CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Guildford Borough Council
Executive, Tuesday 22 October 2019 at 7.00pm

Replacement of Dial a Ride Mini Buses

Approved Executive 1 paper

Executive approved this item on Tuesday 22 October 2019. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

ItemEX50

Resolved

(1) That Option 1 – the proposed purchase of ten new electric Mini Buses for the Dial-A-Ride service – be approved. (2) That the transfer of £820,000 from the provisional to the approved capital programme, be approved. Reasons: To ensure an up to date and reliable fleet for this service and reduce the Council’s vehicle emissions. Alternative options considered and rejected by the Executive: Option 2 - replace current fleet of buses with new Diesel vehicles Option 3 - delay replacement of the fleet for 2-3 years Details of any conflict of interest declared by the Leader or lead councillors and any dispensation granted: None
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting. Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Guildford's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive

Executive summary

The Council’s Dial a Ride (DAR) mini buses are approaching five years of age and the Community Care Service has asked us to review replacement options. We have looked at three options:

1. Replace with a new electric fleet 2. Replace “like for like” 3. Delay replacement of the fleet for 2-3 years

The conclusion reached is that electric vehicles provide a beneficial environmental solution at an affordable financial cost.

Recommendation to Executive

(1) That Option 1 – the proposed purchase of ten new electric Mini Buses for the DAR service – be approved.

(2) That the transfer of £820,000 from the provisional to the approved capital programme, be approved.

Reasons for Recommendation: To ensure an up to date and reliable fleet for this service and reduce the Council’s vehicle emissions.

Purpose of report

1.1To provide the Executive with the information necessary for it to review the options available in relation to the replacement of the Council’s DAR fleet.

2. Strategic Priorities

2.1This proposal contributes towards a sustainable local environment by the use of non- polluting electric vehicles for one of the Council’s front-line services. We calculate there will be a reduction of CO2 emissions from fuel of 52,400kg per year (or 366,800kg CO2 over the life of the vehicles). There would be an improvement in air quality and a positive impact on the Council’s reputation.

3. Background and Issues

3.1The ten DAR minibuses are approaching five years of age and this is the earliest point we would consider replacement. At five years, in good condition, we would expect a high resale value. After this time reliability and value will decline.

3.2The Service would like to introduce fully electric vehicles. Following market research, we have identified new electric vehicles that we believe could replace the current diesel-powered vehicles. The procurement and build process would take approximately one year.

3.3Diesel vehicles are cheaper to purchase but electric vehicles are cheaper to run. The cost of a new diesel minibus is approximately £50,000 compared to an electric minibus at approximately £79,000. There is a further cost of £30,000 required to be spent on charging infrastructure. In total, a fleet of ten DAR vehicles with charging infrastructure would cost an additional £320,000 to purchase.

3.4However, when the cost of fuel and servicing for the diesel variant over the life of the vehicle is taken into account, the cost difference reduces significantly. For example, at an annual mileage of 13,000 miles, a diesel-powered vehicle would cost £2,400 to fuel. An equivalent electric powered vehicle would cost £400 to cover the same distance. This saving of £2,000 per vehicle, per year plus other savings on road tax, servicing and maintenance means that the operating cost of an electric fleet will be around £187,000 less over a seven-year life. This produces a net additional cost of £133,000 over a 7-year life (£1,900 per vehicle per year).

The calculations are set out in table 1 below:

Table 1 – comparison of diesel versus electric DAR minibus replacement

Option 1 (Electric) Option 2 (Diesel) £ £ Purchase cost 790,000 500,000 Fuel 28,000 168,000 Infrastructure 30,000 Nil Servicing 5,000 30,000 Road fund licence Nil 22,000 Total Over 7 Years 853,000 720,000 Additional cost per year £19,000 or £1,900 per of electric fleet vehicle

3.5The average daily mileage of our minibuses is 50 miles, which means we would not need to charge the buses every day. This, along with multiple charging options available on the Council’s property estate means the risk of services being affected by loss of power is low. 4. Consultations

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Replacement of Dial a Ride Mini BusesReport 222 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

8 of 20 attended
CR
Councillor Caroline ReevesChairperson, present
FW
Councillor Fiona WhiteVice-Chairperson, present
JB
Councillor Joss BigmoreCommittee Member, apologies
AG
Councillor Angela GoodwinCommittee Member, present
DG
Councillor David GoodwinCommittee Member, present
JH
Councillor Jan HarwoodCommittee Member, present
JM
Councillor Julia McShaneCommittee Member, apologies
JR
Councillor John RiggCommittee Member, present
PS
Councillor Pauline SearleCommittee Member, present
JS
Councillor James SteelCommittee Member, present
TA
Councillor Tim AndersonCommittee Member, in attendance
AG
Councillor Angela GunningCommittee Member, in attendance

All 20 on the meeting page

More from Guildford Executive

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
17 Sep 2026 MinutesThe minutes of the meeting held on 20 August 2026 were confirmed. The Leader signed the minutes. : The minutes of the... Decided Open
17 Sep 2026 Delivery Plan Progress Report 2025/26 - 2026/27To note the summary of the actions delivered from the 2025/26 Delivery Plan and the progress made in Q1 and Q2 toward... Noted Open
17 Sep 2026 Scrutiny Review of the Council’s Heritage Service and Tourist Information CentreTo develop the strategic direction within the report at Appendix 1 into a fuller strategy for the Heritage Service, i... Approved Open
17 Sep 2026 Homelessness Review DecisionsApprove the contracting out of the Council’s statutory homelessness review function under section 202 of the Housing ... Approved Open
17 Sep 2026 GBC New Build Housing Development - Hurdle RatesTo adopt the proposed hurdle rate framework for affordable housing development schemes across the Borough as an indic... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies