CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Gravesham Borough Council
Cabinet, Monday 16 November 2009 at 7.00pm

Review of Scrutiny Procedures

Agreed Executive 3 papers

Cabinet agreed this item on Monday 16 November 2009. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item79

Resolved

The Cabinet agreed that the recommendations contained in paragraph 2 of the report be endorsed.
Word for word from the decision Gravesham published for this meeting. Source: democracy.gravesham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Gravesham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Review of Overview Scrutiny Procedures at Gravesham Borough Council

Report of the Task Group

1 Executive summary.

1.1At the request of the Cabinet a task group consisting of the Deputy Leader, Cllr David Turner, as Chairman along with Cllr John Burden the Chairman of Scrutiny, Cllr John Cubitt the Lead Member for Community Safety/Environment and Cllrs Andrea Webb and Harold Craske both substitutes for the Overview Scrutiny Committee was set up to undertake the review.

1.2Terms of reference

To review by various means, including learning visits to other authorities and the involvement of South East Employers, the Overview Scrutiny function within the Council and identify if the committee could better fulfil its role through

• pre-Cabinet scrutiny of key decisions and the role that Overview Scrutiny Committee or the Policy Overview Committees may play in this process

• an improved relationship between the Cabinet Overview Scrutiny Committee, and what form this could take

• the development of a clear protocol for use of the call-in tool, and

• enhanced selection and prioritisation of topics for scrutiny review

To submit recommendations to Cabinet and Overview Scrutiny Committee based on the evidence gathered during the review.

1.3Recommendations to Cabinet are:-

1. That the committee maintains political impartiality, including appointment of an opposition member as chairman.

2. That the Executive acknowledges the importance of impartiality and values it, not least in the light of the view of the Audit Commission and the way it will view the council if the functions of scrutiny are not seen to be working (see note below).

3. That there is follow up on the implementation of recommendations: (1) At meeting following their resolution, response to recommendations. (2) After 6 months, automatic agenda item to receive report on (a) actions completed and their outcomes and (b) status of actions in progress.

4. That members of the ruling group on the committee be encouraged to freely challenge the Executive without being ‘primed’ on what questions to ask.

5. That a form for call-ins be implemented, to include the reasons for the call-in, and a format for discussing called-in items be agreed.

Page 1 of 12 6. That there be cross-party agreement of criteria for call-in.

7. That there be additional training for members to include the scrutiny of partnerships (eg CDRP, LSP, local boards, delivery board).

8. That there is ability for the Overview Scrutiny Committee to co-opt other councillors with specific expertise onto scrutiny in a non- voting capacity when appropriate.

9. That there is ability for the Overview Scrutiny Committee to co-opt non-elected members with specific expertise onto scrutiny, in a non-voting capacity.

10. That there be further investigation into practicality of pre-decision scrutiny at GBC and report back in two months.

11. That POCs be permitted and encouraged to identify actions/ projects in support of council policies.

12. That suggestions for topic reviews from a wider audience including cabinet, POCs, other members, officers and the public be permitted and encouraged.

13. That a rolling programme of topic reviews be established and maintained.

14. That informal mechanisms for local health scrutiny reviews be developed and strengthening of district representation on county health scrutiny committees be sought.

15. That a work programme be developed based on the strategic aims of the Sustainable Community Strategy.

16. That a methodology for the scrutiny of partnerships be developed.

17. That protocols for Councillor Call for Action (CCfA) be developed.

Note

At a recent seminar on the function of scrutiny in CAA Alison Kelly (Strategy Advisor Governance and Accountability for the Audit Commission) stated that scrutiny was “absolutely key” to an authority’s future prospects for improvement under CAA.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Final reportoverviewscrutinyReport 102 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Minute 14Report 21 KB Download
PDF
Review of Scrutiny ProceduresReport 30 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

13 of 18 attended
NB
Nick BrownOfficer, present
KB
Kevin BurbidgeOfficer, present
JB
Cllr John BurdenGuest, in attendance
JC
Cllr John CallerGuest, in attendance
NC
Nick ChannonOfficer, present
LC
Cllr Lee CroxtonGuest, in attendance
JC
Cllr John CubittCommittee Member, present
HD
Hardip DhaliwalOfficer, expected
JG
Julie GibbsOfficer, present
LH
Cllr Laura HryniewiczCommittee Member, present
SK
Sarah KilkieOfficer, present
MN
Melanie NorrisOfficer, present

All 18 on the meeting page

On this subject at Gravesham

Search all
  1. Review of Scrutiny ProceduresThis decision
  2. Scrutiny Review of Street Cleanliness, littering, and Fly-tipping throughout the BoroughAgreed
  3. Scrutiny Review of GBC's Maritime Strategy - Oral UpdateNoted
  4. Scrutiny Reviews Oral UpdateAgreed
  5. Scrutiny Reviews - Oral UpdateAgreed
  6. Scrutiny Review Programme - Future work planAgreed

More from Gravesham Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
2 Nov 2026 Refuse Vehicle ProcurementTo procure three refuse collection vehicles (one new vehicle and two new chassis with replacement body vehicles) to s... Refused Open
28 Sep 2026 Change to Order of BusinessIt was agreed that the order of business, during the meeting, be amended accordingly. Agreed Open
28 Sep 2026 Cygnet Leisure Centre - Wet Side ImprovementsDecision, outlining the intention to part fund the refurbishment, was published on 14 July 2026 GCLL had provided a p... Noted Open
28 Sep 2026 Gravesham Borough Council's response to 'The Shift'· The Council will work with the Shift Committee & young people to explore, design & develop an interim community spa... Decided Open
28 Sep 2026 LGA Corporate Peer Challenge - Progress Review Follow-up· That the content of the LGA Corporate Peer Challenge Progress Review report be noted · That the process for publish... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies