Resolved that application GR/04/1098 be REFUSED on the following grounds:- (1) the proposal will introduce conflicts between pedestrian and vehicular traffic on a narrow, unmade road to the detriment of road safety. The proposal is therefore contrary to Policy T5 of the adopted Gravesham Local Plan First Review 1994; (2) the proposal constitutes an over-intensive form of development on the site. The proposed design and massing of the development would result in an excessively dominant appearance, harmful to the amenity of the surrounding area. The development is therefore contrary to Polices H2, H3 and TC1 of the adopted Gravesham Local Plan First Review 1994.
Word for word from the decision Gravesham published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gravesham.gov.uk
Land rear of Ranmorene, Old Watling Street, Gravesend.
Erection of a detached two bedroom bungalow with detached double garage
P Dale
To seek members’ instructions on the possible ground of refusal, the resource implications of refusing permission, and how the council’s case could be represented on appeal.
1. Introduction
This application was considered originally at the meeting of the Regulatory Board on 15 November 2006 at which it was deferred for a site visit. The site visit took place on 25 November 2006.
Members are asked to bring their copy of Agenda Item 7 of the Regulatory Board meeting on 15 November and Agenda Item 8 of the Regulatory Board meeting on 13 December to this meeting.
The recommendation of the Director (Planning and Regeneration) was to grant permission subject to conditions.
The Board, however, resolved that it is minded to REFUSE planning permission
2. Possible grounds of refusal
The Director (Planning and Regeneration) has recommended the following ground of refusal:-
1. The proposal will result in the creation of a pedestrian and vehicular access onto a narrow carriageway which will be unsafe. This proposal is therefore contrary to Policy T5 of the adopted Gravesham Local Plan First Review 1994.
2. The proposal constitutes an over-intensive form of development on the site. The proposed design and massing of the development would result in an excessively dominant appearance, harmful to the amenity of the surrounding area. The development is therefore contrary to Policies H2, H3 and TC1 of the adopted Gravesham Local Plan First Review. 3. Resource implications
The Director (Planning and Regeneration) had recommended permission for the current planning application. If permission is refused, depending on the type of appeal, it may be necessary to engage an external consultant experienced in planning matters to defend the Council’s decision on appeal.
Aside from the financial cost of employing a consultant there would be some administrative costs involved in any appeal, involving staff in the Committee Section and Engineering and Planning staff. It would also involve staff in Legal Services if an appeal goes to a Public Inquiry.
4. The risk of a claim for costs against the council
Members should be aware that the applicant, in lodging an appeal, may claim costs against the Council and if Council is not able to substantiate the grounds of refusal on appeal on the basis of the development plan policies and other material planing considerations, the Planning Inspectorate may consider the decision as unreasonable and award costs against the Council.
Government circular 8/93 states that “planning authorities are not bound to adopt, or include as part of their case, the professional or technical advice given by their own officers, or received from statutory bodies or consultees. They will be expected to show that they had reasonable planning grounds for taking a decision contrary to such advice, and they are able to produce relevant evidence to support their decision in all respects. If they fail to do so costs may be awarded against the authority” (Paragraph 9, Annex 3).
In the event of a successful costs claim by the applicant under these circumstances, it is not possible to estimate what the possible amount might be, as this will depend on the method of appeal and what witnesses the appellant called.
Members’ instructions are requested:
To seek members’ instructions on the possible ground of refusal, the resource implications of refusing permission, and how the council’s case could be represented on appeal.
REPORT NO 2 PAGE 2
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.