Cabinet was reminded of the background leading to the choice of a hydraulic lift in the public areas. The existing lift had served the Council well. There had been a significant increase in the use of it by other organisations and the number of trips undertaken carrying a large amount of equipment and heavy weights far exceeded that envisaged. This had led to the lift breaking down on a frequent basis, often with people inside. The lift was a key element of the Council fulfilling its obligations under the Equality Act 2010. Following a tendering exercise, two key contractors had been shortlisted for the possible repair of the lift and following that consulted about its replacement. The outcome of that consultation was that both companies suggested that a traction lift be used. Having investigated the options, officers’ recommended to Cabinet that the Apex product was the one most suited to the Council’s needs and since it was an open contract the maintenance of the lift could be undertaken by an alternative company. Resolved that the Assistant Director (Governance and Law) be authorised to enter into a contract with Apex Lifts to replace the Civic Centre Foyer Lift with a budget of £78,000 being made available for the project.
Word for word from the decision Gravesham published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gravesham.gov.uk
1.1As part of the Accommodating Excellence programme (2005-06) a third lift was installed to service the Council Chamber, Committee rooms, Kent room / auditorium and box office, foyer and basement toilets / Blake Gallery and make the building fully accessible and inclusive for all, thus complying with the then current Disability Discrimination Act 1995.
1.2The north and south lifts are traction operated with a plant room immediately above the lift shaft. Due to the constraints of the building it was not possible to accommodate a plant room above the foyer lift shaft so a hydraulic lift was the only viable option at the time.
1.3Over the last few years the use of the public areas of the building has increased significantly due to hirings and further changes and intensification of use within that area (e.g. City Praise, Blake Gallery, Lower Hall and Changing Place facility). As a result the foyer lift is the most used lift within the building and can be in use constantly seven days a week. It is also probably fair to say that its use, in terms of ‘dead-weights’ carried (e.g. for City Praise and Woodville) and the number of trips is greater than could possibly be envisaged when it was designed and installed. 1.4 As a result the lift is becoming increasingly prone to breakdowns, often with people inside. Two lift contractors, who undertake repairs to the lift, were asked to provide costed schedules of what works they thought were required to redress all the problems with the lift and the information provided is as follows:
Contractor Recommendation Cost Pickerings Replace hydraulic power pack £11,200 Bi-stable switch / tape heat and tape £ 1,370 Modernisation package – control panel, flexes and £15,640 rewire Variable frequency door drive package and retractable £ 6,800 skates Total £35,010
Contractor Recommendation Cost Otis Hydraulic oil change (included within hydraulic power £3,361 pack recommended by Pickerings) Full valve service (included within hydraulic power £1,926 pack recommended by Pickerings) Total £5,287
1.5However both companies advised that they could not guarantee that if these repairs were undertaken the lift would work trouble free and co-incidentally the most recent breakdown was due to a new fault.
1.6When this lift is out of operation, the building is no longer fully accessible thus not fulfilling the Council’s obligations under the Equality Act 2010 in relation to providing an inclusive building.
1.7As a result of the ongoing issues and the uncertainty that a potential spend of £35-40,000 would guarantee no further problems a specialist consultant was appointed to prepare and tender a specification for a replacement lift suitable for the Council’s needs for further consideration.
1.8Over the last ten years the space required for a traction lift plant has reduced significantly to the extent that it is now possible to install a traction lift and all associated plant within the existing shaft of the foyer lift. The advice received from lift engineers and the lift consultant is that traction lifts are more reliable than hydraulic operated systems.
2. Current Position
2.1The lift renewal has been tendered with the initial results for a traction operated lift being as follows:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.