RESOLVED - i) That the full planning applications and outline applications specified in the appendix to these minutes be granted , refused or referred to the Department for Communities and Local Government or deferred as indicated subject to the conditions, if any, as specified therein and to any other appropriate conditions of a routine or standard nature. ii) That the applications granted in accordance with delegated powers be noted.
Word for word from the decision Gateshead published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gateshead.gov.uk
DC/17/01247/FUL [name removed] Dairy South Farm Lamesley NE11 0ET
Proposal:
Erection of animal shelter including change of use of portion of field to form a fenced enclosure (amended 01/03/18)
Declarations of Interest Nature of Interest
None None
List of speakers and details of any additional information submitted:
[name removed] (applicant) spoke in favour of the application.
Further information for members:-
Officers requested the submission of a drawing showing the internal floor plan of the proposed building to demonstrate that it will be laid out as four stables and to help explain why the building has the footprint proposed. The applicant has failed to provide the requested plan and thus has not been able to allay officers concerns that the footprint of the building proposed is excessive.
Referring to the British Horse Society’s (BHS) website:
As a guide the BHS minimum stable size recommendations are:
horses: 3.65m x 3.65m (12ft x 12ft) large horses: 3.65m x 4.24m (12ft x14ft)
As a guide the Donkey Sanctuary minimum stable sizes for donkeys are:
mules: 3.65m x 3.65m (12ft x12ft) donkeys: 3.05m x 3.05m (10ft x 10ft) large donkeys: 3.05m x 3.65m (10ft x 12ft)
Based on the above, using the dimensions for large horses and large donkeys, the proposed shelter should have a minimum internal footprint of 53.3 square metres to adequately accommodate 2 horse and 2 donkeys. This application proposes a building with an internal footprint of 105 square metres, which is almost double what is recognised as appropriate accommodation for 2 large horses and 2 large donkeys.
Officers consider that this shows that the building proposed is excessively large and it fails to preserve the openness of the Green Belt; therefore reinforcing that is can only be considered as inappropriate development, for which no very special circumstance has been demonstrated.
Further to the above, the BHS also provide guidance on the area of pasture required for each animal. They recommend1.25-2.5 acres per horse and 0.5 acres per donkey. Based on the location plan submitted with this application it is considered that the total area of pasture available to the applicant is approximately 3.5 acres. Therefore, on the basis of having 4 animals on site, there is only enough space for 2 donkeys and 2 small horses. This further supports Officer’s concerns that the size of the building proposed is excessively large and hence inappropriate in the Green Belt.
Decision(s) and any conditions attached:
That permission be REFUSED for the following reason(s) and that the Strategic Director of Communities and Environment be authorised to add, vary and amend the refusal reasons as necessary:
1. The proposed development represents inappropriate development, which by definition is harmful to the Green Belt and no very special circumstance has been demonstrated to outweigh the harm. Therefore, the proposed development is contrary to the National Planning Policy Framework and policy CS19 of the Core Strategy and Urban Core Plan.
Any additional comments on application/decision:
None. Date of Committee: 7 March 2018
Application Number and Address: Applicant:
DC/17/01358/OUT [name removed] Monkridge Gardens Residents Association and lands at 21 and 23 and land south of 9-23 Monkridge Gardens Dunston Hill Gateshead NE11 9XE
Proposal:
Outline planning permission with all matters reserved for the clearance, lowering and levelling of site and the erection of up to 10 dwelling houses, with a new shared-surfaced vehicular and pedestrian access.
Declarations of Interest:
Name Nature of Interest
None
List of speakers and details of any additional information submitted:
Councillor Peter Maughan spoke against the application.
[name removed] (Agent) spoke in favour of the application.
Further information for members
Withdrawal of objection/removal of refusal reason
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.