Resolved that (1) the Head of Financial Services be authorised to implement the use of an incentive for direct debit payments by council tax payers and council tenants with a prize draw of £250 which the winner may keep or donate to a charity; (2) a budget of £6,000 to be met from the Performance Improvement Reserve be approved.
Word for word from the decision Gravesham published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gravesham.gov.uk
1. That the cabinet endorses an incentive for direct debit of a competition with a prize draw of £250 which the winner may keep or donate to charity (paragraph 4.9)
2. Subject to (1) above, that a budget of £6,000 is set for this exercise to be met from the Performance Improvement Reserve.
3. That subject to (1) and (2) above, the Head of Financial Services is authorised to proceed with its implementation.
1. Introduction
1.1Following an examination of the efficiency gains from the increased use of direct debit, the Management Team has identified it as a priority for the year.
1.2Efforts at DD penetration are gaining increasing significance in value for money judgements for the Comprehensive Performance Assessment.
1.3Compared to similar authorities, Gravesham’s DD collection rate of 47% for council tax is low and offers potential for improvement.
1.3The analysis however suggests a more limited scope for an increase in the 13% of tenants who pay their rent by DD.
1.4At the request of Management Team, the Head of Financial Services has undertaken further research on the use of incentives to improve take-up. 2. Overview of Strategy
2.1A range of initiatives has been drawn up for the campaign (Appendix A)
2.2A co-ordinated approach across departments has been agreed to offer better value and ensure consistency.
3. Potential Efficiency Savings and Targets
3.1The immediate cashable savings are relatively small.
3.2Research shows that the transaction cost of a cash payment is 50p more than DD, thus giving an average saving of £5 a year for each council tax payer or rent payer who changes over.
3.3The council would make a cashable saving of £2,000 per annum for every 1% increase in DD take-up.
3.4However, increased take-up of DD has even more significant gains arising from the reduction in debt recovery activities and back-office functions. Fewer incoming calls, letters and emails and a drop in reminder notices and court summonses would release resources for alternative purposes.
3.5Based on the target of 5% improvement set for council tax, the estimated total savings in 2007/08 would be £108,119 of which £17,175 would be cashable (Appendix B).
3.6Preliminary analysis suggests that the target of 5% improvement set for council tax payers this year is achievable.
3.7The high proportion of rent payers either in receipt of income support or on a low income restricts the use of DD as a method of payment.
3.8Consequently only a 1% increase in DD is envisaged among rent payers in 2007/08, giving a saving of £3,987 of which £1,263 is cashable (Appendix B).
4. Choice of Incentives
4.1In researching the range of incentives, discussions have been held with a number of councils which have undertaken successful DD campaigns.
4.2Some initiatives that have proved effective in some authorities are considered unsuitable in our circumstances. They include Reading Borough Council’s withdrawal of giro payment slips and the closure of cash offices in Salisbury District Council and North Warwickshire Borough Council. 4.3 Some incentive schemes have distinctly favoured DD payers as in the case of Warrington MBC which supplies 32 weeks of school dinner vouchers for the price of 30, if payment is made by DD.
4.4The frequent radio advertising which gave Bristol City Council some 2,000 new DD payers is considered too expensive.
4.5However, the experience of Maidstone Borough Council with a DD collection rate of 70% suggests that success may equally be achieved by cost-effective and less radical measures which combine financial and non-financial incentives.
4.6The main costs in our strategy would be in the design, production, distribution and display of publicity material on DD.
4.7Based on the research, 3 main initiatives are proposed for consideration.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.