Agreed to purchase the long leasehold interest of 42 Round Hill Way for £262,000 and enter into a settlement agreement. Reason(s): The Council already have an obligation for the structural repairs to the property and as such has a liability in relation to this property as it suffers from significant structural defects. To take ownership of the property will enable the property to be put back to the most appropriate use within the HRA. Other options considered and rejected by the Executive: Do not purchase property – legal action has been threatened which brings high risk of substantial damages for disrepair and legal costs, a court order requiring the Council to carry out the works of repair, and damage to reputation. Do the Works – doing the works will not remove the risk of a claim in damages for historical losses suffered by the leaseholder and will mean that the property remains in private ownership. Details of any conflict of interest declared by the Leader or lead councillors and any dispensation granted: None.
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
3.1The Council already have an obligation for the structural repairs to the property and as such has a liability in relation to this property as it suffers from significant structural defects.
SS / J-SCS-065 / 00945327 / Version : Page 1 3.2 To take ownership of the property will enable the property to be put back to the most appropriate use within the HRA.
4.0Status of Report
The report is open.
5.0Strategic Priorities
5.1The purchase of the property would contribute to the Council’s strategic priorities for a more sustainable borough and decent and affordable homes.
Background
6.1The property is a one-bedroom ground floor flat with front and rear garden, held under a lease with 90 years remaining. The Council are the freehold owner and under the terms of the lease remain responsible for the structural repairs.
6.2This property was purchased under the Right to Buy on 21 December 1998 and then later sold privately in October 2009.
6.3The property is suffering from significant structural issues, there is known land subsidence in the immediate area.
6.4The leaseholder does not live in the property but holds it as an investment property. Due to the structural defects the flat is currently not suitable for the leaseholder to sublet or sell at a reasonable price on the open market in its current state of disrepair.
6.5The Council own the flat above, which is vacant and has been void since 22 June 2022.
6.6The property has been valued by Clarke Gammon Weller, in its current state at £150,000 and should the extensive structural repairs for which the Council are responsible be carried out, at £240,000. As the Council is responsible for maintaining the building and completing the structural works, an offer of £262,000 has been accepted to purchase the
SS / J-SCS-065 / 00945327 / Version : Page 2 property. This offer reflects the Council’s potential liability due to the structural defects and damages should a disrepair claim be made.
6.7The benefit to the Council of purchasing the freehold is that a former council property will have been regained to add to housing stock and a claim for damages will be avoided.
Options
7.1Do not purchase property – legal action has been threatened which brings high risk of substantial damages for disrepair and legal costs, a court order requiring the Council to carry out the works of repair, and damage to reputation.
7.2Do the Works – doing the works will not remove the risk of a claim in damages for historical losses suffered by the leaseholder and will mean that the property remains in private ownership.
7.3Buy the property – the Council gains an asset, legal action is avoided the money that would likely have to be paid in damages and legal costs is instead utilised in the acquisition (using RTB receipts) of a property which can then be put back in to the most appropriate use within the HRA.
Consultation
Not applicable
9.0Key Risks
9.1There is a risk of both reputational damage and legal action if the Council do not purchase the property.
10.0Legal and Governance Implications
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.