CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Halton Borough Council
Executive Board, Thursday 18 June 2026

Surplus Primary School Places - Key Decision

Decided Executive 3 papers

AI summaryHalton Executive Board backs public consultation on potential closure, merger or academisation of up to eight Runcorn primary schools, driven by 20.6% surplus capacity.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedBacks closure, merger or academisation consultation for up to eight Runcorn primaries
MoneyNo sums statedLGA advice provided at no cost to the council
What happens nextPublic consultation 30 June to 30 September 2026Further report to Council in Autumn 2026
Who it affectsNot stated

What was decided

The Board supports opening an initial public consultation on the closure, federation or merger, including through academisation, of The Holy Spirit Catholic Primary School, St Edwards Catholic Primary School, Woodside Primary School and Brookvale Primary School. Report P8

The Board will recommend to Wade Deacon Trust that it consult on the closure of Weston Point Community Primary School to enable a merger with Westfield Primary School. Report P9

The Board supports opening an initial six-week public consultation on the closure of Westfield Primary School if the proposed merger with Weston Point Community Primary School does not proceed, and will recommend to The Heath Family Trust that it consult on the closure or merger of Bridgewater Park Primary School and Palacefields Primary Academy. Report P10, P11

Why

Runcorn primary schools have about 20.6% surplus capacity: 6,223 places available against 4,944 pupils on roll as of October 2025, driven by a falling birth rate and declining pupil numbers. Report 1.1, P27, 3.7

Surplus places are creating financial and operational pressures on schools, including reduced funding, staffing challenges, limited curriculum breadth, and four council-maintained primaries have already requested financial support. Report P2, P30

Independent advice from the Local Government Association set out four options, and partners agreed to take Option 4, a system-wide rationalisation of the school estate, as the preferred approach. Report P3, 3.6, 3.8

What happens next

A Surplus Schools Strategic Advisory Board has applied agreed criteria to all Runcorn primaries and shortlisted the eight schools listed for potential closure, merger or academisation. Report 3.9, P33, P34

A six-week public consultation will run from 30th June to 30th September 2026, not including the school summer holidays, with a further report to the Council in Autumn 2026 on whether to publish formal statutory notices. Report 3.14, P5

Any subsequent closures or mergers would be implemented by 31st August 2028, with separate processes led by the relevant Academy Trusts and Diocese where they are the admission authority. Report P74, 3.16, 4.4

Options considered

  • Rejected: No planned action: provide support and react as schools struggle individually Report P25, 3.8
  • Rejected: Actively work to keep all school sites open Report P25, 3.8
  • Rejected: Localise decision making to Runcorn's MATs, Dioceses and individual schools Report P25, 3.8
  • Chosen: Rationalise the school estate with a collaborative plan, including closure of a minimum number of schools to strengthen the system. Agreed by all parties as the strategic, system-wide response to falling rolls and surplus capacity Report P25, 3.8, 3.6

Implications

  • Legal: The Council has a statutory duty under the Education Act 1996 to ensure sufficient and suitable school places; any future closures will follow statutory consultation and notice processes. Report 4.1, 4.3, 3.16
  • Financial: High surplus capacity reduces per-pupil income and limits access to Department for Education capital funding, but rationalisation is expected to improve long-term financial sustainability. Report 5.1, 5.2, 5.3, P20
  • Equalities: An Equality Impact Assessment will be carried out for any proposals taken to statutory notice, covering SEND, disadvantaged children, faith communities and other protected groups. Report 8.1, 8.2, 6.4
  • Climate: Reducing the number of under-occupied buildings is expected to improve energy efficiency and support the Council's carbon reduction commitments. Report 6.5, P58
  • Risk: There is reputational and community risk from school closure proposals, but failure to tackle surplus places poses greater long-term risks of deficits, declining quality and unplanned school failure. Report 7.1, 7.2
  • Staffing: Falling rolls are already leading to staff reductions and loss of curriculum expertise in affected schools, with implications for extracurricular and competitive sport. Report P17, P18, P20
  • Other: Different admission authorities are involved: the Council for community and voluntary controlled schools, Academy Trusts for academies, and Dioceses for voluntary aided schools, so each will lead its own consultation where relevant. Report 3.4, 4.4

Who and where

  • Pupils, parents and staff at the eight shortlisted Runcorn primary schools: Holy Spirit Catholic, St Edwards Catholic, Woodside, Brookvale, Weston Point Community, Westfield, Bridgewater Park and Palacefields Primary Academy Report P8, P9, P10, P11, P34
  • Wider Runcorn primary school community and local residents Report 3.12, 6.6, P60
  • School leaders, diocesan authorities, academy trusts, trade unions and the Children, Young People and Families Policy and Performance Board Report 3.3, 3.6, 3.15

Timeline

  • Summer and Autumn 2025: Council met with school leaders, diocesan representatives and academy trust leaders on falling rolls Report 3.3
  • January 2026: Local Government Association independent report on rationalising Halton primary schools completed Report 3.5, 3.6
  • March 2026: LGA report shared and Surplus Schools Strategic Advisory Board established Report 3.6, 3.9
  • March and April 2026: Surplus Schools Strategic Advisory Board met and agreed assessment criteria Report 3.9, P33
  • May 2026: Advisory Board discussed and analysed assessment results and agreed recommendations Report P34
  • 8th June 2026: Children and Families Policy and Performance Board to scrutinise the process and next steps Report 3.15
  • 18th June 2026: Executive Board decision on the strategic approach and proposed consultations
  • 30th June to 30th September 2026 (six weeks, excluding school summer holidays): Public consultation on the proposed school changes Report 3.14, P5
  • Autumn 2026: Further report to the Council on consultation findings and whether to publish formal statutory notices Report P5, 3.14
  • By 31st August 2028: Final implementation date of any subsequent actions Report P74

Plain English for the jargon

  • Surplus capacity: The difference between the number of school places available and the number of pupils on roll, expressed as a percentage.
  • Federation: Two or more schools that share a single governing body while keeping their individual identities.
  • Academisation: A school converting from local authority or voluntary aided status to become an academy, usually within a multi-academy trust.
  • Admission authority: The body responsible for setting a school's admissions policy: the local authority for community and voluntary controlled schools, the academy trust for academies, and the diocese for voluntary aided schools.
  • Surplus Schools Strategic Advisory Board (SSSAB): A group set up in March 2026 with the Council, school leaders, dioceses and trusts to apply agreed criteria and recommend Runcorn primary schools for consultation on closure, merger or federation.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item5

Resolved

That the Board supports the strategic approach and proposal to: 1) proceed with opening an initial public consultation on the closure, federation or merger, including through academisation, of The Holy Spirit Catholic Primary School, St Edwards Catholic Primary School, Woodside Primary School and Brookvale Primary School; 2) recommend to Wade Deacon Trust to consult upon the closure of Weston Point Community Primary School to enable the merger with Westfield Primary School; 3) proceed with opening an initial 6-week public consultation on the closure of Westfield Primary School if the merger with Weston Point Primary School does not proceed; and 4) recommend to The Heath Family Trust to consult upon the closure or merger of Bridgewater Park Primary School and Palacefields Primary Academy.
Word for word from the decision Halton published for this meeting. Source: moderngov.halton.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Halton's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive Board, 10 pages

Executive summary

1.1Halton Borough Council is facing significant and sustained surplus primary school capacity in Runcorn, driven primarily by a declining birth rate and falling pupil numbers. As of October 2025, there are 6,223 primary school places available compared to 4,944 pupils on roll, equating to approximately 20.6% surplus capacity across the town.

This level of surplus is creating increasing financial and operational pressures on schools, including reduced funding, staffing challenges, limited curriculum breadth, and difficulties maintaining buildings and resources. In some cases, this is already leading to budget deficits and risks to long-term viability.

Following engagement with school leaders, dioceses and academy trusts, and informed by independent advice commissioned from the Local Government Association, the Council has determined that a strategic, system-wide response is required. The LGA offered four options (detailed later in this report), and Option 4—rationalising the school estate to create a more sustainable and high-quality education system—has been agreed as the preferred approach.

A Surplus Schools Strategic Advisory Board has applied an agreed set of criteria that are clear, fair and objective, to assess all Runcorn primary schools and identify those where viability is in question. As a result, a number of schools have been identified for potential closure, merger or amalgamation (including through academisation), with the intention of strengthening the overall system rather than managing decline on a school-by-school basis.

The report seeks approval to commence a public consultation (July-September 2026) on these proposals. Feedback will inform a further report to the Council in Autumn 2026, at which point decisions will be made on whether to proceed to formal statutory notices.

Overall, the proposed approach aims to ensure a sustainable, high-quality and financially viable education system in Runcorn, while fulfilling the Council’s statutory duty to provide sufficient and appropriate school places and carefully managing the impact on local communities.

2.0RECOMMENDED: That the Board supports the strategic approach and proposal to:

 Proceed with opening an initial public consultation on the closure, federation or merger, including through academisation, of The Holy Spirit Catholic Primary School, St Edwards Catholic Primary School, Woodside Primary School and Brookvale Primary School.

 Recommend to Wade Deacon Trust to consult upon the closure of Weston Point Community Primary School to enable the merger with Westfield Primary School.

 Proceed with opening an initial 6 week public consultation on the closure of Westfield Primary School if the merger with Weston Point Primary School does not proceed.

 Recommend to The Heath Family Trust to consult upon the closure or merger of Bridgewater Park Primary School and Palacefields Primary Academy.

3.0SUPPORTING INFORMATION

3.1Like many local authorities across the country, Halton continues to face a number of significant and interrelated challenges, including increasing levels of Special Educational Needs, pressures on public sector resources, rising demand for services, persistent and in some cases deepening disadvantage, and a declining birth rate. At the same time, sustained efforts by the Council and its partners are contributing to improvements in some areas, including educational attainment. However, despite this progress, underlying risks remain. The impact of falling pupil numbers is particularly being felt in primary schools in Runcorn.

3.2The falling birth rate in Runcorn, together with consideration for the per pupil funding formula for schools means that some schools are facing a significant income loss as their numbers on roll decrease year on year.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
FinalAppendix 1 1 pages Download
PDF
Timeline, 26/05/2026 Management TeamAppendix 2 1 pages Download
PDF
Surplus Primary School Places: Key DecisionDecisions 10 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

8 of 13 attended
MW
Councillor Mike WhartonChair, present
AB
Councillor Angela BallMember, present
ED
Councillor Eddie DourleyMember, present
RL
Councillor Rosie LeckMember, present
TM
Councillor Tom McInerneyMember, present
PN
Councillor Paul NolanMember, present
DT
Councillor Dave ThompsonMember, present
AW
Councillor Andrea WallMember, present
MR
Mark ReaneyOfficer, expected
ED
Ed DawsonOfficer, expected
TG
Tim GibbsOfficer, expected
ZF
Zoe FearonOfficer, expected

All 13 on the meeting page

More from Halton Executive Board

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
22 Oct 2026 Halton Housing Trust Annual ReportThe Board thanked Halton Housing for the presentation and noted the report. Noted Open
22 Oct 2026 Highway Asset Management Plan (HAMP)That 1) approves the Highway Asset Management Plan (HAMP) 2026-2029 (contained in Appendix A) for adoption and public... Approved Open
22 Oct 2026 Waste Management and Recycling Contract - Key DecisionThat 1) Members approve the continued delegation of defined elements of the Council’s Waste Disposal Authority functi... Approved Open
22 Oct 2026 Waste Strategy and Household Waste Collection PolicyThat 1) Members approve the draft Waste Management Strategy and the draft Household Waste & Recycling Collection Poli... Approved Open
22 Oct 2026 Specialist DA Therapeutic Support for Children: Request for Waiver of Standing OrdersThat the Board 1) are advised of the Domestic Abuse Board mapping work of the domestic abuse system and support offer... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies