Resolved
Write off the outstanding debt of £214,332.50 owed to the Council; 2. uphold the Council’s right to pursue a claim at a later date should a UK address for the landowner be identified; and 3. note that the decision to write off the debt is only an internal accounting adjustment and this decision does not preclude the Council from recovering the debt at a later date. Reason(s): 1. The action taken under the planning and environmental protection acts was approved by the Council in 2021. The reports identified the owner of the land was absent and that recovery of debt was unlikely. 2. In 2021 the Council used powers to act in default under Section 79, Environmental Protection Act 1990 and Section 178 Town and Country Planning Act 1990, to clear the land of all temporary living accommodation and structures, vehicles, animals and equipment. 3. The action although costly was not only successful in abating nuisance from smoke, it also resulted in the clearance of all of the unauthorised uses on land with the exception of waste deposits. 4. The responsibility for the enforcement of the waste management regime is within the remits of both Surrey County Council and the Environment Agency. The Council did not clear any deposited waste from the site. 5. Despite the use of a debt recovery agency the recovery of the outstanding debt of £214,332.50, covering the bailiff and removal fees, has not shown any progress over the last 3 years. 6. The Council used a debt recovery company who reported that they had no success in locating the owner. Whilst communication was received from the owner’s son, he had no formal interest in the land and denied any responsibility for the costs. 7. The seizure of the land in light of the debt was not considered prudent due to the restricted planning profile and the potential contamination from waste deposited on this land and the neighbouring area to the west. Other options considered and rejected by the Executive: Option 1 - Request a Charge to be placed on land at the Land Registry, for the value of outstanding debt, providing a legitimate avenue to recover the debt should there be a future sale of any part of the land. Officers consider it unlikely that any sale would generate sufficient revenue to pay a charge to the Council due to the low land value. Option 2 - To pursue the debt with a higher level specialist debt recovery concern, again this is not deemed practical and advised as having a low probablilty of success due to difficulty in tracking down the legitimate land owner, believed to be residing abroad. Option 3 - Seize the land and organise the sale to recover the outstanding debt however, this was also deemed impractical and may not generate sufficient revenue due to the status of the land in terms of planning and remedial costs of remedying existing contamination. Details of any conflict of interest declared by the ... EX5