(1) To note that the legal research undertaken concludes that the Council does not own the tow path, Weir, or bridge, and neither does the Council have any obligations to maintain the assets. (2) To progress with “Option 1” a s outlined in S ection 10 of the report submitted to the Executive . (3) To communicate publicly the Council’s rationale for progressing with “Option 1”. (4) To continue to be available to engage with the National Trust or other Parties should other currently unknown options become available. Reason: The Council was receiving continued public criticism and is facing pressure to provide a permanent solution to the collapsed Tumbling Bay Weir and footbridge. A decision was required from Executive to provide clarity on the level of the Council’s ongoing involvement in this matter. Other options considered and rejected by the Executive: · OPTION 2: The Council makes a one off limited financial contribution of £tbc to another organisation leading the work and taking ongoing responsibility, likely to be the National Trust. · OPTION 3: The Council takes a more active role in the project. In order to do this, the Council would need to recruit a suitable project manager to take the lead in coordinating a collective agreement on next steps with key stakeholders over the next 6 months. This option incurs an initial £50,000 revenue cost and £000’s in contributions this and future years. This will be growth in the MTFP and savings will need to be found to cover this cost. · OPTION 4: Assume full legal responsibility for the Tumbling Bay Weir and agree a transfer of the land and Weir to Guildford Borough Council ownership. Details of any conflict of interest declared by the Leader or lead councillors and any dispensation granted: None.
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
Brief Description of Mandate Consideration of options relating to the Tumbling Bay Weir which collapsed in 2019 and was replaced with a temporary weir (which has a limited lifespan of 5 – 10 years) by National Trust and GBC. Overall Status Not yet commenced
Estimated Start Date August 2022
Estimated End Date August 2023
Priority Matrix Score
Mandate Reference Number PR000849
Ownership
Mandate Owner Abi Lewis
Directorate Strategic Services
Service Area Regeneration & Corporate Programmes
Service Team Capital, Transport & Infrastructure
Project Manager Yet to be appointed
Programme, Sub-Portfolio, or Project Project Mandate -
Compelling Case for Change Why do we need to undertake The Tumbling Bay Weir collapsed in November 2019 and the Council agreed with this project? National Trust at the time to share the costs of installing a temporary structure to restore water flow in the Navigation. Ownership and liability for replacing the Weir is currently not established. The footpath remains closed, and the Council (and National Trust) continue to face significant public pressure to restore public access, as well as installing a permanent Weir.
Key Deliverables Key Deliverable Description Period Status
To be defined by CMB & Permanent Weir? New footbridge? Fish pass Executive Liaison installation?
Success Criteria
Success Criterion Description Status
To be defined by CMB & Reputationally it would be a success for this issue to Executive Liaison be resolved at zero or minimum cost to the Council. That another organisation takes full ownership and responsibility for the Weir and footbridge.
Strategic Objectives
This work does not target any of the Council’s core strategic objectives but could loosely link to: Strategic Objectives Protecting our environment - Make every effort to (Corporate Plan) protect and enhance our biodiversity and natural environment Mandate -
Project Categorisation and Ranking
Question Provide a Ranking for this Project Score
Health & Safety 0 - N/A - No health or safety concerns 0
Physical Security 0 - N/A 0
Cyber Security 0 - N/A 0
Keep the Lights On (KTLO) 0 - N/A - Or works to services we plan to stop 0
Regulatory Compliance 0 - N/A 0
Net Present Value (NPV) 0 - None - Negative NPV 0
Quality Assurance 0 - N/A 0
IT Application Project 0 - N/A 0
Homes and Jobs: Residents 0 - N/A 0 having access to the homes and jobs they need
Community: Empowering 0 – N/A 0 communities and supporting people who need help
Improved GBC 0 - N/A 0
Project Categorisation and Ranking Aggregation
Project Categorisation and Ranking Total (Priority Matrix Score) 10 Mandate -
Impact Assessment
Are the anticipated outputs Millmead Weir replacement (EA led scheme) which Parks & Countryside team is from this project going to involved impact on other projects
List Services or Projects Parks & Countryside Impacted
Impact Assessments Required Equality IA Privacy IA Business IA Environmental IA Climate Change IA
Yes N/A N/A Yes N/A
Impact Assessment Further Information & Links
Impact Assessment Not completed at this stage but will need to be developed. Information & Links
Waverley Collaboration Considerations What does Waverley currently N/A do to provide this service
What discussion has been had None to date but could be an opportunity to discuss whether Waverley has “spare” with Waverley about this project management resource to support the progression of any actions relating to this mandate mandate.
What opportunities are there None – not relevant as one-off, location specific project for savings through the collaboration Mandate -
Strategic Benefits
Estimated Financial Benefits
Financial Benefits
Item N/A
Description N/A
Benefit Type N/A
Estimated Value of Benefit N/A
Key Financial Benefit N/A
Owners N/A
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.