20190169 - Demolition of existing house and outbuildings and erection of a part four storey and part three storey building for the residential development of 20 no.
DeferredPlanning4 papers
Planning Committee deferred this item on Wednesday 12 June 2019. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
(a) that application 20190169 be DEFERRED to enable negotiations with the applicant and/or the applicant’s agent to address the Board’s concerns in regard to all five grounds of refusal, as the Board considered a residential reuse of this site to be justifiable subject to revisions/amendments and additional information being agreed with officers and being formally submitted, with the instruction that the application be reported back to the Regulatory Board (Planning) on 4 September 2019 for Members to consider the revisions/amendments and additional information submitted, at that time. The concerns of the Regulatory Board (Planning) included that the proposed development fails to make any provision for affordable housing, or any other developer contributions and as such the proposal is contrary to Policy CS10 and CS16 of the Borough Council's adopted Gravesham Local Plan Core Strategy (September 2014) and National Planning Policy Framework; and (b) that should the applicant and/or applicant’s agent decline to enter meaningful negotiations then the application be reported back to the Regulatory Board (Planning) on 4 September 2019 for Members to determine the application in line with the officer’s original recommendation.
Word for word from the decision Gravesham published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gravesham.gov.uk
SUMMARY REPORT Application Ref: 20190169 Site Address: Cobham Lodge, Valley Drive, Gravesend, DA12 5UE.
Demolition of existing house and outbuildings and erection of a Application part four storey and part three storey building for the residential Description: development of 20no. one bedroom, 41no. two bedroom and 3no. three bedroom apartments with associated car parking.
Decision Level: Planning Regulatory Board – 12 June 2019
Reason for referral: Major development proposal
Recommendation: Refusal
Summary of Reasons for Recommendation
The proposal is to demolish the existing house and all outbuildings on the site and construct a part four storey and three storey building to provide 20 X one bedroom, 41 two bedroom and 3 three bedroom apartments.
In this case there are significant objections to the development relating to the siting, size, bulk, massing, design, impact on the street scene, adverse impact on the amenity of surrounding properties and poor amenity for future occupiers. Furthermore this proposal is failing to provide affordable housing or any S.106 contributions.
As such it is considered that this planning permission cannot be supported.
1.1Concern has been raised by a Councillor regarding the impact on a number of surrounding trees which are protected by a Tree Preservation Order. 1.2 The Tree Preservation Order (TPO) is at the southern end of Valley Drive which covers 8 sites including the application site of Cobham Lodge. The following diagram shows the location of trees from when the order was made in 1989 (Please note since the TPO came into force in 1989 there has been various infill developments in the vicinity of the area).
1.3The application is accompanied by an Arboricultural Impact Assessment and a Tree Protection Plan which demonstrates that trees T9-T15 within the grounds of the property to the south known as The Ridges/Valley View (Valley View was built in the rear garden of The Ridges) would be adequately protected during the build through the use of tree protection barriers and no development is proposed within the root protection areas of those trees. If the application was to be supported it would be appropriate to secure these protection through the imposition of appropriate planning conditions.
1.4Tree T8 which is to the south east of the dwelling has been felled, although the Local Planning Authority has no record of agreeing to the felling of this tree. This matter will be investigated separately.
1.5To the front of the property is protected tree T7, which is an established Beech Tree. This tree is considered to have at least 20 + years life left and has no significant defects. Should consent be granted it would be appropriate to impose conditions requiring this tree to be protected during the construction using tree protection methods and ensuring that no development takes place within the root protection area.
1.6The only trees lost as a result of this proposed development would be a 7m cypress tree and a 4m high spruce tree in the north east corner of the site. If the development were to commence, the loss of these trees would be unfortunate, but they are not protected by the TPO. Furthermore should the scheme be supported, a condition requiring the replacement of these two trees, with trees of an appropriate age/size, could be secured by way of a planning condition.
1.7On the north-western side of the application site is a birch tree, whilst to the south-west of the site is a group for 4 laurel trees and a birch tree. None of these trees are impacted by this development. ____________________________________________________________________ Recommendation
The recommendation remains unchanged from that set out on the main papers, being a recommendation for REFUSAL on 5 grounds.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
20190169: Demolition of existing house and outbuildings and erection of a part four storey and part three storey building for the residential development of 20 no. one bedroom, 41 no. two bedroom and 3 no. three bedroom apartments with associated car parking: Cobham Lodge, Valley Drive: report heReport
65a20190169 - Demolition of existing house and outbuildings and erection of a part four storey and part three storey building for the residential development of 20 no.This decision
20190169 - Demolition of existing house and outbuildings and erection of a part four storey and part three storey building for the residential development of 20 no.This decision
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.