21/P/00120/S106/1 - The Barn, The Street, Effingham, Leatherhead, KT24 5LP
ApprovedPlanning1 paper
AI summaryGuildford Planning Committee approved removing the affordable housing requirement from a 15-dwelling Effingham development at The Barn, with delegated authority to vary the Section 106 Agreement.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedAffordable housing requirement removed from site
Money£72,034 S106 allowance in FVACouncil notes actual S106 figures of £114,708
What happens nextAssistant Director of PlanningTo agree the Section 106 variation under delegated authority
Who it affectsThe Barn, Effingham, KT24 5LP15-dwelling scheme, all now market housing
What was decided
Application 21/P/00120/S106/1 was approved, with delegated authority granted to the Assistant Director of Planning to vary the Section 106 Agreement and remove the affordable housing requirement on the site. Report P18
No on-site affordable housing and no off-site commuted sum is required after the variation. Report P17, P79
Why
An independent review by Dixon Searle Partnership found the Financial Viability Assessment satisfactory, concluding the scheme cannot support an affordable housing contribution on present day costs and values. Report P16, P70, P75, P78
The applicant said it could not find a registered provider partner; only one response was received, and Hyde Housing said it only acquires sites of 100 units or more. Report P5, P7, P56
The Housing Strategy and Enabling Manager, Effingham Parish Council and Effingham Residents Association all objected, citing local need and questioning the viability case. Report P39, P42, P46, P47
What happens next
The Assistant Director of Planning will finalise and sign the deed of variation to the Section 106 dated 30 April 2024, removing the obligation to provide 6 affordable homes. Report P18, P23, P28
The money
£3,267,000 Benchmark Land Value submitted by applicant in FVA Report P71
£2,750,000 Benchmark Land Value used by DSP in independent testing Report P74
£2,121,550 Residual land value for the 100% market scheme as submitted Report P71
-£1,145,450 Deficit versus the applicant's assumed benchmark land value Report P71
9.0% Actual profit on GDV after the deficit, per DSP Report P71
£72,034 S106 allowance used in the submitted FVA Report P74
£114,708 Total S106 figures the Council says are actually in the agreement Report P74
£67,819 Legal fees on residential sales submitted in the FVA Report P74
£11,250 DSP's adjusted legal fees at £750 per dwelling for 15 units Report P74
£72,000 Total Section 106 contribution cited by EFFRA Report P47
£67,034 Education contribution to Surrey County Council Report P47
Chosen: Approve the variation and remove the affordable housing requirement. Independent FVA review found the scheme cannot viably support affordable housing on current costs and values Report P16, P17, P78
Rejected: Refuse and require affordable housing or a commuted sum. Applicant demonstrated no partner can be secured and the scheme shows a deficit even with DSP's adjusted assumptions Report P5, P7, P65, P75
Rejected: Require a commuted sum for local community benefit instead of on-site affordable units. Viability evidence accepted; no off-site contribution is being required Report P43, P47, P79
Implications
Financial: Developer will deliver 15 market homes with no affordable housing obligation and no off-site commuted sum; remaining S106 payments for education and highways are unchanged. Report P17, P47, P79
Equalities: Housing register shows 2,468 households in need of affordable housing, including some with a local connection to Effingham, and the site lies in a Designated Protected Area. Report P39
Legal: A deed of variation to the existing Section 106 Agreement (dated 30 April 2024) is required, with delegated authority to the Assistant Director of Planning to agree the wording. Report P18, P23
Risk: DSP noted the developer is relying on market improvement and value engineering; the review applies only to the scheme as submitted and current values. Report P75
Who and where
Future residents of the 15-dwelling scheme at The Barn, Effingham (all market housing) Report P8, P21, P23
Households on the Council's housing register, including those with a local connection to Effingham Report P39
Residents of Effingham and surrounding villages Report P39, P42, P46
Surrey County Council as recipient of the education contribution Report P47
The applicant, St Edmunds Developments Report P14, P69
Timeline
2021: Original planning application submitted and searches for affordable housing partners began Report P7, P56
30 April 2024: Section 106 Agreement completed, securing 6 affordable units of the 15 approved Report P23, P24, P28
1 May 2024: Planning permission 21/P/00120 granted Report P11, P35
August 2024: Applicant sought advice from Guildford Borough Council on finding a way forward Report P7, P56
April 2025: Financial Viability Assessment submitted by DS2 LLP on behalf of the applicant Report P14, P69
2026-01-07: Planning Committee approves the S106 variation with delegated authority to the Assistant Director of Planning
Plain English for the jargon
Section 106 Agreement: A legal agreement between a developer and a local planning authority used to secure planning obligations such as affordable housing.
Deed of Variation: A legal document that changes the terms of an existing agreement, in this case the Section 106.
Financial Viability Assessment (FVA): An appraisal of whether a proposed development can support its policy costs, such as affordable housing, at current values and build costs.
Benchmark Land Value (BLV): The minimum land value a reasonable landowner would accept, used as a test in viability appraisals.
Designated Protected Area (DPA): A rural area designation under national policy where affordable housing protections apply because of limited local housing markets and constrained land supply.
Residual land value: The amount left for the landowner after deducting build costs, profit, fees and policy contributions from the scheme's total value.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemPL87
Resolved
That application 21/P/00120/S106/1 be approved, with delegated authority granted to the Assistant Director of Planning to agree to the variation of the Section 106 Agreement to allow for the removal of the requirement for affordable housing provision on the site.
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
This application has been referred to the Planning Committee by the Joint Assistant Director of Planning because there would be a variation to the approved affordable housing provision.
Key information
Planning permission was granted in 2024 (application ref: 21/P/00120) for the proposed conversion of the existing dwelling on the site to three dwellings and the erection of 12 new dwellings together with associated garaging, access and landscaping. This planning permission has not yet been implemented. Of the 15 units approved, 6 units (40%) were proposed to be affordable units, as secured by the S106 agreement attached to 21/P/00120.
As outlined above, this application seeks to vary the legal agreement to remove the requirement for any affordable housing provision. The application states that it has not been possible to find an affordable housing partner for the proposed development and that the viability of the scherm has changed and its is no longer viable to provide affordable housing within the development
The supporting statement submitted with the application states:
• Affordable housing partners were sought when the scheme was first submitted to the local planning authority in 2021 and attempts to contact potential providers has continued, including Abri, Aster, Hyde Housing and Clarion Housing Association. • Only a single recent response has been received to the enquiries and therefore Guildford Borough Council (GBC) advice was sought in August 2024 to find a way forward to deliver the much needed housing. • The recent reply from Hyde Housing states: “I’m afraid this would not be of interest as we are currently only acquiring sites of 100 units plus and would only acquire s106 units where they come with additional units that can be converted to affordable using grant.” • A Financial Viability Assessment of the Proposed Development illustrates that the scheme cannot support an affordable housing contribution in lieu of obtaining an affordable housing partner. • It is therefore submitted that, in light of the national housing crisis, it is more important to deliver a scheme of fully market housing, which will contribute towards the five year housing land supply, than to lose the opportunity to deliver considered and attractively designed housing on a suitable site such as this.
The proposed amendment would result in the delivery of a fully market housing scheme.
Summary of considerations and constraints
As the proposed development proposes 15 units and is also located within Effingham which is a 'Designated Rural Area', affordable housing provision was required under the original planning application (21/P/00120) in line with Policy H2(2) and H2(3) and this provision was secured by way of the agreed S106 Agreement.
There has been no change in the policy requirements relating to affordable housing provision since the permission was granted and the S106 agreement completed on 1 May 2024.
However, as noted above, the applicant has been unable to find an affordable housing partner for the development and the overall cost of the scheme has changed which has resulted in a scheme that is no longer viable and therefore will not be delivered in its current form.
The applicant has submitted a full Financial Viability Assessment to demonstrate that this is the case.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.