That the Service Manager, Development Services in conjunction with the Director of Organisational Development & Democratic Services be authorised to take all enforcement action necessary including the service of any enforcement notices and proceedings through the courts to ensure the unauthorised garage is demolished and the garden area re-instated.
Word for word from the decision Gedling published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gedling.gov.uk
1.1Planning permission was granted on the 10th June 2016 for ground and first floor extensions to create a two storey dwelling together with a detached garage at No. 6 Jessops Lane, Gedling, (Reference 2016/0148).
1.2The work commenced around September 2016 but in October 2016 it was brought to the Council’s attention, the detached garage to the front of the dwelling was not being built in the approved location on the site; it was being built closer to the front boundary of the property and nearer the highway.
1.3In addition, the approved alterations to the single storey projection to the rear of the property had not been built as approved. The approved plans showed there would be an increase in the width of the ground floor by 0.5m to the north eastern elevation and alteration of the original flat roof to a double gable. The development has actually been constructed to include a single gable with a mono-pitch design.
1.4The owner was asked to stop work and submit a retrospective application for the alterations by varying condition 2 of the original planning permission which required the development to be built in accordance with the approved plans.
1.5The application seeking to vary condition 2 was received on the 27th January 2017, (Reference 2017/0154) and on the 19th April 2017, a report was presented to the Planning Committee where Members resolved to refuse the application.
1.6An appeal was subsequently made to the Planning Inspectorate seeking to overturn the Council’s decision. On 15th August 2017 the Inspector issued her decision dismissing the appeal. 2 ASSESSMENT
2.1The site formally comprised of a detached bungalow set back from the front boundary with the highway by approximately 10metres. The level of the garden is elevated about 1 metre from the level of the highway. The levels in and around the site fall to the north east, setting the application site at a higher level than the neighbouring property, No. 8 Jessops Lane (a detached bungalow) and lower level than the neighbouring property No. 4 Jessops Lane (a two storey detached dwelling) . The detached garage has been built forward of the previously approved position and is now around 1.2 metres from the front boundary wall.
2.2In both the approved and proposed locations, the garage would be visible within the street scene. However, the garage, which is partly built to roof level, has been erected on the site closer to the highway than approved and when combined with its elevated position, it is considered the garage is unduly prominent and incongruous within a residential area where the majority of other dwellings and outbuildings are set back from the front boundary.
2.3In addition, the height and length of the garage’s side elevation are considerably above the height of the boundary wall, leading to an oppressive effect on pedestrians walking past the site along the lower pedestrian footway. This is contrary to the aims of Policy 10 of the Aligned Core Strategy; Design and Enhancing Local Identity which among other things requires new development to make a positive contribution to the public realm and a sense of place, including through the creation of attractive and safe environments and through reinforcing valued local characteristics such as street patterns and the position of buildings and the layout of spaces.
2.4The development is also contrary to the similar development criteria set out on Policy ENV1 of the Replacement Local Plan (Saved Policies 2014) and the requirements of the National Planning Policy Framework (Part 7) which requires good design.
2.5The Planning Inspector has stated in her decision letter, “The visual dominance of the garage and its poor relationship with the surrounding properties is noticeable on both approaches along Jessops Lane, particularly from the nearby junction and when viewed from the opposite side of the road”.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.