(1) That the key findings in the report submitted to the Executive be noted. (2) That the options in section 6 of the report be implemented. Reason: To better control costs and provide a more robust governance approach to spend in this area. Other options considered and rejected by the Executive: None. Details of any conflict of interest declared by the Leader or lead councillors and any dispensation granted: None
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
This report outlines the extent, nature, and spend on Consultants and Agency workers within the Council over the last five years and notes some key findings.
Over the last five years the Council has spent a combined total of £36.5 million on Agency Workers and Consultants across revenue and capital.
Of that spend, £24.5 million was on Consultants and £11.97 million was on Agency Workers.
Recommendation to Committee
To note the key findings and options for the Executive to consider.
Reason for recommendation
It is recommended that the Executive consider the options outlined in order to better control costs and provide a more robust governance approach to this spend area.
Is the report (or part of it) exempt from publication?
No
Purpose of report
1.1For the Executive to understand the extent, nature, and spend on Consultants and Agency Workers over the last five years.
1 2. Strategic Priorities
2.1Consultants and Agency staff comprise key resource to deliver projects and programmes across the organisation, supporting all of the Councils Strategic Framework; placemaking, community and innovation. Both consultants and agency staff are brought where there is a lack of capacity (resource gap) or capability (skills gap).
2.2Consultants in the Corporate Programmes work area in particular are delivering placemaking objectives.
Background
3.1For the purposes of this report, Consultants have been defined as ‘engaged by the Council to deliver a specific piece of work’. Agency workers have been defined as ‘working to cover a substantive post or ongoing post within the organisation’.
3.2Consultants are generally engaged on an ad-hoc basis across the organisation without a formal governance process in place and/or a Procurement process. Consultants are engaged for one off pieces of work and to deliver large scale capital projects on an on-going basis. There can be a lack of knowledge transfer occurring when consultants working on major schemes within the Council move on to another assignment outside the organisation.
3.3Agency Workers There is currently a contract in place with Comensura for the provision of agency workers. This has been in place for the five year period that this spend report relates to. The contract was re-procured in late 2019 via the ESPO Framework MSTAR 3 so that the Council can continue to engage Comensura for the provision of agency workers.
3.4Part of the re-Tender review conducted by Procurement identified that there is an issue with off contract spend (i.e. spend not via the Comensura contract) across the organisation where Hiring Managers are going off contract to obtain the workers they require. This is sometimes due to the inability to source quality professional service staff through the Comensura agreement but not always. There has been a pattern of engaging other recruitment agencies in the absence of ascertaining whether the main contract can supply the worker in question. Going off contract in this nature can expose the Council to inflated margins and risk where no Terms and Conditions are in place.
4. Consultations
4.1This report was considered by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee on Tuesday 20 October 2020 and the outcomes were: (I) That the Executive and the Corporate Management Team be requested to consider the options to better control costs and provide a more robust governance approach to spend on consultants and agency workers as outlined in the report submitted to the Committee; and
2 (II) That the Committee be provided with an interim update on consultants and agency worker spend in six months’ time and with a full report of progress achieved in this spend area in one year.
5. Spend on Consultants and Agency Workers
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.