Resolved
That permission be REFUSED for the following reason(s) and that the Service Director of Climate Change, Compliance, Planning and Transport be authorised to add, vary and amend the refusal reasons as necessary 1. The site is included within a Conservation Area that is designated as being Heritage at Risk. The site is also within a non-designated locally listed Park and Garden of special interest. The introduction of housing in this distinctively and long-established farming section of the estate is alien and harmful to the character and appearance of the area. Furthermore, the proposal would see the introduction of dwellings in the open barn structures that would be alien to and cause less than substantial harm to the significance of the heritage assets. No public benefit has been put forward to outweigh this harm and therefore the proposal is considered to be contrary to local planning policies MSGP24, MSGP25 and MSGP26 and the National Planning Policy Framework on design and heritage impact grounds. 2. Insufficient information, in the form of noise and odour impact assessment, has been provided. Without such assessments it cannot be demonstrated that the proposal for new dwellings within a working farm would not cause an adverse impact on the residential amenity of the intended occupants. The proposal therefore fails to accord with residential amenity and noise policies MSGP17 and MSGP18 of the Local Plan and the NPPF. 3. The proposed development, which would be in close proximity to a working farm, has the potential for conflict between residential and agricultural traffic with safe access for all users not being demonstrated. The site is accessed by a poor access road that does not accommodate two-way traffic and there are no footways from the adopted highway to the site and no street lighting. Furthermore, the site would be located well away from any public transport links meaning there is no sustainable travel opportunities. The proposal is therefore unacceptable on transport and highway safety grounds due to a failure to comply with policy MSGP15 of the Local Plan and the National Planning Policy Framework.