That the Service Manager, Development Services be authorised to take all enforcement action including the service of any necessary enforcement notices and proceedings through the courts in conjunction with the Director of Organisational Development & Democratic Services to ensure compliance with Condition 3 of Planning application 0196/2016.
Word for word from the decision Gedling published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gedling.gov.uk
1.1On the 12th October 2011 planning permission was granted to ‘erect a two storey side extension plus loft conversion with 1 dormer window’ (Reference 2011/0968) at 143 Gedling Road, Arnold. . 1.2 The permission was subject to a number of conditions including Condition 3 which stated:
Condition 3 - The windows proposed to be inserted in the side elevation of the proposed two storey side extension shall be obscured glazed and fixed shut at all times. The window to the other side elevation of the existing dwelling shall be obscured glazed and fixed shut at all times. The roof light to the rear elevation roof slope of the 2 storey side extension shall be obscured glazed and fixed shut at all times.
1.3There are two windows in the side elevation of the extension, a window to the loft area and a window to the ensuite bathroom. On the 21st November 2016 the Council received a complaint alleging the windows in the side elevation of the extension were being opened on a regular basis.
1.4Officers visited the site on several occasions but at the time of the visits nobody was at home. Although the windows appeared to be obscure glazed and the windows were all closed, access was not gained to confirm the fact the windows were non-opening.
1.5Letters were sent to the occupier to remind them of the requirements of Condition 3 but no response was received. 1.6 On Tuesday 30th May 2017, a photograph was sent to the Council by the complainant showing the window on the side elevation of the extension to be open.
2 Assessment
2.1The power to impose conditions on planning permissions is an extremely important part of the development management process in order to safeguard matters of planning importance, mitigate the impact caused by the development and ensure the development is acceptable in all planning aspects.
2.2Conditions have to be necessary, relevant to planning, relevant to the development to be permitted, precise, enforceable and reasonable in all other aspects. Conditions should only be imposed where they fulfil all the above criteria (known as the “six tests”). If not, they are likely to fail if challenged at appeal.
2.3In this case, Condition 3 was imposed to ‘protect the privacy of the adjoining dwellings, in accordance with the aims of Policy ENV1 of the Gedling Borough Replacement Local Plan (Certain Saved Policies 2008)’. It is considered the condition complies with the six tests and that the open window has a detrimental impact on the privacy of the adjoining neighbour. 2.4 As the occupiers have failed to enter into any dialogue with the Council, there are two main options available to the local authority when a condition is being breached:
i) to issue a Breach of Condition Notice (BCN) which will require the recipient to remedy the breach. There is no right of appeal to the secretary of state and breach of a BCN is a criminal offence punishable by a maximum fine of £2,500 ; or
ii) to issue a Breach of Condition Enforcement Notice which will require the recipient to take steps to remedy the breach. There is a right of appeal to the Secretary of State which would suspend the notice until the appeal has been determined. Breach of an enforcement notice is also a criminal offence punishable by a maximum fine of £20,000 on summary conviction if it is not adhered to once it has come into effect.
2.5As this is a straightforward breach of condition it is considered the simpler Breach of Condition Notice is the most appropriate action to take in this instance.
Time limits for taking action
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.