(1) That the “Not for Publication” report from PwC Paper one : Financial modelling analysis (referred to as Appendix 1 to the report submitted to the Executive), be noted. (2) That the capital structure of North Downs Housing Ltd be changed to capitalise the company through a mix of share equity and debt financing at a ratio of 40% equity and 60% debt. (3) That the grant of a 25-year secure variable rate loan of £1.44 million to the company be approved at an initial interest rate of Bank of England (BoE) Base rate plus 5% (i.e., 5.5%) to be drawn down in stages as required. (4) That the investment of £0.96 million in equity shares of the company, financed from the pre-April 2013 housing capital receipts reserve, to be drawn down alongside the loan, be approved. (5) That the Head of Financial Services be authorised, in consultation with the Lead Councillor for Finance, to determine the financing arrangements, including the interest rate applicable to any loans with reference to the Bank of England base rate, granted to North Downs Housing Ltd by the Council. Reason for To enable financing arrangements to be agreed swiftly having regard to market conditions prevailing at the time. Alternative options considered and rejected by the Executive: None Details of any conflict of interest declared by the Leader or lead councillors and any dispensation granted: None
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
As noted above, the Council are seeking to create a wholly owned corporate subsidiary company (“WOLAHCo”). WOLAHCo will be financed with a mix of senior debt and equity (both provided by the Council). WOLAHCo will utilise such finance in order to acquire existing residential property in the local area in order to subsequently rent on an open market basis. As such the purpose of this briefing note seeks to address two points: the pricing of the senior debt loan from the Council to WOLAHCo; and an appropriate gearing level for WOLAHCo.
Council loan to WOLAHCo; interest rate pricing
Whilst the pricing of a loan from the Council to WOLAHCo would be a matter of understanding the financial viability (or otherwise) of WOLAHCo and the returns required by the Council, it is usual to consider the state aid position in terms of pricing the loan. In broad terms the European Commission makes use of a reference rate (“Rate”) as a proxy for a market rate in order to measure whether any state aid has been granted. The Rate is determined by summing the results of the following components:
Base rate; currently 1.04%; and
Margin. The margin is a function of the credit rating and the collateral offered by WOLAHCo and determined by the use of the table shown below. (The values shown in the table are expressed in basis points, i.e. 1 basis point equals 0.1%). Based on our current understanding of WOLAHCo then we would infer that WOLAHCo has a “Bad” rating and “High” collateralisation level.
The “Bad” rating is based on the limited / non-existent trading history of WOLAHCo and the “High” collateralisation assumes the Council will take a first fixed charge over the WOLAHCo’s properties and such properties have been fairly valued prior to WOLAHCo’s acquisition of said properties. As such the Margin, in our view, would be 400 basis points, i.e. 4.00%.
Rating Collateralisation High Medium Low Strong 60 75 100 Good 75 100 220 Satisfactory 100 220 400 Weak 220 400 650 Bad 400 650 1,000
Taking both components it would appear that an interest rate of 5.04% charged by the Council on its loan to WOLAHCo would be the minimum pricing required to protect the Council from a state aid challenge. Given that state aid is a legal issue the Council should seek further advice from its legal advisors to confirm its position on this matter before proceeding further. WOLAHCo gearing
To a greater extent than interest rate pricing, the gearing (which we define for the purposes of this note as the proportion of debt to total capital employed) of WOLAHCo will influence its financial viability position. The gearing level is another area where state aid considerations are relevant, i.e. is WOLAHCo over geared as compared to a market participant. WOLAHCo’s operations are centred on the private rented sector market, which is an emerging business model. As a consequence there are few publicly available benchmarks to consider the capital structure of a market entity operating solely in the private rent market.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.