framework; and is unacceptable in that: (a) the application site lies outside of the defined urban settlement boundary on land which is considered to form part of a ‘valued landscape’. As a result the proposed development would result in a range of significant adverse landscape and visual effects, harmful to the landscape character, appearance and function of the countryside and failing to respect or respond positively to the key characteristics of the surrounding area. In addition the proposed development would adversely affect the integrity of the strategic gap and the physical and visual separation of settlements; (b) the proposal would be harmful to, and fail to preserve and enhance, the setting of nearby Grade ll * Listed Buildings; (c) the proposal would result in the loss of best and most versatile agricultural land; (d) had it not been for the overriding reasons for refusal the Council would have sought details of the SuDS strategy including the mechanism for securing its long-term maintenance; (e) had it not been for the overriding reasons for refusal the Council would have sought the on-site provision of affordable housing at a level in accordance with the requirements of the local plan; (f) had it not been for the overriding reasons for refusal the Council would have sought ecological mitigation, compensation and enhancement measures to ensure that all protected species are taken into account during and after construction. These would include alternative provision for habitats, including networks and connectivity and future management and maintenance arrangements; (g) in the absence of a legal agreement to secure such, the proposal would fail to provide satisfactory mitigation of the ‘in combination’ effects that the proposed increase in residential units on the site would cause through increased recreational disturbance on the Solent Coastal Special Protection Areas; (h) in the absence of a legal agreement to secure such, the proposal fails to provide satisfactory details of the design long term management and ownership and associated costs of the proposed Bird Conservation Area to the east of the application site. As a result the proposal fails to provide adequate mitigation, compensation and enhancement measures in relation to the effects of the development on qualifying features of the Solent and Southampton Water Special Protection Area (SPA); (i) in the absence of a legal agreement securing provision of open space and facilities and their associated management and maintenance, the recreational needs of residents of the proposed development would not be met; (j) in the absence of a legal agreement to secure such, the proposal fails to mitigate against the adverse effects of the development on the safety and operation of the strategic and local highway network in the form of a financial contribution towards off-site highway improvements; (k) in the absence of a legal agreement to secure the submission and implementation of a full Travel Plan, payment of the Travel Plan approval and monitoring fees and provision of a surety mechanism to ensure implementation of the Travel Plan, the proposed development would not make the necessary provision to ensure measures are in place to assist in reducing the dependency on the use of the private motorcar; and (l) in the absence of a legal agreement to secure a financial contribution towards improvements to the local public rights of way network , the proposal fails to mitigate the harm from the increased usage of public rights of way as a direct result of the development. Note for information: Had it not been for the overriding reasons for refusal to the proposal, the Local Planning Authority would have sought to address point d) above through the imposition of a suitably worded planning condition and points e) – l) above by inviting the applicant to enter into a legal agreement with Fareham Borough Council under Section 106 of the Town & Country Planning Act 1990.